Who is more beautiful, Aragorn or Legolas?

[Lalaith]

He he. Sorry, I couldn't resist, given the current top thread topics.<BR>Actually, I never *can* decide which of them is more beautiful. Depends on my mood...

[JenFramp]

I am more into the dirty scruffy sweaty look..so I'll go with Aragorn..

[luin'loki]

I think Legolas is not beautiful,he is HOT!! Aragorn is so dirty,thinking looking or even talking makes me shiver like the iciest wind creeping up my back.

[Diamond18]

You crazy devil, you, Lalaith! But I think we happen to be in the same mood today, as the post I just got done writing in <A HREF="http://forum.barrowdowns.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=4&t=001816" TARGET=_blank>this thread</A> illustrates.<P>Personally, if given the choice between Aragorn and Legolas...I'd take Pippin. Book Pippin, that is... With bacon and mushrooms on the side.<p>[ February 03, 2003: Message edited by: Diamond18 ]

[maikafanawen]

Oh, Legolas! He is a beautiful person. So graceful and noble. *sighs* Words fail me.<P>However, Aragorn is not so bad looking either. But he is no match for my Legolas.

[GaladrieloftheOlden]

Hehe, I think so too. Legolas is really...just hotter. Anyways, Viggo Mortensensen's married (I think).

[*Varda*]

Beautiful? I don't really think that's the right word. I can see Legolas and any elf being described as beautiful, because they kind of have that ethereal presence, but Aragorn doesn't have 'beauty'. It doesn't make him less good looking though.<P>And I don't think Viggo's married. I know he's divorced, though.

[Primrose Maggot]

definantly Aragorn!!

[Deiagorn]

uggghh i can see this being a 300+ reply job. Luckily i'm a bloke so I dont have to focus on such... debates. Though i'll stick with an Eowyn or an Arwen any day

[Arwen Evenstar the Fair]

ARAGORN!!!!!!!!!! TOTALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Lush]

Pah. You people all obviously lack in the taste department. The real hottie here is Gimli: those dirty dreads, those stumpy legs, that bulbous nose!

[Diamond18]

And the eye bags!!!!!!

[The Fifth]

Being within His bondage, I'd have to say that Sauron is the most beautiful!<P>I remember riding into war with him, along with the other Nine ... he was radiating with such an ethreal darkness, his armour shimmering, his eyes burning with malice and hate, his golden tresses billowing behind him, cascading like a waterfall leading to the gateway -- actually, I'm not even sure if He <B>HAS</B> hair.<P>Oh, and both Aragorn and Legolas are equally .. good.

[Lhunbelethiel]

VIGGO MORTENSEN. <P> <P>That's my answer to the question, "who is more beautiful?"

[Birdland]

Awww, screw the Limey and the Swede. The only thing I want to know is who thinks I'M hot!

[Elanor]

Personally I prefer Elrond...<P>*Melts into a a little hobbity heap on the Rivendell floor*

[Lalaith]

*strokes chin thoughtfully*<BR>So, this thread has 15 or so replies, of which many are sarky males muttering bitterly.<BR>Eowyn/Arwen thread has 24 replies, all of which are genuine opinion-offering.<P>And there is supposed to be a fan<I>girl</I> problem on these forums?<BR>

[Inderjit Sanghera]

Yes, but us men do it tastefully and intelligently. And how can you not say that Miranda Otto is the most beautiful creature on the Earth? (Well she gives Kristian Kreuk and Keira Knightley a run for their money) *Laughs and giggles* <P>As for who si the better looking of the two. I think in the movie it is problably Viggo, though Orlando is quite handsome too.<p>[ February 04, 2003: Message edited by: Inderjit Sanghera ]

[Lush]

Don't tell me I've been mistaken for a man yet <I>again</I>. Should I stuff my bra perhaps? (Same goes for Birdie, who is definitely a chick...pun intended)<P>

[Inderjit Sanghera]

I think that the flower and your name Lush, give you away as a girl and I don't know why others would think otherwise. And what's this about stuffing bra's? <p>[ February 04, 2003: Message edited by: Inderjit Sanghera ]

[Tar-Palantir]

Why are women always so hung up on looks? There are more important things, you know, like money!!! Which would make Peter Jackson the most beautiful. <p>[ February 04, 2003: Message edited by: Tar-Palantir ]

[Cibbwin]

Eowyn and Gimli are the most bootiful. No competition.

[King_Elessar]

I so prefer Aragorn, but I thinks that Legolas is going to win with the votes.... <P>Bye, Elessar

[Lush]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> There are more important things, you know, like money!!!<HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>Touché. Thank you for setting our priorities straight. Though in that case, I believe it would be the bigwigs at New Line who take the cake.

