Hurt and Heal: Ladies' Round [Archive] - Page 2?login=1

Loslote

04-12-2013, 10:01 PM

++Ar-Zimraphel
--Goldberry
--Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (12)
Elwing (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (11)
Aredhel (9)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Wow. I almost forgot this was going on. :eek:

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-13-2013, 02:02 AM

Double hurt Thu
Heal Goldberry

Thuringwethil (5)
Goldberry (13)
Elwing (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (11)
Aredhel (9)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 04:05 AM

And degrading her to just "being a wife of..." is certainly not very nice, especially given that the husband in question is in fact a kidnapper, in her case.
Compare:
I think, if you say about Ar-Zimraphel that the only thing she managed to do was to lose the scepter and die, I think with Aredhel, it is kind of similar fate. Look also at that - forced to wed some abusive self-centered madman and then dies.
:p

Aredhel did what she wanted instead of what she was told, and she wouldn't be the first Tolkien character to get into trouble for that. You could even say she was the victim of a not very nice fate, comparable to the heroines of G.R.R. Martin's books...
Whether she fell for a mysterious dark stranger or was raped, she can't be blamed for it either way. And don't forget that before she died, she escaped her abusive husband (not an easy feat) and negotiated her way home - and then gave her life so her son could live. What's not cool about her?

I like Goldberry too (mainly for the reasons Legate and G55 mentioned), but I've been very tempted to hurt her at times because of her ridiculous number of points. And partly out of spite too if G55 has hurt Thuringwethil - this game can be really infuriating if somebody has altogether different opinions about everyone. Legate probably knows how I feel. :p

As for Nerdanel, she's about the only person ever, apart from Finwë, who had any control whatsoever over Fëanor. She must have been massively talented anyway, considering how much of her fëa she spent carrying seven children.

Another thing I find cool about Thuringwethil is that if we assume she's an actual person instead of just Lúthien in a bat costume she found on Tol-in-Gaurhoth (which I do), the fact that there's a winged messenger travelling between Morgoth and Sauron is awesome. And female, too. Apart from the spiders, she's the only named female villain. Think of how much terror she must have sown on her errands, even if all she did was fly!

Also, those of you who're constantly trying to hurt Thû - he's male, he's not in! ;)

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Elwing and Ar-Zimraphel

Thuringwethil (6)
Goldberry (13)
Elwing (6)
Ar-Zimraphel (10)
Aredhel (9)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-13-2013, 06:47 AM

Heal Thuringwethil
Double Hurt Goldberry

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (11)
Elwing (6)
Ar-Zimraphel (10)
Aredhel (9)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-13-2013, 06:50 AM

I see Vaire is cleverly weaving a tapestry of letting others
indulge in "bloodletting" while she indulges her artistic tendencies.

Heal Thuringwethil
Double Hurt Goldberry

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (11)
Elwing (6)
Ar-Zimraphel (10)
Aredhel (9)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 08:13 AM

I see Vaire is cleverly weaving a tapestry of letting others
indulge in "bloodletting" while she indulges her artistic tendencies.
I just went through the entire thread in order to avoid revising my thesis. All that has happened to Vairë is that you healed her once. Literally. All. That might be some sort of record. :D

Galadriel55

04-13-2013, 08:38 AM

++Goldberry
--Aredhel
--Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (12)
Elwing (6)
Ar-Zimraphel (10)
Aredhel (8)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

the phantom

04-13-2013, 10:00 AM

Double Hurt Goldberry
Heal Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (10)
Elwing (6)
Ar-Zimraphel (10)
Aredhel (8)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

the phantom

04-13-2013, 10:07 AM

But for some reason, I like Zimraphel more. Probably because she is human. And also has cooler name, but that's a detail.
Okay, I can see voting based on names. In that case... Ar-Zimraphel and Thuringwethil are clearly awesome, whereas Goldberry is eye-rollingly silly. I mean- imagine someone named Redmelon, or Orangeberry, or Blueapple. The only reason it's not apparent how equally silly Goldberry's name is, is that we got used to hearing it.

