View Single Post
Old 11-14-2006, 10:39 PM   #151
the phantom
Beloved Shadow
 
the phantom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: The Stadium
Posts: 5,971
the phantom is wading through snowdrifts on Redhorn.the phantom is wading through snowdrifts on Redhorn.the phantom is wading through snowdrifts on Redhorn.
Send a message via MSN to the phantom
Eye

Yesterday's voting-

Ang for tp (1)
Di for Boro (1)
SPM for tp (2)
Mith for Beth (1)
Eomer for lmp (1)
lmp for Ang (1)
Kath for tp (3)
Esty for Boro (2)
Nogrod for SPM (1)
Roa for Di (1)
lmp take back Ang (0)
lmp for Di
Boro for SPM
SPM take back tp (2)
SPM for lmp (2)
morm for Boro (3)
tp for Di (3)

I almost got you there at the end, Di! But poor Boro got the axe instead.

I told you he wasn't a WW. I've been in villages with him before. I've been a WW with him before. I know the way he thinks and posts. He was, in my mind, the most clearly innocent person.

And in case you wonder why I chose to tie Di with him rather than lmp or SPM, it's because I'm more comfortable with those two. I have no doubt that I could much more easily pick out a WW SPM or lmp than a WW Di. I've seen less of her, plus I've never ever seen her as a baddie. As the game progresses, I will without a doubt begin to form a clearer picture in my mind of whether or not SPM and lmp are innocent (right or wrong), therefore I want to keep them around. Di, on the other hand- it's possible I will never gain a handle on her guilt/innocence.

That's why I tried to get you killed, m'dear. No hard feelings.

Now I'm going to take a general look at yesterday and give a couple thoughts.

1) Mith for Beth?? Very odd. Were Fea's WWs given special instructions to create as much chaos as possible? If so, Mith's vote would fit. I'm not sure what to think.

2) I find lmp's votes slightly suspicious. Did he vote for Ang thinking he'd get a counter-phantom-bandwagon vote started? And when it didn't pan out, he threw his weight onto Di. This seems like the smart choice at this point for a WW. Don't vote for the current leaders (me-3, Boro-2), but rather elevate someone else into frontrunner status. Also, lmp's post #128 rubs me the wrong way. There's just something about it... the wording. It reminds me of me when I've been a WW.

3) My suspicion of lmp leads me to lean towards SPM's innocence. He did change his vote from me to lmp after all. Sauce- did lmp's post #128 make you uncomfortable as well? But I haven't completely cleared you. I'm still wondering if your statement about the rules at the beginning of the village was a ploy. The thing is, the information you gave as far as I understand turned out to be incorrect (WWs are in fact on a team according to Fea), so did you give incorrect info about the WWs so people would think "My goodness- he didn't even know the way the WW role worked. He couldn't possibly be one." But, there is also another ploy that you could've been attempting to execute as an innocent, so I'm up in the air on it. And no, don't ask me to explain the ploy (until after this is over). If I say it then I'll negate its power.

4) Roa, m'dear, it pains me to say it but both yesterday and today you fell head first into a trap of mine. You see, one of your complaints about my behavior was something that I was actually doing purposefully as a ploy, and I was betting that WWs would have a certain reaction to it. Not that I'm saying I'm sure you're a WW. Depending on your personality, it's possible my trap misfired. I'm not going to start gunning for you yet, but I will watch to see if you continue to travel down the path. And yes, I'll eventually explain what this "trap" is that I'm speaking of (later today), and when I do you can tell me what you think of it and by all means vote to lynch me if you don't like my explanation, but I feel the need to leave it alone just for a few hours.

5) Nogrod is innocent.
__________________
the phantom has posted.
This thread is now important.
the phantom is offline   Reply With Quote