[Dimhuanion]

If all the valar were certain parts of Eru the one, then surely this means that Morgoth was representing the darker side of Eru?

Therefore does this mean that there was a part of Eru that was also very dark, a side of him that maybe new that there was going to be strife on Middle Earth and maybe he knowingly let it happen.

I have atheory that maybe Manwe and Morgoth were the two sides of Eru and that he wanted to see what would be more powerful Good or Evil, maybe he was testing to see what would happen and this is why there were Maia who were also good and evil. Its jsut something i've been thinking about i would be interested in waht other people think.

[ November 24, 2002: Message edited by: Dimhuanion ]