Tol-in-Gaurhoth LIV: The Council of Evil

[satansaloser2005]

Thanks for posting those quotes sally. And yes a post requires at least one letter in addition to quotes.

Heh. Yeah, it took me a bit, because I've done something like that before and it worked, but not on this board. I'm a special child. *facepalms*

Well, off to Menel land. Back in a couple minutes.

[satansaloser2005]

Attention!

I realized when I multi-quoted the posts one wasn't added, so I put it in. Just so you can all (both, the way it's going right now) see it.

I'm basically done with my analysis, but I need to do that post now since I realized I'd missed it. Give me like five or ten minutes so I can take care of bolding and things in my post and add the rest of it in, and I'll be back.

[satansaloser2005]

Day One

Okay, so the first 'accusation' of any kind is toward Gwath, saying that he's too tough on Bowie. But this was on the first Day, so while he may be right he couldn't possibly know for sure, as he had no 'pre-game' dream, poor fellow.

Then he mentions Agan, dedicates quite a post toward her, and says that she looks pretty dern suspicious because she's after Gwath, that and her suspicion of Brinniel and all this business. He also accuses her of flip flopping, but not in so many words.

Find Ilya a bit suspicious, and says that Gwath sounds suspicious no matter what he is, but votes Agan.



Day Two

But then, oh, then, he mentions Agan again. And if I'm not mistaken the gist of his post is "oh, just kidding, I read her wrong, I think she's innocent but I'll still keep an eye on her because I should". It makes me thinks that he possibly dreamt her innocent. In the same post he mentions Gwath and Bowie as possible partners.

He then votes Gwath, well after the deadline but a vote nonetheless, and there were other candidates up (including myself and Agan, though Ilya was basically dead anyway so it was a throwaway of sorts) so I wonder if he did indeed dream Gwath.

Thus, his possible dreams for the night of Boro's death, at least that would make sense with what he's posted: Agan (innocent/hunter) or Gwath (wolf/bear).



The next Day he starts off his posting by noting the dead, our beloved and departed Boro and Nog. Who could do such a thing? Perhaps Kath, he suggests. She is a tricksy one, after all.

In the next post he says he's gone through Kath's posts and there's not much to talk about, but he finds nothing that 'jumps out as suspicious'. That doesn't mean that he doesn't suspect her, only that he doesn't see anything in her posts that is suspicious. Perhaps he's dreamt her?

Yay! He called me evil! :) Anyway, moving on. I was on the chopping block that day so since he didn't vote me I doubt he dreamt me. (And even if he did dream me....well, then he definitely wouldn't have voted me because I'm innocent, but I'm the only one who knows that so I won't take that into account.) If you're Miss Paranoid Agan Pants :p and assume that I'm evil, it could be a bluff by not voting me to keep him alive long enough to find my partner. I'll put the theory out there, even though it's not true. Also, he still finds Gwath and Bowie suspicious, but votes Bowie because he's overdefensive. Perhaps he'd dreamt Gwath already (whether this night or the night previous) and wanted to get rid of a possible unknown wolf? Then upon the dawn he could tell us that Gwath was the other furry fiend and we'd be rid of both of them and just left with the bear.

Thus....possible dreams: Kath (wolf/bear), Sally (wolf/bear), Gwath....again (wolf/bear)

He never mentions anyone but the five of us though. He talks of how we react to the other players, but never mentioned Eon, Shasta, Izzy, or any of the dead players in his suspicions. (Edit to this: that's not true, after I saw the Agan vote post. He also mentions Ilya, but the fact remains that he speaks of Gwath the most after Day One, along with Kath, Agan, and I. I'm not counting Bowie because he's dead.)


My theory? His dreams were either Agan (innocent/hunter) and Gwath (wolf/bear), Agan (innocent/hunter) and Kath (wolf/bear), or Gwath (wolf/bear) and Kath (wolf/bear).

So....Agan, my dear, it seems to be up to us (if you're trusting me again, which I doubt). Gwath or Kath? I'm assuming Gwath because Kath is hardly going to vote for herself and if Agan votes me then we definitely wouldn't get a wolf. At the same time, however, I feel rather unsports(wo)manlike killing Gwath while he's gone. But still.

[satansaloser2005]

Hmmmm. I don't think the Gwath/Kath dream analogy fits, come to think of it, because he would have found both the wolves (or a wolf and a bear) and I would assume he would let us know this information. Then again, with people so hard to read this game he may have not said anything specific. I'd like to hear other opinions, of course.