[Gorwingel]

I have to say that neither Legolas or Aragorn are the hottest in the films, the one who steals my heart is Nazgul #9, he is so hot.

[Ainaserkewen]

Hi! Frodo!!!!<BR>But between the two,probably legolas because he is an elf and all there special powers and everything. When I see Viggo(Aragorn) I see a 45 year man. When I see Orly(Legolas) I see a 26 year old hottie

[lanrete]

Aragorn so does Not look like his age! He looks like he's in his early to mid-thirties. As for'Who is more beautiful', Legolas of course! He's beautiful with his long blonde hair(i don't usually dig blonde guys), his don't-mess-with-me attitude-or-i'll-kick-your-*** ! attitude and his mad bow skillz! But ORlie and Viggo?? Hmmm... Mr. Bloom still wins, but he definitely looks much better as Legolas. Not to say Viggo is ugly or anything.. he's got this air about him that makes him quite appealing.. he's soo soft-spoken.. gentle yet manly at the same time.. and so cultured. He's just the kind of guy I would fall for if I was still single.<p>[ February 04, 2003: Message edited by: lanrete ]

[dunadan_aragorn]

Aragorn!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragor n!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Ar agorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn !!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!A ragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!Aragorn!!

[Birdland]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR>When I see Viggo(Aragorn) I see a 45 year man<HR></BLOCKQUOTE><BR>And your point is...?

[thalioniathiel]

Legolas is more beautiful but Aragorn is sexier.

[Diamond18]

Aragorn has manly appeal, but "beauty"? If you want to know who is more "beautiful", it is most definitely Frodo. Sheesh. This thread really should say "Who is more beautiful, Frodo or Legolas?" Then at least there would be real competition. Shallow, skin-deep competition, but nevertheless...<P>The Movies Forum has definitely deteriorated in the last few days. Most of the top threads are about fangirls and sex appeal. I remember the good ol' days back in December when the air was crackling with feverish debates about the newly released TTT.<P>Right. Which leads me to point out that Faramir should be in this debate, bad personality or not.

[Lalaith]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> Aragorn has manly appeal <HR></BLOCKQUOTE> and I find manly appeal beautiful. I don't see beauty as something that belongs just to women and/or children (ie Frodo) (sorry )

[Ringfenwen]

I would never have chosen the word beautiful to describe Aragorn (unless referring to his soul)<BR>Sexy, hot, lush, stunnin', gorgeous, scrummy: YES!!!!!!<BR>beautiful: not in the conventional way, no. <BR>Besides, who wants beautiful. I much prefer mud, blood, sweat and stubble. Far more sexy! <BR>YUM!<BR>but anyway, my vote's for Viggo! (bet ya hadn't worked that out yet!)<BR>now, i better fetch a cloth, drool can't b good for the keyboard!!<BR>AAAAARRRRRAAAAAGGGGGOOOOORRRRRNNNN!!!!

[finnguala]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> If you want to know who is more "beautiful", it is most definitely Frodo. <HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>Exactly! <P>And I also don't think Aragorn and Legolas are beautiful. They're just handsome. Well, 'just'

[Ainaserkewen]

The following is an entry from a friend of Ainaserkewen:<BR> all right i have to admit legolas is really hot with the blond hair blue eyes thing, but the dark and mysterious aragorn gets a lot hotter the dirtier he gets so the question is how hot will aragorn and legolas be in the third movie?

[Angel of the Earth]

I seem to think that Aragorn has the manly appeal he is strong, good at fighting ect. ect. But Legolas has the gracefulness and the lush, long, blonde hair! Can I have both???

[Elois Telcontar]

Aragon, I'm not sure if Orlando will look as good when he is 45, it's a sad fact but blue eyed blonds don't always age as well as brown eyed brunetts.

[Tar-Palantir]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR> I'm not sure if Orlando will look as good when he is 45, it's a sad fact but blue eyed blonds don't always age as well as brown eyed brunetts. <HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P><BR>I hate to burst your bubble, but "Orlando" has brown eyes and dark hair under those contacts and that wig!<P><BR>And furthermore it is not a "fact". People that don't care of themselves are the ones that age poorly.<P><---has blonde hair and blue eyes

[Nuranar]

"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder."<P>*ducks* Sorry, I couldn't resist! But before I have my say, here's a definition of beauty (courtesy Merriam-Webster Online):<P> <BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR>the quality or aggregate of qualities in a person or thing that gives pleasure to the senses<HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>Going with the spirit of the thread, I'll take "qualities" to include physical attributes only.<P>That said: Legolas is certainly the more "beautiful." After all, elves are the fairest of Iluvatar's children. I haven't the Silmarillion handy to reference, but I think they were distinguished by the beauty of their appearance.<P>However, it appears we are discussing attractiveness as well. In that case, I'd have to say...I really don't know! Both are quite <I>attractive</I>, and frankly I don't like to dwell on such things for a very long time. Down that way lies superficiality, you see.<P>But this is still fun to think about, and definitely fun to read everyone's response. Come on now, girls! Don't just state your preference; give your reasoning!