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 10:28 AM

Heal Thuringwethil
Double hurt Elwing

Thuringwethil (8)
Goldberry (10)
Elwing (4)
Ar-Zimraphel (10)
Aredhel (8)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-13-2013, 10:36 AM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Aredhel Hurt Ar-Zimraphel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (10)
Elwing (4)
Ar-Zimraphel (9)
Aredhel (7)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 10:36 AM

Okay, I can see voting based on names. In that case... Ar-Zimraphel and Thuringwethil are clearly awesome, whereas Goldberry is eye-rollingly silly. I mean- imagine someone named Redmelon, or Orangeberry, or Blueapple. The only reason it's not apparent how equally silly Goldberry's name is, is that we got used to hearing it.
Let me see, who have we left?

Woman of Secret Shadow (8)
Goldberry (10)
Star Spray (4)
(High) Jewel Daughter (10)
Noble Elf (8)
mystery woman whose name is unknown but derives maybe from 'large, strong man' (6)
Weaver (11)

Based on this, I should be saving Elwing along with Thuringwethil.

Galadriel55

04-13-2013, 10:40 AM

Well, name-wise I would get rid of Ar-Zimraphel, because I can't stand that name. Tar-Miriel sounds nice, but Ar-Z is plain awful.

++Goldberry
--Ar-Zimraphel
--Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (8)
Goldberry (11)
Elwing (4)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (7)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 10:44 AM

And the dead... (still avoiding schoolwork)

Maiden crowned by a radiant garland- phialed off by TP
Old Spider- swatted by TP
Patience- aged by TP
Old Woman- quieted by TP
Mourning- mercy-killed by TP
She Who Weeps- left crying by TP
Giver of Fruits- pruned by TP
Sparkling Brilliance- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Lonely Wife- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Beauty- weeded out by TP

Galadriel55

04-13-2013, 11:05 AM

Shelob- stepped on by TP

She-spider?

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 11:13 AM

She-spider?
Sorry, I thought lob was a normal word. :p

the phantom

04-13-2013, 12:19 PM

Double Hurt Goldberry
Heal Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (8)
Goldberry (9)
Elwing (4)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (7)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

the phantom

04-13-2013, 12:22 PM

And now Vaire is the only one with double-digits. Which is completely fitting since she's so awesome and famous.

Oh, no wait- she just weaves stuff.

Basically she's an artisan like Nerdanel, only without any of Nerdanel's other credentials. But silly me- why keep Nerdanel alive when we can instead have a less rounded and interesting version?

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 12:25 PM

Heal Thuringwethil
Double hurt Elwing

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (9)
Elwing (2)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (7)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-13-2013, 12:29 PM

Heal Elwing
Hurt Aredhel Hurt Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (9)
Elwing (3)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (11)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

satansaloser2005

04-13-2013, 01:26 PM

Hurt Elwing and Vaire. Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (9)
Elwing (2)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (10)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP

the phantom

04-13-2013, 01:50 PM

Kill Elwing
Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (9)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (7)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (10)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Aganzir

04-13-2013, 02:42 PM

Hurt Ar-Zimraphel and Vairë
Heal Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (11)
Goldberry (9)
Ar-Zimraphel (7)
Aredhel (7)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Galadriel55

04-13-2013, 03:48 PM

++Goldberry
--Thu
--Aredhel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (10)
Ar-Zimraphel (7)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 01:57 AM

Hurt Thu (Agan, here is the difference. I assume you can read well enough to see a difference between "Thu" as abbreviation for Thuringwethil, and "Thû", which, as you pointed out correclty, is a completely different name, because of the umlaut, which nobody had ever used for Thuringwethil :p ) and Aredhel, heal Ar-Zimraphel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (10)
Ar-Zimraphel (8)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-14-2013, 06:24 AM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Goldberry Hurt Ar-Zimraphel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (9)
Ar-Zimraphel (7)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

the phantom

04-14-2013, 08:05 AM

Hurt Goldberry
Hurt Vaire
Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (8)
Ar-Zimraphel (7)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (8)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 10:58 AM

Hurt Goldberry.
Hurt Ar-Zimraphel.
Heal Nerdanel.

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (6)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (8)
Vairë (8)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 11:03 AM

--Thu
--Nerdanel
++Vaire

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (6)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 11:08 AM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Ar-Zimraphel and Vairë

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (5)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (8)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-14-2013, 11:36 AM

Heal Vaire
Hurt Ar-Zimraphael Hurt Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (4)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 11:44 AM

Heal Thuringwethil.
Hurt Goldberry and Ar-Zimraphel.

