Tol-in-Guarhoth CIX - Ten Year Anniversary Game: Dead Thread

[the phantom]

Okay, quickly- what are the scenarios for a possible false Lover reveal?

Would a WW do it to preserve herself? (probably, but any unseen ramifications?)

Would a Seer try to look like a Lover to preserve herself (and make it less likely the WWs would target her since Lover is lower priority than Seer)?

Geez, I really hope no Livings are reading this accidentally, ha ha! It's weird that I keep thinking that. Does that mean I have an inherent distrust of people, ha ha!

[the phantom]

Basically, if she false reveals as a Lover is it up to us to lynch her, or is it up to the real Lovers to combat her, or is it up to us not to spoil her ploy, or do we just leave her to the Wolves?

Gah.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Basically, if she false reveals as a Lover is it up to us to lynch her, or is it up to the real Lovers to combat her, or is it up to us not to spoil her ploy, or do we just leave her to the Wolves?

Gah.

Hard to say... That would require some thinking I seem to be less and less capable of right now as I just try to figure what to do with our extra-vote.

[Nogrod]

Is Boro-wolf telling his mate Agan-wolf to take it like a man/woman?

I'm getting more confused instead of getting good ideas...


Actually I'm still waiting for a vote that could be my saviour aka. someone I think more innocent than not voting for someone I think pretty suspicious. Then I could vote for giving the extra vote for that person - and you two could then follow the rest and make the final decision (if Agan reveals / something drastic happens).

[Nogrod]

Okay.

If Aganzir actually reveals herself to be the Seer I'm not willing to vote for anyone voting her toDay as if one of you two is a wolf he could easily pile up on my vote and make sure Agan dies.

I don't think this scenario a probable one (Agan being the Seer) but it is possible - and it would be a darn big mistake from us if we decided the close vote in the Living Thread killing the Seer, especially with this little to go on.

On the other hand, if something drastic happens - and one of you two is a wolf - then I'd hate to leave it totally into your hands as the wolf could have a strong influence over our extra-vote (or it not happening). So I feel like I need to vote for someone.

If you're both goodies you can override my vote if you get some fresh knowledge I do not have now. And if not, then I have at least made it a bit harder (hopefully) for the lycanthrope to achieve his goal.


But this leaves me now with only:

- Lottie (voting Morm) - and I suspect Lottie quite a lot - and Morm a little.

- Nerwen (voting Mac) - where I basically distrust Nerwen in every game as she's soo cool a wolf and even if I feel kind of good about Mac I can see why many people suspect him - and share the feeling at least partly.

- Legate (voting Greenie) - now I'm totally torn with this: I kind of see what Legate means and am very much troubled by Greenie, but like someone said in the Living thread, it could be a perfect Wolf-tactics to go for someone no one else suspects and look reasonable & out of the fights that get noticed.

- Morm (voting Mac) - like you can gather from the above, I seem to suspect them both, but not as much as some others...


~'~

Haha... it seems Aganzir didn't "reveal".

Torn now (once again).

Could vote for Lalaith (seems innocentish enough) voting Aganzir, or maybe Legate voting Greenie.


EDIT: X'd with many...