WW LXXXIX: The Terror of Tol Fuin

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

How could you know?

Posts 369 and 370. You said you could only focus on a couple of players this game and voted for Galadriel saying you pictured the others as innocent.

Screamed I am the seer....

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Posts 369 and 370. You said you could only focus on a couple of players this game and voted for Galadriel saying you pictured the others as innocent.

Screamed I am the seer....

See, I thought about that, but I'd convinced myself that Nog was the seer, so I thought it was either a fake seer hint to confuse the wolves or that it was a fake seer hint because he was a wolf. Then Nog died.

[Galadriel55]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Posts 369 and 370. You said you could only focus on a couple of players this game and voted for Galadriel saying you pictured the others as innocent.

Screamed I am the seer....

Exactly!

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Posts 369 and 370. You said you could only focus on a couple of players this game and voted for Galadriel saying you pictured the others as innocent.

Screamed I am the seer....

No... I meant that I was finding it difficult to analyse many of the players; Gala, Sally and Nilp were the only ones I really investigated. That's what I meant.

My point is you didn't know I was the seer. Undoubtedly you guessed I was and, as it happened, you guessed correctly. But there was still the chance you would get lucky and have it turn out to be Nog.

[Mithalwen]

I never considered Nogrod as seer for a moment. I suspected you a bit early but wondered whether a first timer would be a likely first time dread, and was fairly convinced even before those posts. Nothing else made sense. Of course we had the advantage of knowing that you weren't one of us and that Galadriel was . Plain ordos are seldom quite so definite about suspects. So if you mean we can't have know because we weren't party to the role email no we didnt' know but I knew by circumstantial evidence and instinct. After I was dead I so nearly told you I knew in a rep and only just stopped myself in time! We can debate the semantics but I would have put good money on it. Of course knowing is useless if you can't do anything with the information.

[Galadriel55]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

No... I meant that I was finding it difficult to analyse many of the players; Gala, Sally and Nilp were the only ones I really investigated. That's what I meant.

My point is you didn't know I was the seer. Undoubtedly you guessed I was and, as it happened, you guessed correctly. But there was still the chance you would get lucky and have it turn out to be Nog.

Well there's also the fact that you were careful not to be too sure about anyone - except for me.

However, you're right, we didn't know for 100%... But we knew 99.9%, and I was ready to eat 10 hats if you weren't the Seer...