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (6)
Ar-Zimraphel (3)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 12:13 PM

Hurt Thu and Aredhel, heal Goldberry

Thuringwethil (8)
Goldberry (8)
Ar-Zimraphel (6)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (7)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 12:19 PM

--Thu, Nerdanel
++Goldberry

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (9)
Ar-Zimraphel (6)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (9)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

the phantom

04-14-2013, 12:32 PM

Hurt Goldberry
Hurt Vaire
Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (7)
Goldberry (8)
Ar-Zimraphel (6)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (8)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 12:44 PM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Ar-Zimraphel and Vairë

Thuringwethil (8)
Goldberry (8)
Ar-Zimraphel (5)
Aredhel (6)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (7)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-14-2013, 12:45 PM

Hurt Aredhel Hurt Ar-Zimraphael
Heal Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (8)
Goldberry (8)
Ar-Zimraphel (5)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (8)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 12:45 PM

Wait, something is wrong with the numbers. I'll fix it.

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 12:48 PM

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (7)
Ar-Zimraphel (1)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (7)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Yeah, looks like Legate got stuck on the previous page, that's where it went wrong. :p

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 01:05 PM

Hurt Thu and Aredhel, heal Goldberry

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (8)
Ar-Zimraphel (1)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (7)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

the phantom

04-14-2013, 01:06 PM

Kill Ar-Z
Hurt Goldberry
Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (7)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (7)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Ar-Zim- tsunami-ed by TP

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 01:12 PM

Hurt Goldberry and Vairë (and in the process remember that my iDevice can do ë). Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (6)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Ar-Zim- tsunami-ed by TP

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 01:30 PM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Vairë and Aredhel

Thuringwethil (11)
Goldberry (6)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Ar-Zim- tsunami-ed by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 01:31 PM

Hurt Thu and Nerdanel
Heal Vairë

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (6)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Ar-Zim- tsunami-ed by TP

the phantom

04-14-2013, 01:32 PM

Hurt Goldberry & Vaire
Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (5)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Ar-Zim- tsunami-ed by TP

Tuor in Gondolin

04-14-2013, 01:41 PM

Heal Vaire
Hurt Thuringwethil Hurt Aredhel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (5)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 01:45 PM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Vairë and Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (5)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (4)
Vairë (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 01:45 PM

Hurt Thu
Heal Vairë

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (5)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (4)
Vairë (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

the phantom

04-14-2013, 01:46 PM

Hurt Goldberry & Vaire
Heal Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (4)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 01:56 PM

Hurt Goldberry & Vaire
Heal Nerdanel

What he said.

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (3)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 01:58 PM

Come on, hurt at least the silly bat, do you see how much she has? It's ridiculous.

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 01:59 PM

I like Goldberry so I'd like to avoid the Nebraskan conspiracy against her... but the problem is, I like everyone who's left. So let's just go for my favourite again.

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Vairë and Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (3)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (3)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:00 PM

Hurt Thu, heal Goldberry

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (4)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (3)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:00 PM

Come on, hurt at least the silly bat, do you see how much she has? It's ridiculous.

I think you misspelled glorious. :smokin:

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:03 PM

Hurt Vaire & Goldberry
Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (3)
Aredhel (5)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:05 PM

I think you misspelled glorious. :smokin:

Not going to argue, sufficient to say, she should have been gone a looong time ago. In any case, she is the one of all the present ladies who deserves it the least.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:05 PM

Just because you picture Thuringwethil as Kristen Stewart doesn't mean we all do, laddie...

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:08 PM

Not going to argue, sufficient to say, she should have been gone a looong time ago. In any case, she is the one of all the present ladies who deserves it the least.
But she's not, which tells you something about how others than you view her. ;)

Phantom, I may be the first person ever to say this, but you're quite witty and funny.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:09 PM

Just because you picture Thuringwethil as Kristen Stewart doesn't mean we all do, laddie...

Ewww. I don't! I imagine her as ugly and old Kristen Stewart with long fingernails* and bat wings.

*Any similarity to any persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental and it had been so basically since I have read David Day's Tolkien's Bestiary.

