Hurt and Heal Hobbit Edition

[mormegil]

Same rules as before:

From 20 to 7 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts are allowed.

From 6 to 4 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts ar not allowed: a player has to hurt 2 different characters and heal one, or he may use only 1 hurt and 1 heal.

When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.

Wait for at least four posters to vote prior to you voting again.

These rules can change whenever deemed appropriate.

Hobbits is the theme. I wonder if it possible to not repeat previous hobbits. I doubt when we get to other races this would be possible so repeats are okay. Let's get nominations....

[Mnemosyne]

I nominate Lalia the Fat, Estella Bolger, Diamond of Long Cleeve, and Rosie Cotton.

ETA: It'd probably be possible to do a whole list of "no repeats," but only by including the entire Gamgee brood or other* characters in Appendix C about whom we know nothing but a name.

*Although since we have an Epilogue we know something about some of said brood; and in fact a number of them are predicted by Frodo in the actual text...

[mormegil]

Nothing but a name seems a bit boring to me.

[the phantom]

Here's a couple that might not have been participants before-

Rory Brandybuck, Sancho Proudfoot, Odo Proudfoot, Ted Sandyman, Nob

[Tuor in Gondolin]

How about Deagol , Adelard Took ,
Merry , Pippin , and Bandobras Took .

[Kent2010]

Others...

Tom Cotton
Dora Baggins
Bilbo

[Gordis]

I vote to have main hobbit characters again, even if they had already participated in the previous games. How can a hobbit competition go without Frodo and Sam?:rolleyes: Unfair, preciousss...
After all, it is HOBBIT game - it is not soon they would get another chance.;)

Maybe we can just list MAIN hobbit characters and then bring the list up to 20 with additional characters on a two-votes basis?

So I propose the following "main" list:

Smeagol (pre-Gollum period)
Bilbo
Frodo
Sam
Merry
Pippin
The Gaffer
Farmer Maggot
Fatty Bolger
Nob
Rosie Cotton
Farmer Cotton
Lotho S-B
Lobelia

What do you think?

[mormegil]

I'm good with that Gordis...others?

We could include Deagol then too and Smeagol's grandmother. Does she have a name?

[Gordis]

If you all aghree to include all the principal hobbit characters, then we have

Main list - principal LOTR characters (14)

Smeagol (pre-Gollum period)
Bilbo
Frodo
Sam
Merry
Pippin
The Gaffer
Farmer Maggot
Fatty Bolger
Nob
Rosie Cotton
Farmer Cotton
Lotho S-B
Lobelia

Additional characters (to choose 6)

Two votes (already included):
Deagol

One vote (need one more vote):
Lalia the Fat
Estella Bolger
Diamond of Long Cleeve
Rory Brandybuck
Sancho Proudfoot
Odo Proudfoot
Ted Sandyman
Adelard Took
Bandobras Took
Dora Baggins
Smeagol's grandmother - nameless, I think.


If you second a character or nominate more, please update and repost the list as we do in the game.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

How about Mayor Will Whitfoot?

[the phantom]

I'll second Mayor Will. And doesn't anyone want to second Rory Brandybuck, Sancho Proudfoot, Odo Proudfoot, or Ted Sandyman? :(

[the phantom]

Oh, and I also second Bandobras Took.

[Kent2010]

I'll second Mayor Will. And doesn't anyone want to second Rory Brandybuck, Sancho Proudfoot, Odo Proudfoot, or Ted Sandyman? :(

I will second Rory Brandybuck and Ted Sandyman, but not the Proudfeet

[mormegil]

I will second Sancho

[Gordis]

So, we have 20, it seems, if we all agree on the main list.

Main list - principal LOTR characters (14)
Smeagol (pre-Gollum period)
Bilbo
Frodo
Sam
Merry
Pippin
The Gaffer
Farmer Maggot
Fatty Bolger
Nob
Rosie Cotton
Farmer Cotton
Lotho S-B
Lobelia

Additional characters (to choose 6)

Two votes (already included):
Deagol
Mayor Will Whitfoot
Bandobras Took
Rory Brandybuck
Ted Sandyman
Sancho Proudfoot

One vote (need one more vote):
Lalia the Fat
Estella Bolger
Diamond of Long Cleeve
Odo Proudfoot
Adelard Took
Dora Baggins
Smeagol's grandmother

[mormegil]

Is everybody okay with this list? If so, let's proceed.

Smeagol (10)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (10)
Sam (10)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (10)
Lobelia (10)
Deagol (10)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (10)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[mormegil]

Hurt Rosie and Ted Heal Sam

Smeagol (10)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (10)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (10)
Lobelia (10)
Deagol (10)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (9)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, double-hurt Ted Sandyman.