[Aganzir]

If I had to pick two people he had dreamt of, I'd say Agan (hunter) and sally (wolf/bear).

If he dreamt of me on night 1 (which makes the most sense), his Gwath vote means nothing. However I don't think he found Gwath a wolf even if he dreamt of him. In my opinion there isn't enough evidence pointing at it. Plus I find Gwath rather innocent-looking.
If he found Kath a baddie, why didn't he try to find any evidence against her? Therefore a Kath dream doesn't make sense to me.

I am for lynching sally today.

[satansaloser2005]

If I had to pick two people he had dreamt of, I'd say Agan (hunter) and sally (wolf/bear).

If he dreamt of me on night 1 (which makes the most sense), his Gwath vote means nothing. However I don't think he found Gwath a wolf even if he dreamt of him. In my opinion there isn't enough evidence pointing at it. Plus I find Gwath rather innocent-looking.
If he found Kath a baddie, why didn't he try to find any evidence against her? Therefore a Kath dream doesn't make sense to me.

I am for lynching sally today.

Honey, if he dreamt me, he would have tried to kill me. The Day I could have been lynched he voted for someone else. It just doesn't make sense, unless he dreamt me last Night which means nothing to us anyway.

I think Gwath makes a bit more sense for a baddie than Kath, although I'd be amenable to lynching either. However, I think I'll have to go for Gwath, for reasons I stated before.

Here's my predicament for the day. I don't know when/if I'm going into work (they have to fix a bunch of equipment or something so I don't know when they'll call me) but if I'm called in I might have to vote before I leave. Just letting you all know now. If I don't go to work today I'll hold my vote closer to deadline so we can have more discussion. I just wanted to keep you all in the loop.

[satansaloser2005]

By the way, we have to get toDay correct. Here's why.

We have seven players. (Agan, Sally, Kath, Eon, Gwath, Shasta, and Izzy.) Two wolves, and one bear.

We kill an innocent toDay, who is not me, we have six players and two wolves. ToNight the wolves kill Agan, who will no doubt take me with her. Four players, two wolves. The wolves win.

So if we have to lynch an innocent toDay, let it be me, I suppose. Because at least that way there's a chance that when/if Agan dies she'll take a wolf with her, instead of me.


Obviously I'd rather survive, but if we lynch an innocent toDay we're pretty much dead unless the wolves don't kill Agan or unless Agan changes her mind and hunter picks someone else. (Or unless she's lying. But I'm too lazy to consider that possibility. :p Besides, I'm pretty sure she's misguided, not guilty.)




So if it absolutely comes to it, I'll Nilp myself. But it's far from my first choice.

[satansaloser2005]

A few facts and figures.


There are (counting from my last post) 257 posts in this thread.

Agan has 68. I have 47. That means that, between the two of us, we are responsible for 44.75% of the posts in the game.

The dead players (Brinn, Boro, Ilya, Nog, Bowie, and Menel) have 78 posts between them, accounting for 30.35% of the posts.

Gollum has 20 posts, or 7.78% of the game thread.

That means that the other living players (Gwath, Eon, Kath, Shasta, and Izzy) all have under 20 posts apiece (all but Gwath have 15 or less) and between them account for 44 posts, 17.12% of the thread, and which also means that all of the other living players (sans Agan) combined have less posts than me.


Don't be offended, I know a lot of the people who are alive are having internet trouble or are away yet for Christmas/New Years, I'm just bored and felt like crunching some numbers.

Point is, I'd love to analyze people, but Izzy's got no posts, Shasta's only post is to say that he can't post, and the other three unknowns (again, assuming Agan's telling the truth about her being the hunter) don't strike me as particularly interesting either. Can't get blood out of a turnip, rock, whatever butters your toast, but the moral of the story is that this game is seriously lacking in posts. :(



Oooo I haven't done the votes for yesterDay yet. Perhaps I'll do that. At least I'll give somebody something to read when they come back. ;)

[satansaloser2005]

Votes from Day 1
Brinn-->Agan at 12:22pm
Eon-->Gwath at 3:48pm
Bowie-->Brinn at 4:50pm
Boro-->Izzy at 4:51pm
Agan-->Brinn at 4:57pm
Noggie-->Brinn at 5:00pm
Menel-->Agan at 5:06pm*
Ilya-->Brinn at 6:11pm*
Gwath-->Eon at 6:32pm*
Did not vote: Izzy, Kath, Sally, Shasta


Votes from Day 2
Sally-->Ilya at 2:24pm
Kath-->Agan at 4:31pm
Agan-->Ilya at 4:54pm
Bowie-->Ilya at 4:58pm
Ilya-->Sally at 4:58pm
Menel-->Gwath at 7:23pm*
Did not vote: Eon, Gwath, Izzy, Nog, Shasta


Votes from Day 3
Menel-->Bowie at 4:03pm
Agan-->Sally at 4:44pm
Kath-->Agan at 4:55pm
Sally-->Bowie at 4:59pm
Eon-->Sally at 5:02pm
Did not vote: Bowie, Gwath, Izzy, Shasta


Again, underlined known guilty parties (not that we have any yet) and italicized known innocents (which are abundant). Times are Central, with a deadline of 5pm.