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:12 PM

*bats wings*

(pun unintended)

(however, the Finnish word for a bat also means girls who like girls)

(that pun always intended)

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:17 PM

Thanks for that mental image, Legate.... :rolleyes:

Hurt Goldberry and Aredhel. Heal Nerdanel.

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (2)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (6)
Vairë (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

x'd with Agan's intriguing Finnish lesson

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:19 PM

Thanks for that mental image, Legate.... :rolleyes:
It was TP who started it! *points*

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:19 PM

Based upon Tolkien text evidence though, you're right that she doesn't deserve the title on verifiable accomplishment- but you can't say she deserves it less than Vaire. She's just as flat a character as Thuringwethil, but rather than "flying message-carrying vampire" she's "sewing lady", which seems more boring to me.

Basically, Thuringwethil has a very shaky base on which to build, but it's a fantastic base (flying + vampire), thus the possibility of constructing a marvelous character.

Now Goldberry we've actually seen a bit thanks to Frodo's detour, so she's justifiable- I won't say she's not at all. But then it depends on taste when it comes to that- I recall she and Tom had an allure that was "nearer to the mortal heart" or some such, rather than "keen and lofty" like elves etc. So then the question is, do you identify more with Hobbits and men, or with the Noldor?

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:19 PM

Heal Thuringwethil
Hurt Vairë and Nerdanel
Because out of Aredhel and Nerdanel, I kind of like Aredhel better. It's a really tough choice though.

Thuringwethil (10)
Goldberry (2)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (1)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:21 PM

Hurt Thu, heal GB

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (3)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (5)
Vairë (1)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:22 PM

Oh, Phaaaaaaaaaaantom....

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:22 PM

Kill Vaire
Hurt Goldberry
Heal Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (2)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vaire- needled by TP

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:24 PM

Basically, Thuringwethil has a very shaky base on which to build, but it's a fantastic base (flying + vampire), thus the possibility of constructing a marvelous character.
And that's exactly it. Typical stereotype. A sewing lady (who makes the tapestry of history, nonetheless!) is less interesting than a winged vampire.

Now Goldberry we've actually seen a bit thanks to Frodo's detour, so she's justifiable- I won't say she's not at all. But then it depends on taste when it comes to that- I recall she and Tom had an allure that was "nearer to the mortal heart" or some such, rather than "keen and lofty" like elves etc. So then the question is, do you identify more with Hobbits and men, or with the Noldor?

Hey, but have you seen Frodo's impression of her? Totally Elvish. (And Frodo was more Elvish than Hobbittish, I would say, comparing his taste of things to that of Sam and all, they were the Hobbits, but he really was pretty Elvish in general. Definitely Elvish for a Hobbit, but even for a "human".)

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:25 PM

Hurt Goldberry and Aredhel. Heal Nerdanel.

Thuringwethil (9)
Goldberry (1)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (7)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:26 PM

Heal Thuringwethil
Kill Goldberry
Hurt Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (10)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Now everyone has either a hurt or a heal left.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:29 PM

Hurt boring bat

Thuringwethil (9)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by Aganzir

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:31 PM

What's that, Legate? Why is the phantom allowed to write his name in caps but I'm not?

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:33 PM

What's that, Legate? Why is the phantom allowed to write his name in caps but I'm not?

To be fair, his is initials, not his full name, but I say you should be in all caps for getting a kill off the lad (and a good kill at that). :smokin:

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:35 PM

And that's exactly it. Typical stereotype. A sewing lady (who makes the tapestry of history, nonetheless!) is less interesting than a winged vampire.
Yes, well, what's that quote about awful/scary things making for long, interesting stories, but years of beauty and peace are swiftly summarized in a sentence or two...

Certainly there's a part of me that is uncomfortable with that, but it remains true for the most part. Thuringwethil was a player in the middle of a long and bloody conflict, while Vaire hung about in Valinor. The potential is just so far apart for interesting/cool stories we could invent.

That isn't to say that I wouldn't be fond of Vaire in real life- she could have a fun sense of humor and possess other talents and a pleasant disposition. So if this contest were for naming, "Which people do you want at your dinner-party?" then I'd vote for her over Thuringwethil most likely. The vampire would just be too great a risk, what with my tasty jugular and all...

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:37 PM

Let's even things up a bit...