[Diamond18]

If anyone is interested, my mother thinks that Éomer is the hottest.

[The Fifth]

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:<HR>I have to say that neither Legolas or Aragorn are the hottest in the films, the one who steals my heart is Nazgul #9, he is so hot.<HR></BLOCKQUOTE><P>Why does Ringwraith <B>9</B> get all the credit? What about me, #5? I am far more attractive than him! Besides, he has pimples and covers it up with his helm.

[Lalaith]

*strokes chin thoughtfully (again)*<BR>No Faramir lovers here, I see. tORN is full of them - I wonder if these things are local phenomena...

[Lady_Báin]

hmmm... i am really surprised no mods. have caught this yet *shrugs* oh well

[Finnguala]

Lol <P>Well, Eomer is quite cute too.

[Elois Telcontar]

Bubble duly busted, I don't follow the actors so I didn't know that Orlando was wearing a wig, that's too bad he looks great as a blond.<P>I guess I was really thinking of Star Wars I was 13 when that first came out Harrison Ford looked a lot older than Mark it in the first film. By the last film he looked a lot younger than Mark Hamilton, but then Mark was in a terrible car accident and I'm sure that really hurt his boyish looks, I had a huge crush on him at the time and by the end I really admired Harrison Ford, and still do by the way he's a great actor and has had a great career.<P>But, you never know how things will turn out and I don't really want to wait 20 years to see what Orlando will look like, assuming we could talk him into putting the wig back on and getting into costume.{but then again I really have no plans for the next 20 years, so I guess I may as well wait to see what Orlando will look like in 20 years)<P><BR> I'm joking, I'm a joker I know(waits to be hit by flying objects from all over Middle Earth)

[Onona Calimaelen]

mmmmm...who can say, they are both pretty good looking. Aragorn has that whole rugged outdoors men thing going on. But I would have to say, as far as beautiful...has to be Legolas. He is so HOT. mmm, what else is there to say.

[Aredhelaran]

Eomer? Hahaha. I think Aragorn is cooler, although I have to admit that Legolas, the clean-shaven well groomed accurate-archer is a sight better looking. I like Aragorn more.

[Diamond18]

Oh, come on! <I>*grumbles*</I> Éomer gets no respect...

[The Saucepan Man]

What, no votes for Boromir? He would certainly get my wife's vote (or maybe that's just a Sean Bean thing ).

[Diamond18]

Ah, but the transient nature of physical admiration makes Boromir, unfortunatly, a prime character to be forgot. He died, and wasn't in TTT.

[HCIsland]

I kind of avoid these types of threads, but I was talking to my wife about whom she felt was most attractive and she is a definate Faramir fan. Perhaps the way he came across in the film left a bad taste in a lot of people's mouths, but I'm wondering if there are others out there or is my wife just weird. She is putting book Faramir's personality into movie Faramir's body and liking the result.<P>H.C.

[Nuranar]

Diamond, <I>I</I> think Éomer is hot. What makes it better, I like his role. He's so serious, but has such a strong character. He sees the truth and not only knows what to do but determines to do it. And he defends his sister!

[elanesse]

hi all. i'm new here. but am very versed in the art of being utterly obsessed with viggo mortensen therefore i think aragorn is definatly the better of the two. and also does anyone know if there is and aragorn/viggo mortensen appreciation thread around here????

[annunfalathiel]

i just gotta say that although legolas is quiet good looking aragorn has to b the best coz he is just.............................................. .................................................. ...........the best?!

[Lalaith]

While Eomer didn't do it for me in general, I *did* very much like the way he whistled for the horses.

[Rynoah, the Overly-Happy]

Aragorn? Legolas? Bah... give me a steadfast Gondorian Man any day of the week and twice on Valentine's day... or something. Boromir or Faramir get my vote, and Boromir gets first dibs between the two. Although I like the book Faramir a WHOLE lot better than the movie one.

[Firondoiel]

LEGOLAS ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!<p>[ February 14, 2003: Message edited by: Firondoiel ]

[Lush]

This thread is...Well, let's just say that "an abomination" would be putting it mildly. Neverthless, David Wenham would definitely have a spot in my harem.

[Estelyn Telcontar]

This thread has definitely outlived any purpose it once may have had. Closed.