Smeagol (10)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (10)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (10)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (10)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[the phantom]

Hurt Deagol, Hurt Lotho, Heal Rory

Smeagol (10)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (10)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (9)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Gordis]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hurt Ted, Hurt Lotho, Heal Gaffer

Smeagol (10)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (10)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (8)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Kent2010]

Double hurt Smeagol

Heal Rosie

Smeagol (8)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (10)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (8)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Nogrod]

I'm praying none of the six first in the line will win and do my best to prevent it... Nothing against anyone of them though, they're quite great characters all of them but it's just soo booring they end up winning all and leave others as mere statists.

So double hurt Frodo, heal farmer Maggot

Smeagol (8)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (8)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Aganzir]

Nog I agree with you but that was an evil choice!

Heal Frodo, hurt Teddy & Sméagol.

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (9)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (8)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[the phantom]

I agree to a certain extent Nog, but I just finished rereading "Hobbit" recently and I'm rereading "Fellowship" now, and Bilbo is just so darn likable and funny and smart and cool. I may not support him to the bitter end, and may favor a lesser known character, but the fact remains that no way do I want to see him gone before some of these other people. Do we really think being a minor character alone makes one worthy of winning the trophy?

Hurt Lotho, Hurt Deagol, Heal Sancho

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (9)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (10)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (7)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Double hurt Frodo


Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (7)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (11)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Rory Brandybuck Hurt Lotho S-B Heal Ted Sandyman

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (6)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)
__________________

[Kent2010]

Hurt Smeagol and Pimple

Heal Frodo

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (11)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, hurt Rosie and Teddy.

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Deagol, Heal Bullroarer

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Nogrod]

Double hurt Frodo, heal Ted Sandyman

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (5)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Aganzir]

Why do you always have to hurt Frodo? :(:Merisu:

[Nogrod]

Why do you always have to hurt Frodo?If we hurt all of the "favourites" one by one they'll never get down as someone has time to heal them. So one needs to concentrate the votes a bit.

As I said, nothing against Frodo as such but it seems there are some others favouring this kind of approach. If you suggest we should go for Sam, Pip or Merry first, be my guest. I'd follow that as well. Now it just looks like Frodo is the first on the line...

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Lotho S-B Heal Smeagol

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (11)
Merry (10)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Aganzir]

But Frodo is much nicer than the other hobbits! :Merisu:

[Nogrod]

But Frodo is much nicer than the other hobbits! :Merisu:Go start a campaign against Merry, Pip or Sam and I'll follow you suite!

[Kent2010]

Go start a campaign against Merry, Pip or Sam and I'll follow you suite!

Smeagol isn't an option?

[Nogrod]

Smeagol isn't an option?He sure is... like number five to me - but I'm ready to help outing him even before that.

[Kent2010]

He sure is... like number five to me - but I'm ready to help outing him even before that.

Smeagol got booted by his grandmother, Frito at least provides entertaining parodies (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=js_6ZoOkjJ0).

[Gordis]

Double hurt Merry the sneaky back-stabber! Sssss...:mad:

Heal Bilbo

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (11)
Frodo (6)
Sam (11)
Merry (8)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Aganzir]

Double hurt Bilbo, heal Frodo.

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (9)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Merry (8)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

(deleted-posted too soon)

[mormegil]

Double hurt the mayor Heal Sam

Smeagol (7)
Bilbo (9)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Merry (8)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Kent2010]

Hurt Lotho and hurt Smeagol

Heal Bilbo

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Merry (8)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (2)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Nogrod]

Heal Lotho, doublehurt Merry

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Merry (6)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Gordis]

Double hurt Merry, Heal Bilbo

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (11)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Merry (4)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Fatty Bolger Hurt Sancho Proudfeet Hurt Merry

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (11)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Merry (3)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[mormegil]

A lot of Merry haters...

Double hurt Biblo and heal Merry

Smeagol (6)
Bilbo (9)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Merry (4)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Aganzir]

Double-hurt Sméagol, heal Frodo.

Smeagol (4)
Bilbo (9)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Merry (4)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (3)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Kent2010]

Double hurt Pimple

Heal Merry

Smeagol (4)
Bilbo (9)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Merry (5)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (1)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Gordis]

Double hurt Merry
Heal Bilbo

Smeagol (4)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Merry (3)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (1)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Rosie Cotton Gamgee Hurt Farmer Maggot Hurt Smeagol

Smeagol (3)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Merry (3)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (1)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Mnemosyne]

Kill Lotho, hurt Smeags, heal Merry.