Heal Aredhel

Thuringwethil (9)
Aredhel (4)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by Aganzir

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:37 PM

Actually, funnily, my dinner party guests would be the three ladies left here. Which effectively means that no matter who wins, I'm perfectly happy.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:39 PM

Hurt Aredhel.

Thuringwethil (9)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by Aganzir THE DEADLY

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:40 PM

Hurt Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (9)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:41 PM

I was going to make some sort of joke about capitalizing my name based upon divinity (in keeping with the Biblical tradition), but it seemed a bit sacrilegious. Particularly on a Sunday, right?

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:42 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (8)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:44 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:46 PM

Heal Nerdanel.

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:48 PM

Hurt Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 02:51 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

the phantom

04-14-2013, 02:51 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (5)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 02:58 PM

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 02:59 PM

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:01 PM

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:03 PM

Heal Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:04 PM

Hurt Aredhel.

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (2)
Nerdanel (6)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 03:04 PM

I leave for a couple hours and you write two pages of posts and kill both my favourites? Go bugger.

++Thu

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:05 PM

Hurt Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (2)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:07 PM

Correcting.

Thuringwethil (7)
Aredhel (2)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:08 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (2)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:10 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (5)
Aredhel (2)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:10 PM

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (2)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:12 PM

Hurt Aredhel

Thuringwethil (6)
Aredhel (1)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:13 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (5)
Aredhel (1)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:14 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (4)
Aredhel (1)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:15 PM

Kill Aredhel.

Thuringwethil (4)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:16 PM

Heal Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (5)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:17 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (4)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:17 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:18 PM

Heal Thuringwethil.

Then again, at this point, I'm comfy with the options.

Thuringwethil (4)
Nerdanel (5)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:19 PM

Hurt Nerdanel

Thuringwethil (4)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:19 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:19 PM

Hurt Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:21 PM

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:21 PM

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (4)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:22 PM

Hurt Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:23 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:26 PM

Um, why am I suddenly having trouble posting?

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:28 PM

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:28 PM

Um, why am I suddenly having trouble posting?

I guess the forum prevents us from posting the same posts in the same thread in less than five minutes :) Since it keeps going back and forth, it wants to prevent spam, which, in any other thread, it certainly would be. :D

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:28 PM

I like both, but if forced to pick I'd obviously pick Nerdanel based on actual accomplishment rather than strictly my own imaginings. She was a legendary artisan in her own right, daughter and grandmother of two of the best and wife of the very best, which is perhaps what caught his attention. Plus she's red-headed- a rarity. Plus anyone able to influence Feanor must have something very very special...

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:29 PM

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:30 PM

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:31 PM

I am not that set on any of those anymore, I could almost be persuaded to let Thu go. But, since there is nobody else left to "trade" for it, I guess I'll just keep doing that :)

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:31 PM

I like both too. Nobody can deny Nerdanel's achievements, but Thuringwethil is either

a female messenger, probably some kind of a Maia - and cool enough to use imagination in choosing her form

or

the name Lúthien took for herself after leaving Tol-in-Gaurhoth, and no one needs to be told of Lúthien's extraordinary achievements. Still, if it's her, I probably like her Thuringwethil plot the best out of everything she did.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:34 PM

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:34 PM

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:35 PM

This is getting old....

Hurt Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:37 PM

I accept bribes....

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:37 PM

a female messenger, probably some kind of a Maia - and cool enough to use imagination in choosing her form
I always imagined her to be some sort of Maia, or, in my latter years, some sort of spirit akin to that of the Werewolves - evil spirit in animal body. Which would make her, literally, a bat? Actually, is it said that she did shapechange? Was it the cloak? Or what?

Anyway, I wanted to say, you said "female messenger" - I actually never thought about it the way that she would be just a messenger and nothing more. That would be kind of interesting (probably because it's fresh idea to me).

the name Lúthien took for herself after leaving Tol-in-Gaurhoth, and no one needs to be told of Lúthien's extraordinary achievements. Still, if it's her, I probably like her Thuringwethil plot the best out of everything she did.

Actually, I always thought she did not make it up and that it was all somebody - but exactly. I think it redeems the Lúthien storyline, because otherwise it's, sorry to B&L lovers, plain boring, mostly. Maybe the part of being in Angband is more interesting. And in any case, if I like any Thuringwethil, then it is the Thuringwethil when Lúthien pretends to be her.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:38 PM

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:39 PM

I accept bribes....
I already agreed to give you a wad of cash when you come to town in a couple weeks...

