Amanaduial - please accept Naria's innocence. If she were not an innocent, the real Hunter would have come out and said something a long time ago since we then would have been able to catch a wolf. I know you are inexperienced, but this should seem rather logical even to someone who has never played before. Our Gifteds are no use when they stay hidden if they know a wolf. That's what the game's all about
: catching wolves, and your stubbornness on this account is highly alarming. Small wonder Naria decided to vote for you. You will make things a lot easier on yourself if you can accept Naria as a known innocent.
Now to business:
Rune
#70, 72
In character Day 1 posts
#103
Agrees with Gurthang’s famous Seer plan.
#116
Expresses desire to vote for someone on the Nilp wagon. Quoting:
Quote:
Naria
Malkatoj
Gíl-Galad
I have left Luhna out for now because she was the first to vote for Nilp (not counting him self)and because she tend to get annoyed by people acting like Nilp.
|
Interesting because Rune seems to be defending Lhuna from the start.
#127
First to vote for Gil, second wagon.
Day 2
#178
Nothing much, explicitly does not clear Menel.
#184
Nothing, really.
#186
Suspects Garin and Meneltarmacil.
#191
Lightly suspects Malkatoj.
Quote:
Quote:
This is why I will not write Menel off as inoccent, actually I need the seer's word before I belive in the inoccens of anyone.
Luhna if you are a wolf I will start weeping for once again I am convinced of you innocens!
|
Now is not this odd??
Further says to be wanting to vote for Menel or Garin. Possibly Malka as well.
#200
Votes for Garin. I’m not sure how I feel about this. Both Lhuna and me had two votes by then, so Rune was tying the scores. Might be he felt me or Lhun would gather more votes anyway and this would clear him in the future.
#203
Further defends Lhuna.
Day 3
#271
Claims we hurt his brain.
#273
Agrees Nilp’s death might be telling.
TGWBS is too neutral.
Lhuna has finally managed to make him doubt her innocence.
Still suspects Menel and Malkatoj.
Does not know about Kuru, clears Valier.
#283
Votes for Malkatoj, believes Nilp is innocent.
Day 4
#311
Understands why wolves chose Valier. Is glad he is mentioned too. (though he is really only mentioned by people who are convinced of his innocence).
#335
Is sooner prepared to believe me the Hunter than Naria. Is thus willing to vote for:
TGWBS
Naria
Menel
Malkatoj
#347
Believes still in Menel and Malka’s guilt.
#351
Too confused about TGWBS to vote. Votes Malkatoj instead.
Day 5
#370
Keeps insisting we should consider Malkatoj.
#391
Again, all about Menel and Malkatoj. At least he’s consistent.
#398
Little fight with Malkatoj here. Believes Malkatoj should be on our to-lynch list, to put it in my own words.
--
For now, Rune seems as innocent as they come and I think we should try listening to him when it comes to Malkatoj and Meneltarmacil. Should these two prove to be innocent, we can always take a second look at Rune. For now, however, I'll trust Rune as much as I can. Though I do want an answer to one question: what made you so sure of Lhuna's innocence?