Quote:
Originally Posted by Boromir88
Once Mac says "I'm the Ranger" to save his skin, and "vote Lommy, because now I know she's a wolf." You do realize that in this scenario, if I'm the real Ranger (or anyone else for that matter), you'd be the one who would wind up getting lynched, not Lommy. Because once I decide to step out and say...uh wait a second Mac, no you're not, the village isn't going to listen to you and lynch Lommy, they're going to lynch you! You're entire logic that you were an ordo, claiming to be a ranger, just so you could lynch a mutineer Lommy is full of gaping holes. And you are a wise enough player to know if you really are an ordo that logic you laid out this morning, would not work in the least bit.
|
On the whole, this post made sense but - could you run this part by me again? If what you're saying is true, then it seems like Mac's false ranger claim (it's clearly false, regardless of his alignment) would be equally risky whether he's a wolf or an ordo and so the weakness of that ploy wouldn't really have any bearing on the issue of determining his guilt or innocence. Maybe the facade was full of holes, but I don't see how that can tell us anything about his alignment. Either way, he was desparate and about to be lynched anyway.
Am I totally missing your point?