[Aganzir]

The wolves kill me if they dare. I'm a known innocent but there's also a risk I choose well and take one with me. However keeping known innocents around for long has its risks, and the sooner they kill me the slighter the chance I can guess right...

Just so you know, if I have picked an innocent when the wolves attack me, I don't kill him/her. So if you sally indeed are innocent, you have no reason to be worried. And it's not certain that I'm going to hunt you anyway.

It irks me that we don't know if we need to find just one or even three baddies among the active players.

By the way, if you exclude Gollum's posts, you and I are responsible for 49% of the posts.

[satansaloser2005]

The wolves kill me if they dare. I'm a known innocent but there's also a risk I choose well and take one with me. However keeping known innocents around for long has its risks, and the sooner they kill me the slighter the chance I can guess right...

Just so you know, if I have picked an innocent when the wolves attack me, I don't kill him/her. So if you sally indeed are innocent, you have no reason to be worried. And it's not certain that I'm going to hunt you anyway.

It irks me that we don't know if we need to find just one or even three baddies among the active players.

By the way, if you exclude Gollum's posts, you and I are responsible for 49% of the posts.


Really? Oh.....heh, the way I've normally played the hunter's kill goes down no matter what their role. Heck then, hunt me all you like (although I'd obviously prefer you chose a wolf or the bear) and I'll just go on about my business.


Well, I think that the bear is probably inactive, either that or both wolves are. Thus if one of those is the case it's obviously the bear who is idle. However, as someone pointed out earlier in the game, you can trace through night kills so if the bear can just sit back and let the wolves do their dirty work I'm sure they would. At the same time, though, it would be in their best interest to try to kill the wolves, thus making sure that the wolves don't kill them first.


Okay, so Agan, barring me, who do you suspect the most?


Heh, yeah I know, but leaving Gollum's posts in there made it look a bit better. ;)

[Aganzir]

Oh forgot to say this.

Menel didn't leave any clear hints to his dreams. Therefore I don't think he would necessarily have voted you if he had dreamt of you and found you evil, so that's not a valid argument. And when he voted there were no other votes in and he couldn't know if you got voted at all. Therefore I find it understandable that he voted someone else in order not to get too much attention from the baddies, or because he didn't think he'd die so he rather wanted to check out one who he wasn't sure about yet.

edit: xed

[satansaloser2005]

Oh forgot to say this.

Menel didn't leave any clear hints to his dreams. Therefore I don't think he would necessarily have voted you if he had dreamt of you and found you evil, so that's not a valid argument. And when he voted there were no other votes in and he couldn't know if you got voted at all. Therefore I find it understandable that he voted someone else in order not to get too much attention from the baddies, or because he didn't think he'd die so he rather wanted to check out one who he wasn't sure about yet.

edit: xed

You're right. Sorry about that, I got my Days confused and thought that was the Day he voted really late. My mistake.

[Aganzir]

Trying to get the hunter to tell about her plans, eh? ;)

Hmm who are still alive?

Eeeeek I have no idea.

I have some minor suspicions about Kath.
I feel quite good about Gwath and Eönwë, maybe more so with Eönwë (who hasn't shown up for some time though).
About Shasta and Izzy I don't know, obviously.

If I can't come up with anyone and we lynch you now and you're innocent, I could of course hunt Izzy or Shasta and you'd have a known innocent if I died in the night and took no one with me... But that's just an option and if I'm going to do it, I'll tell you in advance.

[satansaloser2005]

Trying to get the hunter to tell about her plans, eh? ;)

Hmm who are still alive?

Eeeeek I have no idea.

I have some minor suspicions about Kath.
I feel quite good about Gwath and Eönwë, maybe more so with Eönwë (who hasn't shown up for some time though).
About Shasta and Izzy I don't know, obviously.