Smeagol (2)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Merry (4)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lotho S-B (0) om nom nom nom
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)


The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne

Fellow snipers are encouraged to snipe. ^_^

[Aganzir]

Kill Sméagol. heal Frodo.

Smeagol (0)
Bilbo (10)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Merry (4)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lobelia (12)
Deagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (10)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)


The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Double-hurt Rorimac.
Heal Digol.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Merry (4)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Gordis]

Double-hurt Merry.
Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Merry (2)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Rosie Cotton Hurt Ted Sandyman Hurt Rory Brandybuck
Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Merry (2)
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[the phantom]

Kill Merry, Heal Maggot

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Merry (0) *trampled by the horses of Rohan*
Pippin (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Merry by Phantom

[Nogrod]

What a disorder!!!

Shame on you! Bright people! It's not that hard to keep the tally on! :rolleyes:

Doublehurt Pippin, heal Ted Sandyman.

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Pippin (8)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (10)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom the unorganised

[Kent2010]

Hurt Pippin and hurt Deagol

Heal Farmer C

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (12)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom the unorganised

[Tuor in Gondolin]

A trouble with this particular game is that
there aren't many (dislikeable?) characters.
Even the S-B's.
Selecting hurts isn't nearly as easy as in other contests.


:)

[Nogrod]

A trouble with this particular game is that
there aren't many (dislikeable?) characters.
Even the S-B's.Totally agreed. So let's get rid of the "obvious winners" and let's then see who emerges victorious!

Having Frodo, Bilbo or Sam there in the final two would be such an anticlimax!

[Gordis]

IMO, the trouble with HOBBIT game is that there aren't any likeable characters. :D Kill them all!

Hurt Sam and hurt Maggot

Heal Lobelia

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (11)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[Aganzir]

Hurt Déagol & Sandyman. Heal Lobelia (who is the most likeable character here <3). :smokin:

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (9)
Sam (11)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

By the way Gordis you forgot to add a point to Lobelia. I corrected it. :)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Originally posted by Gordis
IMO, the trouble with HOBBIT game is that there aren't any likeable characters. Kill them all!
Hmm. That's a bit dark. Although this could be sour grapes coming
from a shade of Carn Dum (ticked off with TB saving all those nice
hobbits). :)

Double Hurt Frodo Heal Farmer Maggot
Bilbo (11)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[Aganzir]

Tuor you skipped my post. :p

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Tuor you skipped my post.
Oops! Corrected (I hope).
Double Hurt Frodo Heal Farmer Maggot

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (7)
Sam (11)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Ladyship Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[mormegil]

Double hurt Bilbo Heal Sam

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Double-hurt Rory.
Heal Digol.

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Duckness Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[Gordis]

Double-hurt Maggot
Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (7)
Sam (12)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Duckness Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[Aganzir]

Double-hurt Sandyman, heal Frodo.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Pippin (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (3)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Duckness Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Pippin Heal The Gaffer

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (11)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (14)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (3)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

The Dead:
Lotho Sackville-Baggins by Her Duckness Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by phantom

[mormegil]

Double Hurt Lob Heal Nob

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (12)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (3)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Kent2010]

Double hurt Sam

Heal Sandyman

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (10)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (4)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

[Gordis]

Double hurt Sam

Heal Fatty

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (8)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (12)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (4)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)
__________________

[the phantom]

Hurt Fatty, Hurt Rosie, Heal Maggot

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (8)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Ted Sandyman (4)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Double-hurt Ted (he's disgusting!), heal Rory Brandybuck.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (8)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Ted Sandyman (2)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom

[mormegil]

Kill Ted Heal Sam

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (8)
Sam (9)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Nogrod]

Double hurt Frodo, heal Bandobras

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (9)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (10)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Gordis]

Double hurt Rosie, heal Bilbo

Bilbo (11)
Frodo (6)
Sam (9)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (8)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Rosie Cotton Hurt Bilbo Hurt Rory Brandybuck

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (9)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (12)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Maggot

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (9)
Pippin (5)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Aganzir]

Double-hurt Pippin, heal Lobelia.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (9)
Pippin (3)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (13)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[mormegil]

Double hurt Lob Heal Sam

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (10)
Pippin (3)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Gordis]

Double hurt Rosie Heal Lobelia

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (6)
Sam (10)
Pippin (3)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (7)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Nogrod]

Doublehurt Frodo, heal the Gaffer

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (4)
Sam (10)
Pippin (3)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (7)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (12)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Double-hurt Bandobras.
Heal Digol.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (4)
Sam (10)
Pippin (3)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (7)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Aganzir]

