Hurt and Heal Take 2

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Can anybody explain to me what's the problem you have with Ulmo? :mad:

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

If we start explaining stuff, it'll easier to attack us where it hurts. ;)

[mormegil]

Can anybody explain to me what's the problem you have with Ulmo? :mad:

He's not the interesting to me. I would like to know why people don't like the two I wanted to win...I always seem to be in the minority on the character likes. Turin and Huan were my picks. So I have one or two others that I would prefer to win so I would like to see them. With Ulmo I know I'm chaffing a few people, mainly those who took down my picks so call it petty revenge :p

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

So I have one or two others that I would prefer to win so I would like to see them. With Ulmo I know I'm chaffing a few people, mainly those who took down my picks so call it petty revenge :p

From the looks of it, there is nobody around anymore who cares about Ulmo :( So you could as well drop it and start actually hurting somebody else, eh? Phantom was the one who killed your Huan! Why don't you go after his favourites!

Bah, infidels. Drown them all!

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Ulmo Hurt Maedhros Nurt Finrod

Melian (8)
Maedhros (8)
Ulmo (5)
Fingon (5)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Heal Ulmo Hurt Maedhros Nurt Finrod

How nice of you, Tuor :) (Although I wonder who Nurt is.)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

How nice of you, Tuor (Although I wonder who Nurt is.)

It's a little known elvish putdown of orcs.
Apparently a putdown of orcish ancestry (inspired
no doubt by a viewing of their birth in PJ's FOTR)).

[Gordis]

Heal Fingon, Hurt Ulmo, Hurt Melian

Melian (7)
Maedhros (8)
Ulmo (4)
Fingon (6)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom

[Oddwen]

Hurt Melian and Ulmo, heal Maedhros

Melian (6)
Maedhros (9)
Ulmo (3)
Fingon (6)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom

[mormegil]

Hurt Finrod and Fingon Heal Melian

Melian (7)
Maedhros (9)
Ulmo (3)
Fingon (5)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Hurt Ulmo and Maedhros, Heal Finrod.

Melian (7)
Maedhros (8)
Ulmo (2)
Fingon (5)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom

[Lalaith]

Hurt Ulmo and Fingon, Heal Melian.

Melian (8)
Maedhros (8)
Ulmo (1)
Fingon (4)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom[/quote]

[Macalaure]

Legate will hate me for this, but...

Kill Ulmo, hurt Finrod, heal Maedhros

Melian (8)
Maedhros (9)
Ulmo (0) *dies as deadly as a Vala can*
Fingon (4)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Gordis]

Hurt Fingon, hurt Melian, heal Finrod

Melian (7)
Maedhros (9)
Fingon (3)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Rikae]

Hurt Fingon, Hurt Finrod, Heal Melian (my nominees are winning! :smokin:)

Melian (8)
Maedhros (9)
Fingon (2)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Fingon Hurt Maedhros Heal Melian

Melian (9)
Maedhros (8)
Fingon (1)
Finrod (6)

Finrod may trail M&M but he has the coolest name.

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[mormegil]

Kill Fingon Hurt Melian Heal Finrod

Melian (8)
Maedhros (8)
Finrod (7)

Finrod may trail M&M but he has the coolest name.

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Fingon by mormy

[mormegil]

Okay reminder on the rules. We may want to revisit these rules if they don't seem to be working but here it is:

When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.

And still wait for 4 others to post.

[Oddwen]

Hurt Melian.

Melian (7)
Maedhros (8)
Finrod (7)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Fingon by mormy

[Rikae]

I would suggest it ought to be a hurt and a heal - otherwise the points are just likely to skyrocket.

[Macalaure]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (7)
Maedhros (8)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Fingon by mormy

Let's see how it's going to work. If it doesn't work, we'll do it differently next time.

[the phantom]

Hurt Melian

Melian (6)
Maedhros (8)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Fingon by mormy

[Mnemosyne]

Heal Finrod

Melian (6)
Maedhros (8)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (6)
Maedhros (7)
Finrod (7)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[mormegil]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (6)
Maedhros (7)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Rikae]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (6)
Maedhros (7)
Finrod (5)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[the phantom]

Hurt Melian

Melian (5)
Maedhros (7)
Finrod (5)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Mnemosyne]

Heal Finrod.

Melian (5)
Maedhros (7)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Lalaith]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (5)
Maedhros (6)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[the phantom]

You can only do one or the other, Lal. :)

EDIT: never mind

[Eönwë]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (5)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (6)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (5)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (5)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[wilwarin538]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (5)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[the phantom]

Let's keep everyone moving down...

Hurt Melian

Melian (4)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Gordis]

Hurt Melian

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Macalaure]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (3)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Mnemosyne]

Heal Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (4)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Rikae]

Heal Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Eönwë]

Heal Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (5)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

edit: fixed

[the phantom]

And the numbers get smaller...

