WW: LXXXV - The Lost Philosophers of Maiar

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Hey, that was just amazing. I mean, sure, I am on the losing side, but I cannot help to feel wonderful about this game. Aside from the "minor" thing that I have been enjoying it since the beginning till the end (except for the moments when I wailed each Evening over the revelation what was the role of the lynched one), I agree with that it must be some sort of record to have four WWs surviving till the very end.

And you were all quite good, I mean, the pack was really "standard", up to the point of being totally unsuspicious. I mean: all this stuff about Nessa really being a Wolf, all this thing about people who were unsuspicious being really innocent - no double-bluffs, it was in fact quite plain, especially the thing about Nessa, like I said on the thread, we can now surely call her a survivalist Wolf. Such narrow escapes, for so long!

I must say I am however really happy for being right about Agan one time, resp. about not suspecting Agan and she still being innocent. I mean, wow.

And Mänwe! I am so sorry for participating in lynching you! But hey, even in spite of that, I am glad that except for the fail on last Day, I have been right about you and defended you even when the crusade started. Silly us, that was a total fail with the presumption about Shasta's last dream. But I mean, for a Seer, this game must have been a horror - he could easily get into deficite over one Night, just imagine, you dream two innocents during first two Nights and next Night they can both be dead and you can start anew. I consider it a small miracle Shasta managed to dream of three people who remained still alive.

Brilliant job, Wolves, what more to say...

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Ehehe I could say the same, except the other time I was the ranger (Legate & Greenie did you get my hint(s)?)

Um... no? What hints might that have been?

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

Um... no? What hints might that have been?

Lobster (okay it wasn't exactly a hint but Greenie might have got it because she calls me Lobster every now and then).
And pull yourself together or I'll give you Sharkey!

Greenie and Legate, both of whose innocence I was more or less convinced, were the only people who might have connected Lobelia to the ranger.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Lobster (okay it wasn't exactly a hint but Greenie might have got it because she calls me Lobster every now and then).
And pull yourself together or I'll give you Sharkey!

Greenie and Legate, both of whose innocence I was more or less convinced, were the only people who might have connected Lobelia to the ranger.

Okay, that was a bit too complicated for me, at least. Had you said "umbrella", it would have been far clearer. Speaking of that, it didn't even cross my mind (okay, I think maybe once on some later Day) that you might be the Ranger, all the time I have been thinking of some quieter or even less experienced players - because the Ranger didn't manage to protect anybody, which I considered interesting given the amount of kills every Night... on the other hand, it's true that exactly for that reason it was not also easy to hit the right person, there were still too many options...

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Legate of Amon Lanc

because the Ranger didn't manage to protect anybody, which I considered interesting given the amount of kills every Night... on the other hand, it's true that exactly for that reason it was not also easy to hit the right person, there were still too many options...

Haha I had it narrowed down to 3-4 names each night, and I think one of my options died every night. I was having a very hard time because of lack of information - I just had no idea what kind of wolves we were dealing with.

[Nessa Telrunya]

Great game everybody! Sorry for framing so many innocents.

I'm really surprised about how it turned out. So many times I thought I was dead for sure, but then someone would help me.

Shasta, you've had really bad seer luck, huh?

[Mänwe]

It was a good game. I did enjoy being lynched last. And no hard feelings to Legate and the others for voting, no doubt in the future I will do the same.

And thank you Nog for the amusing narration.

[Ozban]

Hilarious game.

That Nessa, can't belive it. From Day1 always suspected, never lynched.

And that YesterDays lynch of Manwe was really a masterpiece, my condolence. But I would have voted the same.

It's a pity i died so early, but when I look at it, I wouldn't guess the traitors. Boro and Wilwa kept half-submarine, half-active, I haven't formed any opinion on either of them during the whole game. Skip was seen in last days, but I'd not vote him, there were others more fishy. I voted Nessa on Day1 and I suspected her ever since, even from the grave. I would probably press on lynching her but who can say now, after the battle is over...

Good Job wolfsies. Never want to play against such a squad again.