Hurt Rosie, hurt Pippin, heal Lobelia.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (4)
Sam (10)
Pippin (2)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (6)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (13)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Rosie Cotton Double Hurt Lobelia

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (4)
Sam (10)
Pippin (2)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (7)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil

[Mnemosyne]

Kill Pippin Heal Frodo

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (5)
Sam (10)
Pippin (0) *trampled by fangirls*
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (7)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[mormegil]

Double Hurt Bilbo Heal Sam

Bilbo (8)
Frodo (5)
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (7)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Gordis]

Heal Bilbo Hurt Sam and Rosie

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (5)
Sam (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (6)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (5)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Deagol, Heal Rory

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (5)
Sam (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (6)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Nogrod]

A one-track mind then? Nope. :D

After Frodo and Sam (and probably Bilbo as well) are gone I'll be more flexible... Now it seems Frodo is the one we can out first.

Doublehurt Frodo, heal Bandobras

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (3)
Sam (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (6)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Mithalwen]

Doublehurt Rosie - it would be a mercy killing really. 13 children is too much for anyone ... let alone the environmental impact...

Heal Rory

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (3)
Sam (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (4)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Aganzir]

Double hurt Rosie, heal Lobelia.

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (3)
Sam (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (2)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (12)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Rosie Cotton Double Hurt Lobelia

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (3)
Sam (10)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (11)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (3)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (10)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[mormegil]

Double Hurt Fatty Heal Sam

Bilbo (9)
Frodo (3)
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (3)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (10)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Gordis]

Ahh... the smell of blood... :p

Hurt Frodo Hurt Rosie Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (2)
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (2)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (10)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Kill Frodo.
Heal Digol.

Bilbo (10)
Frodo (0) *spider got you?*
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (2)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (10)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp

[the phantom]

Kill Rosie, Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (11)
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Rosie Cotton (0) *Sam offs her to collect life insurance*
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (10)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Double hurt Bilbo, heal Lobelia.

Bilbo (9)
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (11)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Lobelia Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (10)
Sam (11)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (9)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp

[Gordis]

Double Hurt Sam Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (11)
Sam (9)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (9)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp

[Mnemosyne]

Double-hurt Sam; heal Rory.

With both his wife and master gone, Sam's got nothing left to live for. Should've thought that over, Morm.

Bilbo (11)
Sam (7)
The Gaffer (11)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (9)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Sam

Bilbo (11)
Sam (8)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (9)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom

[mormegil]

Double Hurt Lob Heal Samwise

Bilbo (11)
Sam (9)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Sam (and Bilbo) to go. Oh, big time!

Doublehurt Sam, heal Lobelia

Bilbo (11)
Sam (7)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Sam Heal The Gaffer

Bilbo (11)
Sam (5)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp

[Gordis]

Double Hurt Sam Heal Fatty

Bilbo (11)
Sam (3)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp

[Nogrod]

Yay! Way to go!

[Mnemosyne]

I really wanted to have the honors of offing Master Gamgee, but I'm not going to be in for the eventide and he's so darn close I can't resist.

Double Hurt Sam Heal Sancho

Bilbo (11)
Sam (1)
The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp

So, who's it gonna be? :smokin:

[the phantom]

*sigh*

Morm will hate me for this, but there's no way he's surviving at this point.

Kill Sam, Hurt Gaffer, Heal Rory

Bilbo (11)
Sam (0) *crushed by falling mallorn tree*
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (9)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, double-hurt Bilbo.

Bilbo (9)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (9)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (9)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[mormegil]

Cowards! Each and every one of you are blooming cowards! How dare you strike down such a noble and good hobbit as Master Samwise, why he never did harm to a soul and enriched all hobbits, dwarves, man, and elves, all the free people of Middle-earth and you haven't the decency to allow him the dignity his station deserves. Did he ask anything of anybody? Nay, and yet he gave so much of himself, more I daresay than any that lived in Middle-earth. All of you should be ashamed and know that there is a strong mark against your honor.

Now with that...

Double hurt Lob Heal Nob

Bilbo (9)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (13)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (8)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (9)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Lobelia Hurt Rory Brandybuck Heal Mayor Will Whitfoot

Bilbo (9)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (13)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Nogrod]

How dare you strike down such a noble and good hobbit as Master Samwise, why he never did harm to a soul and enriched all hobbits, dwarves, man, and elves, all the free people of Middle-earth and you haven't the decency to allow him the dignity his station deserves. Did he ask anything of anybody? Nay, and yet he gave so much of himself, more I daresay than any that lived in Middle-earth. All of you should be ashamed and know that there is a strong mark against your honor.Because he's that clean and heroic. Plain and simple.