If I can't come up with anyone and we lynch you now and you're innocent, I could of course hunt Izzy or Shasta and you'd have a known innocent if I died in the night and took no one with me... But that's just an option and if I'm going to do it, I'll tell you in advance.



Oooo now there's a good plan. Course if you pick a wolf the wolves just won't kill you. ;)


Like I said before, I could go for Kath, but I'd prefer Gwath by a small margin, mostly because we'd still have talkative players. Then again, I think he's supposed to be back tomorrow, so I would be fine either way.

Let's see who else shows up, yeah? :)

[Aganzir]

Or then they try to bluff but however I'd still be alive tomorrow.

Or... sally we could make a deal? If you're a baddie you don't eat me and I won't hunt you and then we lynch everybody else and win together? :D

[satansaloser2005]

Or then they try to bluff but however I'd still be alive tomorrow.

Or... sally we could make a deal? If you're a baddie you don't eat me and I won't hunt you and then we lynch everybody else and win together? :D



Heh I'd go for it. Unfortunately, I'm not a baddie so how about you hunt me all you like and we still lynch everyone else and win this thing together? :p

[Eönwë]

Ok, well I've come back.

I'm just going to go and reread posts some posts.


That means that the other living payers (Gwath, Eon, Kath, Shasta, and Izzy) all have less than 20 posts apiece (all but Gwath have under 12)
You lie! (Sorry, I was just watching TT)
Still, I have 15 posts (now 16). It doesn't really matter, but still.
Or maybe it does matter. Maybe you're deliberately trying to make it look worse, and it is part of your plan for world (or at least village) domination. Or maybe it makes you more innocent, as a wolf might not be do careless.

[satansaloser2005]

Ok, well I've come back.

I'm just going to go and reread posts some posts.



You lie! (Sorry, I was just watching TT)
Still, I have 15 posts (now 16). It doesn't really matter, but still.
Or maybe it does matter. Maybe you're deliberately trying to make it look worse, and it is part of your plan for world (or at least village) domination. Or maybe it makes you more innocent, as a wolf might not be do careless.




oooops. you're right. *shifty eyes*

[satansaloser2005]

Little over an hour until deadline. Anyone around?

[Aganzir]

Yes I'm here.

I still think killing sally would be a good thing to do today.

[satansaloser2005]

Yes I'm here.

I still think killing sally would be a good thing to do today.


Okay, let me rephrase that. Anyone besides Agan here? ;)

[Eönwë]

I'm here too.

[satansaloser2005]

I'm here too.

Yay!


Have any thoughts, dearie?

[Eönwë]

Yay!


Have any thoughts, dearie?

Do you really want me to say?;)

I'm thinking I might agree with Agan.

[satansaloser2005]

Do you really want me to say?;)

I'm thinking I might agree with Agan.


In which case....


++Gwath


On the off chance that we'll get someone who is possibly a wolf rather than me, whom I know is not.

[satansaloser2005]

Sorry, hate to be selfish, but if you guys kill me I know we don't catch a wolf. If we kill someone else (as I've been saying all day I was up for either Gwath or Kath and currently I feel better -rather, worse, I suppose- about him than I do her) there's a chance that we'll catch a baddie.


If nothing else getting my vote in first gives me a chance to survive and hopefully buys the village another Day.

[Aganzir]

Have any thoughts, dearie?
I do.

I think we should lynch sally today because your hunter isn't of much use as long as sally is alive. Also, if Menel dreamt of any baddie, I think it's bound to be her.

edit: xed since Eönwë. Gah I should probably have refreshed the page before starting to write a post. Anyway that's good to hear.

[satansaloser2005]

Kath, I really hope you're here. Or coming soon.

I also hope you're innocent, and that my vote is not as incorrect as Agan's.

EDIT: x'd with Agan.

[Aganzir]

++sally

Whatever the outcome, I apologize. And if you're innocent I hope you get your revenge when I'm left here with four times more posts than anyone else.

If she's a wolf I'd take a second look at Kath as well.

[satansaloser2005]

++sally

Whatever the outcome, I apologize. And if you're innocent I hope you get your revenge when I'm left here with four times more posts than anyone else.

If she's a wolf I'd take a second look at Kath as well.



Well, I don't wish you the fate of being the only person still really posting, but there's nothing I can do now.


I sincerely hoped to survive this game but it doesn't appear at the moment that I will. I suggest that you take a look at my posts, Agan. Once I'm proven innocent you'll see that I may have been onto something. Or completely misguided as usual. Either way, I hope that I was of at least some help.

