Morgoth, Sauron and the Tale of Adanel

[Ardent]

Originally Posted by Zigûr

... Is the element of mystery surrounding the identity of the corrupter of Men deliberate, do you think, or was Professor Tolkien recycling old ideas in his characterisation of Sauron to emphasise the stale, recursive nature of Evil?

The concealed nature is consistant with Morgoth's habits. When first arriving in ME he worked in secret and the Valar only detected his presence by the discord he created. It seems to me that a beautiful form is quite appropriate for the stealth attack, but once others know what to look out for (discord) such disguises become useless. Once seduction has failed what other recourse does evil have but to bully? So it's off with the Laura Ashley and on with the full metal jacket.

[Kuruharan]

It is also an interesting point that if Morgoth had appeared before them in his dark and terrible form, Men probably would have been terrified of him and tried to run away from him rather than worshiping him.

[mhagain]

I've long been of the opinion that this was Sauron.

Whichever way you slice it there are serious problems with it being Melkor. After his escape from Aman is, of course, impossible for reasons stated in the OP. You could move the awakening of Men back but then you've a very narrow time window for it to happen in: after the awakening of Elves but before the Captivity of Melkor. That loses the mythical impact of Men waking with the first rising of the Sun, so you need to accept the later conception of the Sun always being there, and all that implies. You also run into trouble with the Western migration of the Repenters, which should have happened a lot earlier.

All of this is resolved by making it Sauron at the Fall of Men. The temples, burning and human sacrifice are very Sauron-esque too, and there doesn't appear to be much (if anything) in the Tale of Adanel to suggest that it had to be Melkor. At the very worst stretch you could probably say that both were there but Sauron did the talking.