And continuing with the destruction of the self-evident idols...

Doublehurt Bilbo (I love Bilbo but in this game he will have to go as he's now the only one wrestling in a series of his own), heal Lobelia

Bilbo (7)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (13)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Aganzir]

You evil people Lobelia hasn't done anything to you!

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Nob, Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (8)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Mnemosyne]

Master Mormegil, I believe I explained myself plainly enough. To have Sam linger after the two most important people in his life are dead is the utmost in cruelty (he contemplated suicide when he thought Frodo was a goner, remember?).

As far as I am concerned, a vote against Rosie or Frodo is a vote against Sam.

Consider yourself warned.

Until next time. :smokin:

[Aganzir]

Double hurt Bilbo, heal Lobelia.

Bilbo (6)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[mormegil]

Double hurt Lob Heal Nob

Bilbo (6)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Mayor Will Whitfoot Hurt Bilbo Hurt Lobelia

Bilbo (5)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (5)
Déagol (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (11)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Double-hurt Bandobras.
Heal Digol.

Bilbo (5)
The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (5)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (6)
The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (5)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (8)
Sancho Proudfoot (11)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Gordis]

Cowards! Each and every one of you are blooming cowards! How dare you strike down such a noble and good hobbit as Master Samwise, why he never did harm to a soul ...
Oh yeah? And it is said about one of the sneaking terrorists who threw into Mount Doom what amounted to a WMD? :rolleyes: It was a war-crime, plain and simple: the use of terrorists by the side that was unable to win by honorable means.:p

Think about all the innocent population of the great city of Barad-Dur, all the non-combatants left behind, think about the Black Numenorean beauties and babies and little orclings and baby-trolls!!!


Hurt Rory Hurt Sancho, Heal Bilbo

Bilbo (7)
The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (5)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Doublehurt Bilbo, heal Lobelia

Bilbo (5)
The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, double hurt Bilbo.

Bilbo (3)
The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Heal Lobelia, double hurt Bilbo.We seem to have the hang of it! I just say first "doublehurt Bilbo" and only after that "heal Lobelia". :D

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Bilbo Hurt Lobelia Heal The Gaffer
Generally Bilbo's a great character but
here it looks like it will soon be Kill Bil-bo

Bilbo (2)
The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom

[Aganzir]

We seem to have the hang of it! I just say first "doublehurt Bilbo" and only after that "heal Lobelia". :D
No, I prefer it my way. ;)

Come on people show some mercy! Poor Lobelia had to live with a horrible, petty husband and a disgusting son and still she was a good and lovely old lady. She could forgive Bilbo & Frodo despite all the evil, childish things they had done to her, whereas Bilbo just kept being mean to her.

[Gordis]

Gah! I have killed Bilbo, then realised I have posted too soon.

So- Bilbo is there trembling and defenceless. Will he survive?:eek:

[Mnemosyne]

Gah! I have killed Bilbo, then realised I have posted too soon.

So- Bilbo is there trembling and defenceless. Will he survive?:eek:

No.

Kill Bilbo; heal the Bullroarer

Bilbo (0) *realizes there's nothing left to do after beating the Old Took*
The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

phantom, it's on*.

*Number of kills accrued, that is. :smokin:

[Gordis]

Double hurt Maggot, heal lobelia

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (10)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Nogrod]

So the game has finally begun!

I'm so proud of you I'd love to hug you all! *hugs*

In what Tolkien-site would this be possible?


Okay, Sancho? Now the prof must have been in a hurry or had a bad day, and then he never came back to correct it.

It brings to mind Sancho Panza - which is a hobbit-like character to be honest. But a person named Sancho is no hobbit. Never.

Doublehurt Sancho, heal the Gaffer.

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (8)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, double-hurt Déagol.

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (4)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (8)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Double hurt the nasty Lob


The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (13)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (4)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (8)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Aganzir]

*sniff*

Morm you're evil! :(:Merisu:

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Deagol Hurt Nob Heal The Gaffer

The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (3)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (8)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Maggot

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (3)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (8)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Nogrod]

Doublehurt Sancho, heal the Gaffer

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (3)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (6)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, hurt Déagol, hurt Sancho.

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (2)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (5)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Gordis]

Kill Déagol, heal Lob

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (12)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Déagol (0) Got strangled ....
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (5)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Nob Hurt Lobelia Heal The Gaffer

The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Déagol (0) Got strangled ....
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (7)
Sancho Proudfoot (5)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne

[Durelin]

Hurt Lobelia, hurt Rory. Heal Sancho.