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:40 PM

I accept bribes....
Thuringwethil will come and get you. And fly you to Finland. If she's alive.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:41 PM

Food. Mostly food. Also, possibly the souls of innocent children or their-what?

Heal Thuringwethil.

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:42 PM

Heal Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (4)
Nerdanel (4)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

This is like a dance.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:42 PM

Hmmm... How about- you get to select the menu at the get-together. Whether it's home-cooked, or picking the restaurant, sit down or take out, etc. etc. your word is law on the food.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:43 PM

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:44 PM

Tempting, Phantom. Very tempting....

Thuringwethil will come and get you. And fly you to Finland. If she's alive.

Oh, but this definitely wins.

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:44 PM

Not that I'd stoop so low as to bribe, of course, but I'm a pretty awesome cook...

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:44 PM

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:45 PM

A dance indeed. *whistles* Two-steps-back-two-steps-up-one-two-three-one-two-three

(Is it inappropriate that I imagined it as a waltz even though there are four "beats" in this particular dance...?)

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:46 PM

Hurt Nerdanel to at least make it closer.

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (3)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:47 PM

Heal Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (3)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:48 PM

Harm Thurwingywilly

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (3)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:48 PM

A dance indeed. *whistles* Two-steps-back-two-steps-up-one-two-three-one-two-three

(Is it inappropriate that I imagined it as a waltz even though there are four "beats" in this particular dance...?)

Dancing, you say? :Merisu:

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:48 PM

Hurt Thuwingwethwil

Thuringwethil (1)
Nerdanel (3)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:49 PM

Shall we at least bring it down to one and one, Agan?

Hurt Nerdanel.

Thuringwethil (1)
Nerdanel (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:50 PM

Shall we at least bring it down to one and one, Agan?

I think you just gave the phantom a kill. Or, if Agan heals her, then to me.

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 03:51 PM

Traitor.

Now you all will have to wait for someone else to vote before posting again. :p

the phantom

04-14-2013, 03:52 PM

Now you all will have to wait for someone else to vote before posting again.
That's what I assumed...

*twiddles thumbs*

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 03:52 PM

Traitor.

Now you all will have to wait for someone else to vote before posting again. :p

I was certain you were going to do that :)

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 03:53 PM

Traitor.

Now you all will have to wait for someone else to vote before posting again. :p

Phantom's actually close enough to cook me dinner....

Also, I figured that was coming. Fair enough.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 04:08 PM

All-righty, so, what will happen first?

Aganzir contacts help and organizes a precise time to post so that she is not passed over in the order...
or
Someone spots that Thuringwethil is sitting at 1 and steps in to claim the final kill.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 04:11 PM

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:12 PM

I don't know that either. I'm just sitting and waiting for something to happen.

Sally, do that. She hasn't been around in ages!

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:12 PM

And nobody has even tried to bribe me yet.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 04:16 PM

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:17 PM

I only offer things to those who are willing to be bribed.

Although there's an old dream I suppose I haven't told phantom about yet...

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:20 PM

No one has attempted to bribe me, either.

Perhaps they know we're far too principled to respond to such things.

*clears throat* Though I suppose, it... wouldn't be wrong to just maybe have a look and see what bribes would be offered if I was one to be bribed. Which I'm not, of course. *cough*

;)

But that's actually true, now that I think about it, I am genuinely puzzled. I understand I even sort of dismissed the possibility of bribing me, but how comes nobody tried to bribe the phantom? Granted, it is like trying to bribe Robespierre, only... never mind.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:20 PM

Notice: Yes, G55, I know you are reading this. If you can, please come and do something.

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 04:22 PM

Holy crap, you guys post a lot! What happened today to make you all so active all of a sudden?

++Thu

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:22 PM

Heal Thuringwethil

Thuringwethil (3)
Nerdanel (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:23 PM

Hurt Thu

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 04:23 PM

Which makes it

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (2)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Edit: xed with both of your lists

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 04:24 PM

Hurt Nerdanel.

Thuringwethil (2)
Nerdanel (1)

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:24 PM

Holy crap, you guys post a lot! What happened today to make you all so active all of a sudden?

And don't ask. It was already a total mess when I came.

