TIG LXIX: Meeting at the House of Usher

[Roa_Aoife]

Originally Posted by The Saucepan Man

The mischief was in sowing the seed of doubt, as evidenced by the fact that Brinniel and others picked up on it, and the fact that we are still discussing the issue now.

Well, given that my misunderstanding about the 'friendly Wolf' appears to have given rise to no small amount of suspicion and now one vote, I hardly think that I am being overly-defensive. I am merely trying to point out the ludicrous nature of the basis for such suspicion. Still, if you were trying to sow the seeds of doubt against me back there, it seems to have paid off.

You are using the fact that other people suspect you as evidence for me intentionally sowing seeds of doubt. Morsul's vote has nothing to do with me- you're just blaming me for it. You're basically saying that the only reason people suspect you is because of me, and not because you actually did anything suspicious.

And there is nothing reasonable about declaring that I was trying to fool everyone by my confusion when you insist that you could not possibly have been doing just that. The first time I stated it was to clarify the numbers which were in debate at the moment, and the second time was to state why your confusion wasn't terribly suspicious because I was confused as well. You jumped on it and ran with it, well before anyone else had mentioned it, so while your over defensiveness may be justified now, it certainly wasn't then.