The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Déagol (0) Got strangled ....
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (6)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Sancho

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (11)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (7)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Aganzir]

Heal Lob, double-hurt Nob.

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (7)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[mormegil]

Heal Gaffer Double hur Lobby

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (10)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (7)

Lotho S-B by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Double-hurt Bullroarer.
Heal Lobelia.

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (7)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Gordis]

Double hurt Maggot, heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (9)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (7)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Nob Hurt Sancho Proudfoot Heal Farmer Maggot

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (8)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Maggot

The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (8)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Nogrod]

Heal the Gaffer, doublehurt Sancho

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (8)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (4)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[mormegil]

Double hurt Lob Heal Gaffer


The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (8)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (4)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Nogrod]

What is it you guys have against Lobelia? She's got character more than any average male-hobbit - and more than many on the list still alive and kicking.

If Bilbo really feared someone that person can't be low in stature indeed! Just think which kind of creatures Bilbo faced during his life and still he was afraid of Lobelia to the fullest! :)

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, double-hurt Nob.

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (4)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Sancho Proudfoot Hurt Nob Heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (5)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (3)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Gordis]

Hurt Sancho Hurt Maggot Heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (5)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis

[Mnemosyne]

Kill Sancho heal Nob

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (11)
Lobelia (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)
Sancho Proudfoot (0) *illicit tunnel collapses*

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Nogrod]

Doublehurt farmer Cotton, heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Lobelia (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Double Hurt Lob

The Gaffer (9)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal The Gaffer Hurt Bandobras Took Hurt Farmer Cotton

The Gaffer (10)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, double-hurt Gaffer.

The Gaffer (6)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Eönwë]

Hurt Nob and Rory, heal the Gaffer

The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[mormegil]

Double hurt Fatty Heal Gaffer

The Gaffer (8)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (10)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Mithalwen]

Hurt the Gaffer, Hurt Will Whitfoot, Heal Rory

The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (5)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (10)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (9)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Nogrod]

Heal the Gaffer, doublehurt Mayor Whitfoot

The Gaffer (6)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (10)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal The Gaffer Double Hurt Lobelia

The Gaffer (7)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Heal Bandobras Took Double Hurt The Gaffer

The Gaffer (5)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[mormegil]

Double Lob Heal Gaffer

The Gaffer (6)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Gaffer, Heal Lobelia

The Gaffer (4)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[Mnemosyne]

Double-hurt the Gaffer, heal the Bullroarer.

The Gaffer (2)
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne

[satansaloser2005]

Jumping in!

Kill the Gaffer, heal Fatty.

The Gaffer (0) had too many potatoes and exploded from starch overdose
Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[Gordis]

Double hurt Maggot, heal Lob

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (8)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[mormegil]

*sigh* another favorite bits the dust...

Double Lob heal Nob


Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (7)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Mayor, Heal Lobelia

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (5)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Lobelia, heal Fatty.

(Phantom, you've created a monster....)

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (5)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Double hurt the Mayor, heal Aganzir.

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (6)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (3)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[satansaloser2005]

Oh, you nassssty boy....

[Aganzir]

Heal Lobelia, hurt Whitfoot, hurt Nob.

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (7)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (2)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Lobelia Heal Mayor Will Whitfoot


Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (5)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (3)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[mormegil]

Double Lob Heal Nob

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (8)
Lobelia (3)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (3)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt Lobelia, hurt the Mayor, heal Cotton. Doo doo doo doo....

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Lobelia (2)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (2)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally

[Mnemosyne]

Kill Agan... I mean Lobelia. Heal Flourdumpling.

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Lobelia (0) *starves in the Lockholes*
Mayor Will Whitfoot (3)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne

[Aganzir]

NO you pigs how can you do that to me!!? You just killed the loveliest hobbit ever!

Double hurt Nob, heal Maggot.

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (5)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (3)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
♥ Lobelia by Mnemosyne :mad:

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

You look positively radiant in wrath, Agan dear. The anger brings out your rosy cheeks. :Merisu:

Hurt the Dumpling twice.
Heal Nob.

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (10)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (1)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne :mad:

[the phantom]

Kill Mayor, Hurt Fatty, Heal Maggot

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (9)
Mayor Will Whitfoot (0) *voted out of office*
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Doublehurt Farmer Cotton, heal Maggot

Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (7)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will Whitfoot by the hasty phantom who only kills without making effort to make a list... :rolleyes:

[mormegil]

NO you pigs how can you do that to me!!? You just killed the loveliest hobbit ever!