[satansaloser2005]

And Eon, vote whoever you feel is the best choice, but keep in mind that Menel repeatedly -repeatedly- spoke of Gwath in negative tones, and only mentioned me as evil once. I'd say he's one of our baddies, whether he be a bear or one of the wolves.

[Aganzir]

Menel started it before having any dreams, and he never indicated he had dreamt of Gwath. Of course it's possible I'm misguided and sally was right all along but as long as I don't know her role I can't concentrate on other possibilities, and eg my suspicion on Kath depends pretty much on sally.

I wish I could make myself trust you but I just can't.

[satansaloser2005]

Menel started it before having any dreams, and he never indicated he had dreamt of Gwath. Of course it's possible I'm misguided and sally was right all along but as long as I don't know her role I can't concentrate on other possibilities, and eg my suspicion on Kath depends pretty much on sally.

I wish I could make myself trust you but I just can't.


*sigh*


Well, again, it's out of our hands. Menel did indeed call me evil, but in the very same post he speaks of Gwath, yet again. And you know how I play. I love playing with Boro and Nog, and I'd keep them around as long as I could afford to. (Of course, that could have been a bluff, but the fact remains that I generally would keep Noggie around, Boro as well.)

[satansaloser2005]

Heh. How mad would you be if Eon didn't return to vote? ;)

[Aganzir]

Yes but I think you're generally quite flexible when it comes to kills - if your buddy wants to kill someone, it's alright to you.

See I force myself to come up with counter-arguments.

edit: xed, yeah I thought of it too. It'd be almost too funny - especially if Gwath actually was a wolf.

[satansaloser2005]

Yes but I think you're generally quite flexible when it comes to kills - if your buddy wants to kill someone, it's alright to you.

See I force myself to come up with counter-arguments.

Heh. Not necessarily.


Last game (well, last game I was a wolf) I really hated killing Legate the first night. Gollum just wasn't around to consult about changing my mind, so I went with his opinion only because I wasn't able to reach him again.

I'm a team player, but since most players are inactive, even if I was a wolf, I'd pretty much be alone, so I could kill whoever I want. And it wouldn't be Nog and Boro.




What about Shasta? I know, he's not posted, but the kills may fit him. I'll have to think about it.

[Aganzir]

Okay that's true...

It would be pretty, err, not so nice from Shasta to come to post kills but not participate in the days.

[satansaloser2005]

Okay that's true...

It would be pretty, err, not so nice from Shasta to come to post kills but not participate in the days.


Good point. I suppose I'm grasping at straws trying to come up with three suspects.


I'm decently certain about either Gwath or Kath. Izzy or Shasta for the bear, I would suspect, but that could be a bluff.


Agan: innocent, 95%
Sally: innocent, 100%
Gwath: guilty, 75%
Eon: undecided
Kath: guilty, 45%
Shasta: no idea, but 60% innocent by lack of ability to participate
Izzy: no idea, thus 60% guilty by default

[Aganzir]

Heck we're running out of possible players...

I (or someone if I'm not alive) should probably check Eönwë and Gwath properly tomorrow... They've been the ones I've felt the most comfortable with but now I'm getting paranoid.

Where's Kath?

edit: xed with sally. I agree it could be Kath or Gwath, they should be checked

[satansaloser2005]

Heck we're running out of possible players...

I (or someone if I'm not alive) should probably check Eönwë and Gwath properly tomorrow... They've been the ones I've felt the most comfortable with but now I'm getting paranoid.

Where's Kath?



I dunno.


I'm uncertain about Eon. If I'm still alive I'll make sure to look at his posts, but he seems....detached. Like when he said he agreed with you. Granted, I'm biased since he wants to lynch me, but it seemed more like "Oh, look, this is working out just how I like it. Shall I wave it in your face?" Not in a mean way, but you understand.

[satansaloser2005]

To Agan's X: Heh. Sure, you see my POV now. ;)

[satansaloser2005]

By the way, Agan dear, we now have over 50% of the posts, whether you count Gollum or not.


You're gonna miss me when/if I'm gone.

[Aganzir]

Yeah... And I agree about Eönwë. But then again he always looks somewhat suspicious. Hmm he's actually looked less suspicious in this game, I wonder if it means something...

[Aganzir]

It's four minutes till deadline and our votes are the only ones cast so there are chances that it's Gwath who dies today, not you.

Arrrgh I'm actually starting to trust you now, I shouldn't, ouch.

edit: three now

[satansaloser2005]

Yeah... And I agree about Eönwë. But then again he always looks somewhat suspicious. Hmm he's actually looked less suspicious in this game, I wonder if it means something...