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 04:25 PM

Kill Nerdanel. Thuringwethil wins!

DEAD
Galadriel- phialed off by TP
Ungoliant- swatted by TP
Andreth- aged by TP
Ioreth- quieted by TP
Nienor- mercy-killed by TP
Nienna- left crying by TP
Yavanna- pruned by TP
Idril- offed by TP
Lobelia- umbrella-ed by TP
Shelob- stepped on by TP
Erendis- drowned by TP
Rosie- finished by TP
Vana- weeded out by TP
Elwing- wings clipped by TP
Vairë- needled by TP
Goldberry- eaten by AGANZIR
Aredhel- impaled by Sally
Nerdanel - left childless by G55

WINNER: THURINGWETHIL

And now we shall party and eat cucumbers.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:25 PM

Kill nerdanel. Thuringwethil wins!

How boring. But hey, at least something happens.

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:25 PM

Yay! Great game. :)

Can't remember it's ever been so nerve-wracking before.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 04:26 PM

It shows how well we know one another (or how well trained we are?), that when Maria says "dream" I immediately experience a shift in hormone levels....

And yes, the incorruptible indeed. For I am far more likely to be the corrupter.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:26 PM

Yay! Great game. :)

Can't remember it's ever been so nerve-wracking before.

I think it has to do with the number of people being present. Two and two is not a good combination. Though I don't think it so nerve-wracking, but then again, neither of those was a favourite I was trying to save.

And ph, I think you mean "Aganzir" ;)

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:28 PM

It shows how well we know one another (or how well trained we are?), that when Maria says "dream" I immediately experience a shift in hormone levels....
Haha, in most cases it's appropriate.

I'll leave the dream till another time, then. If there ever is one, I mean.

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 04:31 PM

No I'm going to go and actually read what the lot of you were talking about for three pages...

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:32 PM

Hahaha, was it three pages? :D

I particularly recommend page 10. It's highly interesting, there's so much happening.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 04:32 PM

No I'm going to go and actually read what the lot of you were talking about for three pages...

Kristen Stewart, sewing, and Phantom giving me money. No, really. :rolleyes:

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 04:37 PM

You guys are ridiculous. This is worse than the last 5 minutes of a werewolf game with only a quarter of the votes in. :D

Hahaha, was it three pages? :D

I think that what you've posted in the last 24 hours is almost as long as the voting done prior. Absolutely ridiculous.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:38 PM

Kristen Stewart, sewing, and Phantom giving me money. No, really. :rolleyes:

As the intellectual and educated elite say, ROFL.

Seriously, I am very sorry for making you traumatised by that image, sally. Though it was really the phantom who first mentioned Kristen Stewart.

You guys are ridiculous. This is worse than the last 5 minutes of a werewolf game with only a quarter of the votes in. :D

It was very much like that indeed. Now I know why in WW everyone is allowed to have only one vote, and why even retractions are frowned upon.

I think that what you've posted in the last 24 hours is almost as long as the voting done prior. Absolutely ridiculous.
I think the worst was happening only during the last, what, seven hours or so. That's about as much as I've been around.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 04:39 PM

I only mentioned it because you were thinking it, Legate.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 04:42 PM

True, young sir, but this

Ewww. I don't! I imagine her as ugly and old Kristen Stewart with long fingernails* and bat wings.

*Any similarity to any persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental and it had been so basically since I have read David Day's Tolkien's Bestiary.

was entirely your doing. ;)

x'd with Phantom :D

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:44 PM

I only mentioned it because you were thinking it, Legate.

The phantom is always right, so pointless to argue.

True, young sir, but this:

Was entirely your doing.
Sure. And for that I have apologized. But the starting point was provided by the phantom.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 04:46 PM

Sure. And for that I have apologized. But the starting point was provided by [B]the phantom.

And he will be punished, I assure you.

the phantom

04-14-2013, 04:47 PM

And of course I already knew Sally was thinking of ways to punish me... Very predictable lot, you are. :p

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 04:49 PM

I think the worst was happening only during the last, what, seven hours or so. That's about as much as I've been around.

Well, I woke up a bit under 12 hours ago to a massive number of votes too. Then it stalled, when I was around, and when I left it got crazy again.