And I felt the same with Master Samwise and nobody so much as cared...

Kill Mayor Hurt Fatty Heal Nob
edit: hurt Bandobras instead of Mayor

Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (7)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by phantom

Edit: If you furnish another hurt Noggy I will update my score count here

[Nogrod]

Funny there's three people trying to make the kill simultaneously... :p

[Nogrod]

Edit: If you furnish another hurt Noggy I will update my score count hereI did it when I saw phantom stealing the kill...

[mormegil]

Reminder about the rules. Once we have 7 left no more double hurting. This has already been done but please do not worry about changing it as it will be too much of a bother and headache. Leave it as is but for the future you may hurt two times but it must be different characters.

[Nogrod]

Also as phantom added his other votes eventually I have now updated my tally to be as it should be. So there should be no more discrepancies there.

Thanks for reminding about the rules Morm.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

I thought the no double-hurting applies to when there are only six people left?

[Aganzir]

You look positively radiant in wrath, Agan dear. The anger brings out your rosy cheeks.
Not yet, I am afraid. Usually my cheeks turn rosy only after 10 minutes of shouting and physical fighting. :Merisu: And I didn't get angry enough to go beat my brothers yet.

Once we have 7 left no more double hurting.
I did it because the rule post on Page 1 says it's not allowed when there are 6 left. :Merisu:

Hurt Nob, hurt Cotton, heal Maggot.

Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (6)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by phantom

[satansaloser2005]

Rubbish. I was gonna kill him too, but got distracted while making my post. :(

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Well, Aganzir, you still look lovely. So there. :p

Hurt Rorimac, hurt Bullroarer, heal Nob.

Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (7)
Farmer Cotton (6)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by phantom

[the phantom]

Hurt Cotton, Hurt Nob, Heal Rory

Farmer Maggot (11)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (5)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt Maggot, heal Fatty, hurt Rory.

Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (5)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Mnemosyne]

NO you pigs how can you do that to me!!? You just killed the loveliest hobbit ever!




:Merisu:

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Bandobras Took Hurt Nob

Farmer Maggot (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (5)
Farmer Cotton (5)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[mormegil]

Hurt Maggot and Fatty Heal the Old Slowcoach



Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (6)
Farmer Cotton (5)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Well, Aganzir, you still look lovely. So there. :p
Yes I'm much better pale. ;)

Hurt Nob, hurt Cotton, heal Rory.

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (5)
Farmer Cotton (4)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[the phantom]

Heal Cotton, Hurt Fatty, Hurt Bandobras

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (5)
Farmer Cotton (5)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Hurt Nob & Cotton, heal Bandobras Took

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (4)
Farmer Cotton (4)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt both Farmers, heal Fatty

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (4)
Farmer Cotton (3)
Bandobras Took (9)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Nob Hurt Bandobras Took Heal Farmer Maggot

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (3)
Farmer Cotton (3)
Bandobras Took (8)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Hurt Fatty and Bandorabas

Why doesn't anybody seem to like Nob?

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (4)
Farmer Cotton (3)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Hurt Nob, hurt Mr Cotton. Heal Mr Brandybuck.

Farmer Maggot (9)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (3)
Farmer Cotton (2)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (7)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Mnemosyne]

Hurt Farmer Cotton, hurt Farmer Maggot. Heal Rory.

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (3)
Farmer Cotton (1)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (8)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[the phantom]

Kill Cotton, Hurt Fatty, Heal Nob


Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (4)
Farmer Cotton (0) *shrunk in the wash*
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (8)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Mnemosyne]

Good work, milord. Sally was trying to get to it first.

[satansaloser2005]

Phantom, I hate you. *weeps bitterly, for had fun pictures in her head of Farmer Cotton being trampled by grand-hobbits*

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Fatty Bolger Hurt Bandobras Took Hurt Rory Brandybuck

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (4)
Farmer Cotton (0) *shrunk in the wash*
Bandobras Took (6)
Rory Brandybuck (7)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Hurt Nob, hurt Rory, heal Bandobras

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (7)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[satansaloser2005]

Heal Fatty, hurt Nob and the Took.

Farmer Maggot (8)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (6)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Hurt Fatty and Maggot

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (6)
Rory Brandybuck (6)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Hurt the Took and the Brandybuck, heal Nob.

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (4)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[the phantom]

Hurt Fatty, Heal Nob

Farmer Maggot (7)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (5)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Gordis]

Hurt Maggot and Nob, Heal Fatty

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (4)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Double Hurt Fatty, Heal Bandobras

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (4)
Bandobras Took (6)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

♥

[Mnemosyne]

Fea, luv, we're past double-hurting. Sorry.