Very much could be. I mean, I understand that you have a bad feeling about me, but there's not a lot of evidence so for him to latch on to your suspicion with nothing but 'let's kill her' seems very, VERY off to me.

[Eönwë]

Ok, ok I will vote, but only because I have to. I really am at a loss. And because I want to see what Gwath has to say before I vote for his lynching, I think I'm going to have to vote for:

++Sally

edit: x-ed with many.

[satansaloser2005]

It's four minutes till deadline and our votes are the only ones cast so there are chances that it's Gwath who dies today, not you.

Arrrgh I'm actually starting to trust you now, I shouldn't, ouch.

edit: three now

No, really, you should.


Two now, sweetie. Is it selfish of me to hope that we're the only two that show up?

[Aganzir]

Hahaa if sally isn't a wolf they could be Eönwë and Gwath! :D *hums I Think I'm Paranoid in her head*

[satansaloser2005]

Crap! Crap, crap, crap!



Agan, you better win this thing or I'm going to be a tad hacked off. :(

[Aganzir]

I promise to try.

[Eönwë]

Very much could be. I mean, I understand that you have a bad feeling about me, but there's not a lot of evidence so for him to latch on to your suspicion with nothing but 'let's kill her' seems very, VERY off to me.

And there's lots of evidence for lynching Gwath, is there?

[satansaloser2005]

Sorry, didn't mean to be rude but I actually tried to 'participate' for once and I still died.



Well, make sure to take a look at everyone very closely, Agan dear. You're for the most part on your own now.


And as of now I'm dead. Enjoy the rest of the game!

[satansaloser2005]

And there's lots of evidence for lynching Gwath, is there?

A lot more than there was for me, yes. Such as Menel's discussion of him.

[Aganzir]

And now whoever the wolves are they're going to get no hints for my hunting pick from my posts as I've suggested everyone.

I wonder if they dare to come for me... :smokin:

[Eönwë]

I'm really sorry if it isn't you, Sally.

[satansaloser2005]

And now whoever the wolves are they're going to get no hints for my hunting pick from my posts as I've suggested everyone.

I wonder if they dare to come for me... :smokin:

Heh. I hope not, because there won't be any posts with the two of us gone. ;)




Try Eon or Gwath toMorrow. They both seem horribly off to me. Eon's sudden appearance toDay and then the way he went about voting for me seemed wrong. I thought he was gone for a while because he was posting, but he's not put in anything of a lot of value. (Granted, I can't go back and check now, but nothing comes to mind that he's said that's memorable.)


Anyway, I'll shush now. Agan, kick some fuzzy butt. :D

[Kath]

I know I'm way too late for voting, I just wanted to pop in to apologise for missing the vote. I had my laptop in the room with me but got so completely distracted by Shooting Stars and Graham Norton that I didn't even realise the time until about 5 minutes ago.

[satansaloser2005]

I know I'm way too late for voting, I just wanted to pop in to apologise for missing the vote. I had my laptop in the room with me but got so completely distracted by Shooting Stars and Graham Norton that I didn't even realise the time until about 5 minutes ago.

It happens. Couple days ago I went out of town and suddenly realized I had to be back for the deadline. I just barely made it. :p




Well, since Gollum's not here I may as well tell you I was innocent, so you don't have to wait to find out. (By the way, Gollum, if you could use a co-mod for the game I'd be happy to serve. I have the next couple days free and would be able to call the Days/Nights for you if you like, since I'm sure you're busy.) Anyway, I hope y'all enjoy the rest of the game. Later!

~~Sally~~

[Gollum the Great]

Wow! Sorry for being so late.

In confirmation, Sally is as innocent as she claimed.

Werewolves, send me a name.

Sally, thanks for the offer. My time is circumscribed and I'll send you any necessary info beforehand.

[Gollum the Great]

I was unavoidably detained once more. Description to follow...

[Gollum the Great]

Day found only Aganzir, Gwathagor, Eonwe, and Kath in conference. Isabellkya's corpse was on the table and Shasta had taken flight during the night.

"Uh oh," said Aganzir, looking over the other three.

The ensuing battle was swift and decisive. Kath and Eonwe moved for the werewolf, readying club, whip, and blazing sword. Aganzir slew the Balrog Eonwe with lethal venom, but lost his skull to a heavy blow from the Olog Kath.

"Excellent work, minion!" praised the Dragon Gwathagor, "The whole purpose of your life is fulfilled. I hope this death won't be very to painful."

