Tol-in-Gaurhoth LXIII: The Cottage of Lost Play

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by Rikae

No, it isn't, and your grasping at straws to paint me as suspicious doesn't make you look any better.

I was not saying you're suspicious, just that it seemed like a contradiction and I was wondering which one you were going to go with. The contradiction makes you look more innocent, because I think a wolf would be much more careful with what they wrote.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Eönwë: Why did you voted for Inzil yesterDay and why did you decide to rather let a triple-lynch to take place?"

Haven't I explained this? I thought that the votes had already been counted, as it was already one minute after the deadline for voting, so then I just removed my vote (as is the procedure for votes after the deadline). I did not realise that it could have counted until it was too late.

[Nogrod]

"As you seem to be awake Eönwë, what is your take on Autume and Nessa?"

[Nogrod]

"And..." Nogrod continued, "what would you say to those who say you were having something going on with Inzil back there?"

[Nogrod]

"I don't know if this is for good or bad to Autume, but I do think her last speech was a bit awkward indeed - well it doesn't help me to decide anyway.

I mean she decided to pick from McCaber's posting the thing considering Nessa as the "revealement" of a seer while I'd say Nerwen or I would be much more logical outcomes - and neither of us being actually released by his comments in any believable fashion either (there was this "which group do you think you belong Nerwen" -stuff and that "I'd say he's clean" for me. But as I said that's not something we could count for as a seer dream revealed).

Then her jumping on Lalaith seems like a desperate attempt as I have argued already that Lalaith's vote on Day1 most clearly shows she's not in a team with Fea. I may be wrong and she might be that cunning - but the place for that kind of arguments is toMorrow or the Day after that. Not now.

Also the odd way she tried in the end to bring also Eönwë into the suspicious-list looks quite far-fetched.

But if she's just trying to get herself into this then it might be undertandable. Bah, I don't know..."


Votes thus far...

Lalaith -> Autume
Rikae -> Eönwë
Nerwen -> Autume 2

I would like to hear your thoughts on Nessa especially, but of everyone you who have not yet voted - and to hear from Nessa as well - before voting.

[Nessa Telrunya]

Well, my vote against Fea wasn't necessarily a retaliation. Like many others had already said, Fea had a wolfish feel to her, so I was going on that. Hope that clears things up.

And, due to earlier conclusions, I'm not too trusting of Eonwe. soo...


++Eonwe

[autume98]

What do you make of McCaber thinking Nessa was innocent?

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by autume98

What do you make of McCaber thinking Nessa was innocent?

Well that was circumstantial, not "reveal"-like. Seers have their opinions based on the actions and they have their knowledge based on the dreams they have. We need to be able to make a difference between the two as the first is just as fallible as our thoughts are, but the second is fact.

Sadly McCaber never left us a clear trail as to what he actually knew...

[autume98]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Well that was circumstantial, not "reveal"-like. Seers have their opinions based on the actions and they have their knowledge based on the dreams they have. We need to be able to make a difference between the two as the first is just as fallible as our thoughts are, but the second is fact.

Sadly McCaber never left us a clear trail as to what he actually knew...

Which means that Nessa could've done a wolf on wolf vote...

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by autume98

Which means that Nessa could've done a wolf on wolf vote...

Exactly... And that's what I've been afraid for the last hours...