No no no! You're all wrong! And So am I!
It's obvious what happened! The finger was left on the floor until an Orc with an eye infection ate it. The finger worked within him, making the eye grow bigger and brighter, and making the Orc a little too obsessed with fire and ordering folk around. When Sauron (Necromancer) returned, he found this giant eye bossing everyone around and so burst it with a pin. He then had the idea for becoming a giant eye, as that was all the Orcs seemed to want to follow.
|