He drew a very deep breath and unleashed a blast of horrendous flame in the troll's direction. After the heat had abated and the smoke thinned, little remained in the Council's hall. The bodies, table, and lamp were utterly obliterated. Gwathagor then exited the mountain.

He led his armies to war with the Free Peoples, going hither and thither, leaving a wasteland in his wake, and undoing much of the Valars' work. But in the end the Shadow passed away, for while Eru watches His Middle-Earth, it cannot be wholly destroyed.



That was a bit shorter than I had intended. I hope you players enjoyed the game.

Dead/gone:

Aganzir (Werewolf, Hunter)
Boro (Alatar, Innocent)
Brinn (Wingless Dragon, Innocent)
Eonwe (Balrog, Forced Werewolf) Done Good Work
Ilya (Balrog, Innocent)
Isabellkya (Balrog, Innocent)
Meneltarmacil (Winged Dragon, Seer)
Nogrod (Troll, Innocent)
Sally (Troll, Innocent)
Shasta (Winged Dragon, Innocent)
Strongbow (Balrog, Innocent)

Incinerated:

Kath (Olog-hai, Forced Werewolf) Done Good Work

Alive:

Gwathagor (Wingless Dragon, Mastermind/Werebear) Winner!

[Brinniel]

Hmm...I sorta figured it'd all be over today. Sorry Gollum that it was so short. Watching the game, I realised early on things weren't looking bright for the innocents (especially when the most vocal players kept getting killed). I don't think we had much of a shot simply due to lack of participation (I may have only been alive one Day, but I know I'm partly at fault too). Perhaps for future reference, we should avoid having games run over the holidays..

Anyways, congrats to the other teams! Gwath, it's a good thing I died early on because I probably would've voted you. Not that I strongly suspected you, but I just thought Sally looked so clearly innocent. Eonwe, I didn't suspect much until the end of the final Day. Kath, I thought was innocent. I say she always manages to fool me, and it's true.

Aganzir, I must apologise because while my vote for you was a random one, after I was lynched I was convinced the entire game you were evil. Even after you declared yourself the hunter, I thought you were lying and just trying to draw out the real hunter (unsuccessfully). Only towards the very end did I start to doubt my suspicions. I don't know what it was, you just seemed so manipulative. And your suspicions of Sally reminded me of when you (as a werewolf) got me lynched in Noggie's game... :rolleyes:

[Gwathagor]

Ha ha ha! I actually won! Though I don't feel like I really earned it, since I was gone so much. I'm sorry about that. Well-played, everybody! I'm also sorry about the Werebear mix-up. I wasn't really a Werebear; I was more like a Alpha Werewolf, since I was giving instructions to Eonwe and Kath, rather than just playing for myself.

Thanks for the interesting game, Gollum. I like how I destroyed Kath once I had gotten as much use as I could out of her. :D Sorry, Kath, that was Gollum's idea, not mine.

[Kath]

Now see, that's where I didn't enjoy this game as much as I might have, the whole werebear thing was just really odd. The wolves, well, me anyway, were basically told that the werebear was on our side which is why we didn't kill Gwath toNight and lynch Agan tomorrow, thus ensuring ourselves the win which was our plan had we not been informed that the werebear was working with us. I mean even Gwath didn't know that that was going to happen.

I also feel that it's something of a hollow victory because we, well Gwath, only won because of a modfire at the same time so it doesn't feel as earned as it could have done.

Despite that it was fun and it was lovely to be a wolf once again and everybody who played I think played fantastically, sally terrified me with how well she was pegging everyone and Agan and Menel covered their Gifted tracks beautifully. And I have to apologise to Nog because it was entirely my entire to kill him - though I have to say that it was so, so nice to be able to kill off all the loudmouths for once. Given the number of players who didn't turn up it was perhaps a shame that we did that even if it wasn't actually intentional because it did make for such a quiet game but it still felt good. :D

[Boromir88]

Gollum, good game. :D

Nice job Gwath et Eonwe and Kath. I was not once ever suspicious of you Eonwe. That was well done. Kath I only became suspicious of towards the end.

Gwath I thought you were a wolf the day after I died, because I said the day you were a wolf, and I defended you, it would be the end of me.

I was slightly confused about the werebear as well, I kept wondering why there weren't two kills at night. I was thinking it was either Izzy or Shasta who hadn't been around for various reasons and we were only getting the wolf kills.

Agan, sally, I adore the both of you, I want to make an attempt to be in every village with both of you. We can continue with Mith's upcoming game. :p

Strongbow, you definitely need to do this again.

