The Game I Recommend:
Three Wolves: no PMing during the DAY but are allowed to privately plot at NIGHT. One kill per night. We all know this role. Just reiterating that when the wolves were allowed to plot all day, it was a foolish "advantage" as wolves can pick up "hidden" signals in each other's posts far more easily than innocents can, so they don't need extra chat.
Seer: I sleep fitfully at NIGHT and ask Illamatar... I mean... the mod... whether or not a chosen villager is guilty. In the day, I try to stay alive and I try to keep villagers alive and get werewolves lynched.
Villagers: We talk a lot without knowing anything for certain.
This game is the most fun. But since we seem to want "frills" of a sort, I'm perfectly happy to add
Hunter: whenever the Hunter dies, s/he gets to take somebody out with them.
Ranger: Protects somebody each NIGHT and the wolves can't kill the one they're protecting.
Ranger is probably my favorite "extra" role... probably because of that game Thinlo mentioned. Fun time, that.
Cursed is neat too... usually doesn't come into play, but has altered the course of a game once or twice.
Whatever works.
And we're having retractable? I thought that was the one certain thing; your vote is your vote and that's final.
|