Hurt Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Macalaure]

Heal Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (5)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac
Fingon by moorm

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (4)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac

[the phantom]

You didn't count your own vote, Mac. ;)

[Mnemosyne]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac

[Macalaure]

Corrected number:

Melian (3)
Maedhros (4)
Finrod (4)

[wilwarin538]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)
Finrod (4)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac

[the phantom]

Tie game!!

Hurt Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)
Finrod (3)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Mac

[mormegil]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)
Finrod (2)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Macaroon

[Macalaure]

Hurt Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)
Finrod (1)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Macaroon

[Gordis]

Kill Finrod

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)
Finrod (0) gets eaten...

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Macaroon
Finrod by Gordis
__________________

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (2)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Macaroon
Finrod by Gordis

[the phantom]

Tie again!! :)

Heal Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (3)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantoom
Turgon by moorm
Ungoliant by Monsieur Legato
Ecthelion by Odi-wen
Thuringwethil by Odi-wen
Azaghâl by Monsieur Legato
Fëanor by the Goddess of Memory
Lúthien by Phantoom
Miriel by Phantoom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantoom
Turin by Phantoom
Hurin by Phantoom
Mîm by Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantoom
Ulmo by Sir Macaroon
Finrod by Gordis

[Groin Redbeard]

Nasty elves! This is what I like, no matter which one I pick to hurt it's the right choice.

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (2)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[Lalaith]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (1)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[mormegil]

Hurt Melian


Melian (2)
Maedhros (1)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Melian

Melian (3)
Maedhros (1)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[Nogrod]

Heal Maedhros

Melian (3)
Maedhros (2)

That was close!!!


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[the phantom]

Tie again!! :)

Hurt Melian

Melian (2)
Maedhros (2)

Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[Macalaure]

Heal Maedhros

Melian (2)
Maedhros (3)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

(edited phantom in)

[Rikae]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (2)
Maedhros (2)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Maedhros

Melian (2)
Maedhros (1)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[Nogrod]

Hurt Melian

Melian (1)
Maedhros (1)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac

[the phantom]

Kill Melian

Melian (0) *dies*
Maedhros (1)


Eliminated:
Thingol by Phantom
Turgon by The Blacksword
Ungoliant by Darth Legate
Ecthelion by Oddie
Thuringwethil by Oddie
Azaghâl by Darth Legate
Fëanor by Eminem
Lúthien by Phantom
Miriel by Phantom
Aredhel by Sir Mac
Morwen by Phantom
Turin by Phantom
Hurin by Phantom
Mîm by ++Nilp
Huan by Skip & Phantom
Ulmo by Mac
Finrod by Gordis
Melian by Phantom

EDIT: Are we missing a couple people off the kill list? Where's Fingon?

[Nogrod]

Yay tp! Well done! :)

It's co-operation and timing that counts!

[Macalaure]

That was a pretty exciting finish. :)

[the phantom]

Whew! That was close!

Nice double punch there Nog. :D

[Nogrod]

That was a pretty exciting finish. :)Absolutely so!

And really. I have not been lurking back there all the time just to come in with the decisive moment but when I saw the situation a few minutes ago I had to hang around to see it to the end.

You know I was really crossing fingers who would come next if I decided to hurt Melian and not to heal Maedhros, but when I saw tp would be four votes away I counted on him to make the day - and he did!

[Rikae]

I would have been happy with either of them winning (but would have preferred Maglor :().

:D

[mormegil]

I can say that after Turin and Huan, Maedhros is who I wanted to win and Melian would have been fourth so I'm fairly happy, but you Turin haters should be ashamed.

[Rikae]

And really. I have not been lurking back there all the time just to come in with the decisive moment but when I saw the situation a few minutes ago I had to hang around to see it to the end.


Us too, I had just finished beating Mac at Settlers of Catan. ;)

[Nogrod]

but you Turin haters should be ashamed.Whoever they are, they should.

Us too, I had just finished beating Mac at Settlers of Catan.Sounds like a nice afternoon at home... :)

[Nogrod]

Don't get me wrong though. I think Melian is great. But she's a bit too good compared to Maedhros. Maedhros has an edge to him - a fault that makes him much more interesting as a character...

[Rikae]

Sounds like a nice afternoon at home... :)

Afternoon and late night in different hemispheres, but yeah. Heheh...

I generally like the flawed characters too - and, for the record, didn't hurt Turin because of his tragic flaws, if you will, but because I just find him... creepy, somehow. (And this from a Grima fan...)

[mormegil]

Any interest in a round 3?

[Gordis]

Any interest in a round 3?

Only in LOTR now ;)

[mormegil]

Only in LOTR now ;)

That was my thought too.

[Thinlómien]

Yay! The top three (or actually top four) are all my favourites and Maedhros might be my most favourite ever. Well played, everybody. :D ;)