And Menel you don't do this enough, sir. Once I thought Gwath was a wolf, I narrowed you and Agan down to being the seer for the way you both went after him on Day 1.

I think one of our handicaps for the dutiful villagers was just how many seer dreams did Menel have? I'm still confused over the number and that makes it hard to take anything out of the Seer's death. Of course, I'd much rather have the seer not be killed, but when he/she is it's a great help to know exactly how many dreams the seer had. That's something I still have no idea about.

[Aganzir]

Sorry sally. Actually I started hoping no one would come in and vote you and Gwath (or anyone else) would be lynched instead because our talk during the last minutes of the day made me rather, well, convinced of your innocence.
I just couldn't help feeling the way I did.

Haha Brinn. :D Though I think we have this little habit of suspecting each other rather often so it isn't that surprising. I always find you forced-looking.

Well played, baddies. I had a bad feeling about Kath through the whole game but didn't do anything about it because I was so much after sally. But as for Gwath and Eönwë... I had a fleeting suspicion about them both on day 1 but played it down by thinking Nah, that's just normal behaviour for them, I don't want to start being nitpicky again. To be honest I wasn't as convinced about their innocence as I appeared to be - I was trying to look like the seer who had dreamed of them and found them innocent. I picked them because they looked rather innocent and I found I could change my mind about Gwath beautifully. No wonder my plan didn't work. :rolleyes:

I'm sorry, though, that the village was so quiet. I understand it was mostly because of RL stuff, what with holidays and Christmas and all. Still, after the other louder players had died, I didn't have much enthusiasm to make big cases and spend a lot of time online, either. It's not fun to feel I was playing all alone (which is maybe a bit unfair of me because there were other players participating well anyway - I'm probably just too used to seeing good long posts every time I refresh the thread).

I think Menel had had two dreams when he was killed. Who actually were those dreams? Why did you wolves decide to kill him anyway?

As for my role, I was told that if the wolves attacked me, I would kill one regardless of whether I had sent in their name or not. I sent in a name every night though. First I think I was hunting Nog because I thought there had been something fishy in the way he, Boro and me seemed to decide the lynchee on day 1. My second two nights I hunted sally, and then Eönwë.

I'm a lousy hunter to reveal at such a bad time but I figured the wolves hadn't killed me because they had realised I was the hunter, and thought I could as well make it public information. Not that it would have changed the outcome of the game.

Anyway thanks for the game Gollum. It was nice to have a bit smaller village for once (although it also meant it was quieter). If we don't take into account some frustration of having so many posts compared to most, the game was enjoyable.

[Gollum the Great]

I think Menel had had two dreams when he was killed. Who actually were those dreams? Why did you wolves decide to kill him anyway?

N1: Boro But Boro died the same night, leaving no gain.

N2: Agan Good choice, but the info never got out.


I had been hoping that the players would take into consideration (maybe they did, but I didn't see it) the species they carried. For example, trolls would hardly be fit to take on as a huge a scale role as the mastermind, but they might be more easily forced to the werewolf. And vice versa with the dragons. You get the idea.

I'm afraid the wolves were at a disadvantage, Gwath knew who they were, but didn't know his identity. Also Gwath sent them instructions once or twice, perhaps (I don't know for sure) hampering their movements. And losing once all the innocents were dead. Sorry if you felt irritated, Kath.

[Gwathagor]

To be honest I wasn't as convinced about their innocence as I appeared to be - I was trying to look like the seer who had dreamed of them and found them innocent. I picked them because they looked rather innocent and I found I could change my mind about Gwath beautifully. No wonder my plan didn't work.


I ought to have suspected you were insincere in your support of me! I thought that about Boro and his defense of my innocence, and consequently had him killed. Very clever - I'd rep you if I could! :)

[Gwathagor]

I think Menel had had two dreams when he was killed. Who actually were those dreams? Why did you wolves decide to kill him anyway?


Ah, it was at my suggestion that Menel was killed. It was your fault, actually. :) I knew that you would have Sally lynched the next day if you could, and I was hardly going to stand in the way of that. So, we couldn't kill you or sally, which left only Menel. I had no idea he was the seer.

[Aganzir]

Gwath you're evil. :p

However I'm sure Boro likes your sig. Now he maybe learnt he shouldn't defend you and you'll continue to get lynched early. ;)

[Gwathagor]

Gwath you're evil. :p

However I'm sure Boro likes your sig. Now he maybe learnt he shouldn't defend you and you'll continue to get lynched early. ;)

That would be just my luck, though I surely deserve it after this game.