WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Thinlómien]

I said I'm only willing to consider Shasta.

Your case on Eönwë was useless. You know it. You didn't even have the guts to admit it.

What do we have in Gwath? Someone who will be modfired soon most likelily.

And me? You think I as a mutineer would stay all night to see a certain innocent lynched when there are so many to choose from? I'm not that crazy. I'd go now and let you lynch someone innocent or already dead. I would have gone hours ago, with lots of noise that you should lynch Mac and left it be.

[Thinlómien]

I'm going to sleep for an hour now but I'll be back then (some two hours before the deadline). Don't do anything stupid while I'm gone. Please.

[Boromir88]

This Lommy crusade is getting really scary...I've never seen it before, and really Lommy what are you trying to prove from going all out Mac? If he's a wolf you'll get full credit. This type of attack is beyond both being innocent, one is a wolf, or it's as Shasta says both are wolves.

Mac, anyone can think up names of who they protected, and reasons why. Did you leave any hints/clues from previous days, as Rikae did? It of course that isn't required from any gifted, but I'm usually pretty decent at picking up hints (or at least they are hints in my mind! ) and it would help your claim if you did leave any.

[Macalaure]

Ah, I forgot your defense of Eonwe. You worked really hard to scrape the bottom of the barrel there. Respect.

Originally Posted by Lommy

I like the fact that he brought Inzy to spotlight and said he had been ignored by everyone yesterDay, even though his vote was a wasted one.

"Being under radar" is the only justification he ever gave to his votes (except on Day1 and with me today). And Inziladun was definitely not ignored by everyone. If Eonwe's vote had been valid, I would have joined him over voting Kath in a second.

Originally Posted by Lommy

A very good point, if I may say (although I disagree).

Indeed, and a very good hint for the cobblers. Seems like you should have read my case before defending him.


Yes, he did make a few statements about different possibilities, most obvious or misleading, but the "under radar" points right before his votes are the only times he actually shared his thoughts on others. We are severely challenged to gather information and find connections between people. Eonwe intentionally makes it impossible to evaluate him.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Lommy

I said I'm only willing to consider Shasta.

Thus he must be innocent. Not my first choice.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Your case on Eönwë was useless. You know it. You didn't even have the guts to admit it.

Courtesy, please, ok?

Originally Posted by Lommy

And me? You think I as a mutineer would stay all night to see a certain innocent lynched when there are so many to choose from?

Staying up all night just so you won't have to deal with me one more day is more believable, that's true... wait

Originally Posted by Boro

Did you leave any hints/clues from previous days, as Rikae did?

I'm afraid no. I suck at hints and usually end up revealed right away if I try. *recalls last game as cobbler...*

If nobody is willing to believe me, whatever...

[Boromir88]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

If nobody is willing to believe me, whatever...

Since I can I'm going to catch up on the reading...I don't think I've thoroughly read anything past page 19 or something. I remember you mentioning you would not spend the day defending yourself, and would try to step up your game, let's see.

All I can guarantee you Mac, is since Nogrod hasn't riled me up and Lommy had this morning, but it's cool now, I'm in a clear mood right now. A good mood to actually read something openly, without any pre-judgements. (hmm maybe it was the recent ice cream I had...it was milky delicious and ice cream has a tendancy of making me CCC - cool, calm, collected. ).

So, you will just have to settle for that at the time being

[Boromir88]

Lommy.

Originally Posted by Boromir88

This Lommy crusade is getting really scary...I've never seen it before, and really Lommy what are you trying to prove from going all out Mac? If he's a wolf you'll get full credit.

Basically I've never seen this kind of play from you before, so I can't tell whether you're an innocent or wolf...and want to know why you're changing up your game significantly?

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Lommy.
Basically I've never seen this kind of play from you before, so I can't tell whether you're an innocent or wolf...and want to know why you're changing up your game significantly?

It wasn't a conscious decision. I just decided to stick to a decision for once. It may be even partly the fault of your psychologising but I decided I have to trust my judgement (well, and Rikae's) and I must have him dead before he kills us all. I confess I've acted more confident than I've been at times, but that ranger claim really was the last nail to Mac's coffin. Others have proven it's inconsistent, I will only say I was expecting it all along, I'd knew he'd try it so when he did I knew I had been right all along.


edit: xed with the three i's

[Thinlómien]

It's 6am so my brain is a little porrdigy, I just realised I phrased that rather self-contradictingly. I just mean I never thought "ha, I'll be aggressive this time" but rather as the game went on I was like "I'm not stopping suspecting Mac just because others don't suspect him".

edit: xed with Boro - Nog has a point there, he's merely saying that a real ranger would have told us not to lynch him because he'll die anyway and he asked if Mac has done this and he hasn't

[Inziladun]

I have to go to bed myself. Let's see what the morning brings.
Vote well, shipmates. For what its worth, right or wrong, mine would probably be for Mac.

[Boromir88]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

It wasn't a conscious decision. I just decided to stick to a decision for once. It may be even partly the fault of your psychologising but I decided I have to trust my judgement (well, and Rikae's) and I must have him dead before he kills us all. I confess I've acted more confident than I've been at times, but that ranger claim really was the last nail to Mac's coffin. Others have proven it's inconsistent, I will only say I was expecting it all along, I'd knew he'd try it so when he did I knew I had been right all along.

Sure just go ahead and blame me for it...

I was going to add this, but decided not to until you answered, because if you were a wolf I didn't want to just feed an answer to you.

I remember too when you returned, I said you looked really innocent based on one of your flip-floppy posts and that's when I started my tp treatment, or psychoanalyzing. Anyway, I woud have imagined wolf-Lommy would have kept up that performance if it was making you feel innocent.

Doesn't mean you aren't a cobbler-Lommy now though who is trying to protect a wolf by causing such a stir about Mac...hmm but would cobbler-Lommy be up this late and going off a few hours of sleep? Probably not.