[satansaloser2005]

Heal Fatty, hurt Nob and the Maggot.

I'll update the totals when Fea gets a chance to edit her post, I promise. For now though....

Farmer Maggot (4)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (6)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Hurt Fatty and Bandobras

Farmer Maggot (4)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (4)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Farmer Maggot Hurt Nob Hurt Fatty Bolger

Farmer Maggot (5)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (5)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Nogrod]

Hurt Nob and Rory, heal Maggot

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Nogrod no triple hurting :)

Reminds me of an mst3000 episode
featuring "Deep Hurting." :D

I think it should be

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (5)
Rory Brandybuck (4)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[satansaloser2005]

Tehe. Hurt Rory and the Took, heal Fatty.

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (4)
Rory Brandybuck (3)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[mormegil]

Hurt Fatty and Bandorbas Heal Nob

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (3)
Rory Brandybuck (3)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Gordis]

Hurt Maggot and Rory. Heal Fatty

Farmer Maggot (5)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (3)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Hurt Nob, hurt Fatty, heal Maggot.

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (3)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt Maggot and Took, heal Fatty.

Farmer Maggot (5)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Farmer Maggot Hurt Fatty Bolger

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[mormegil]

Heal Nob Hurt Fatty and Maggot


Farmer Maggot (5)
Fatty Bolger (5)
Nob (3)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Mnemosyne]

Hurt Nob and Maggot; heal the Bullroarer.

[Mnemosyne]

Hurt Nob and Maggot; heal the Bullroarer.

Farmer Maggot (4)
Fatty Bolger (5)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (3)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

Methinks I sense a stalemate...

[satansaloser2005]

Heal Fatty, hurt Maggot and Took. That's right, people, I went there.

Farmer Maggot (3)
Fatty Bolger (6)
Nob (2)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[Aganzir]

Heal Maggot, hurt Fatty, hurt Nob.

Farmer Maggot (4)
Fatty Bolger (5)
Nob (1)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom

[the phantom]

Kill Nob
Hurt Fatty
Heal Rory

Farmer Maggot (4)
Fatty Bolger (4)
Nob (0) *fired by Barliman*
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (3)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom
Nob by Phantom

[mormegil]

You are all terrible. We have some awfully bland characters left with one possible exception...

Anyway hurt Fatty and Rory heal Maggot


Farmer Maggot (5)
Fatty Bolger (3)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom
Nob by Phantom

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Farmer Maggot Hurt Fatty Bolger Hurt Rory Brandybuck

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (2)
Bandobras Took (2)
Rory Brandybuck (1)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom

[Mnemosyne]

Kill Rory. Hurt the Bullroarer. Heal Fatty.

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (3)
Bandobras Took (1)
Rory Brandybuck (0) O'Ded on Old Winyards lol.

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom
Rorimac by Mnemosyne

We're down to three, which means one hurt OR heal per post, correct?

*rubs hands together cunningly*

[Eönwë]

Heal the horse-rider


Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (3)
Bandobras Took (2)


Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom
Rorimac by Mnemosyne

[satansaloser2005]

Haha, tough luck, Steve.

Wait, what the heck am I doing? Heal Fatty!


Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (4)
Bandobras Took (2)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom
Rory by Mnemo

[Mnemosyne]

Eonwe: FALSE!!!

And dude, Rory is the Master. ^_^

Of Buckland.

[Aganzir]

Sally you can't kill Bandobras - Eönwë healed him.

[Aganzir]

Kill Bandobras. Okay hurt him then since sally didn't want to hurt him! :(

Farmer Maggot (6)
Fatty Bolger (4)
Bandobras Took (1)

Lotho by Mnemosyne
Sméagol by Aganzir
Merry by Phantom
Ted by Mormegil
Pippin by Mnemosyne
Frodo by Nilp
Rosie by Phantom
Sam by Phantom
Bilbo by Mnemosyne
Déagol by Gordis
Sancho by Mnemosyne
Gaffer by Sally
Lobelia by Mnemosyne
Mayor Will by Phantom
Cotton by Phantom
Rory by Mnemo

[satansaloser2005]

Sally you can't kill Bandobras - Eönwë healed him.

So he did. Didn't see the edit. Fixed and edited the totals, thanks darling.


ETA: You can't either, sadly. He's at two since Steve's heal and I changed my choice accordingly.

[Eönwë]

Wait, Aganzir! You can't kill off Bandobras yet! He still has a point!

edit: Exactly, m'dear Sally