And of course I already knew Sally was thinking of ways to punish me... Very predictable lot, you are. :p

And of course we all knew that you would know. Says something about all of us, doesn't it? :rolleyes: :D

Aganzir

04-14-2013, 04:50 PM

The Kristen Steward idea is interesting given Thuringwethil's possible association with Lúthien. Just sayin'.

Edit: I'm aware of the typo, but it maxes my Tolkien geek credentials, right?

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:52 PM

Well, I woke up a bit under 12 hours ago to a massive number of votes too. Then it stalled, when I was around, and when I left it got crazy again.
Yes, I was absent basically all day yesterday, so I was shocked to see the amount, and today it's been mostly the same, only I managed to be around especially around the last part...

And of course we all knew that you would know. Says something about all of us, doesn't it? :rolleyes: :D

Eexactly.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 04:54 PM

The Kristen Steward idea is interesting given Thuringwethil's possible association with Lúthien. Just sayin'.

Edit: I'm aware of the typo, but it maxes my Tolkien geek credentials, right?

No! Because now I can scare Sally further by the image of an old, ugly, bat-winged actress with long fingernails eating cherry tomatoes in an utterly disgusting way...

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 05:33 PM

No! Because now I can scare Sally further by the image of an old, ugly, bat-winged actress with long fingernails eating cherry tomatoes in an utterly disgusting way...

Like Denethor in the movies?

And, speaking of Thuringwethil's image, what do you think of these?

http://s40.radikal.ru/i090/1207/52/8c927ec72e56.jpg

http://dreamworlds.ru/uploads/posts/2008-11/1226749711_364px-gamaun.jpg

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 05:56 PM

Like Denethor in the movies?
That was exactly what I was thinking.

And, speaking of Thuringwethil's image, what do you think of these?

And this would actually be quite nice Thuringwethil, though I am not sure if it fits, also, hmm, mood-wise. Also, mostly I would imagine her with bat wings rather than feathered (but that makes these pictures more interesting, as an innovative idea). Actually, what are these? Because I am sure I have seen them somewhere very recently. (Anyway, the second one looks also a bit like Agan. ;)) But in general, back to the Kirsten Steward (ah! And this was honestly a typo from me, so apparently it works that way) idea, if you made these much older and uglier, it would be sort of like what I was talking about.

satansaloser2005

04-14-2013, 06:02 PM

(Anyway, the second one looks also a bit like Agan. ;))

Heh, heh, heh. A tad, yes.

Galadriel55

04-14-2013, 06:08 PM

Also, mostly I would imagine her with bat wings rather than feathered (but that makes these pictures more interesting, as an innovative idea).

Me too. Just these are meant to be birds, not bats.

Actually, what are these? Because I am sure I have seen them somewhere very recently.

These are pictures of the birds from Slavic mythology. The second one is the bird Alkonost, and the first is either Alkonost or Sirin depending on who you ask; it's a fragment of Vasnecov's painting of both of them. There are two versions about these birds that I know of: one, that Alkonost is the bird of joy, and Sirin sings joyful songs that lure you into darkness and death (so she's the dark one). The other is that Sirin sings of happiness and Alkonost of sorrow (and also, that Alkonost makes a great storm when she flies above - the reasoning behind the second picture). So depending on which version you follow, the bird in the first picture is either Alkonost or Sirin. Here's the full painting:

http://www.bestiary.us/files/images/alconost_sirin.jpg

(Anyway, the second one looks also a bit like Agan. ;))

:D

EDIT: I did some research, and the second picture is actually Vasnecov's painting of Gamayun, not Alkonost. My bad.

Legate of Amon Lanc

04-14-2013, 06:12 PM

These are pictures of the birds from Slavic mythology. The second one is the bird Alkonost, and the first is either Alkonost or Sirin depending on who you ask; it's a fragment of Vasnecov's painting of both of them. There are two versions about these birds that I know of: one, that Alkonost is the bird of joy, and Sirin sings joyful songs that lure you into darkness and death (so she's the dark one). The other is that Sirin sings of happiness and Alkonost of sorrow (and also, that Alkonost makes a great storm when she flies above - the reasoning behind the second picture). So depending on which version you follow, the bird in the first picture is either Alkonost or Sirin.

A-ha. Now I know where I saw them. About a month ago, I was at an exhibition where they had the original paintings of these, and some more...