Quote:
Originally Posted by Macalaure
Form, I'm jumpy about Boro because he did something an innocent Boro would not have done. Would a wolf-Boro do it? Not sure, maybe not, because it would be too risky. Would a cobbler-Boro do it? Yes. (Note that I said Boro=evil, not Boro=wolf.)
Anyway, with the Snitch's power the way it is, I would not consider lynching him a waste in the least.
|
Although my gut's still on
Boro's side here, you do bring up an interesting point--I'd completely forgotten about the Cobbler. That would, certainly, put a whole different dimension on yesterday's events. The thought occurred to me, reading over yesterday's posts, that the whole
Boro and
Sally smooch-fest might have been one or the other's attempt to play at the Lovers--I did not think it likely that both would have done that, but in the same way a genuine
Boro-Innocent would impersonate a seer to protect the seer, I could see a
Boro-Cobbler impersonating a Lover to confuse the seer--and I could see
Sally having played along with with it either way.
But I'm still not
sold on it.
Boromir's reasoning makes sense to me, and, anyway, I'm not sure why he would have picked
Sally. If, as a Cobbler, he thought her innocent, then he's giving shelter to an Innocent--which makes no sense. If he thought her a wolf, it certainly would certainly give her protection, if the seer bought it--but would the seer buy it? And what reason would
Boro-Cobbler have for thinking
Sally a wolf at that stage in the game?
Yeah... not sold on it...
And
Brinn has earned a vote. That's... actually not a bad case,
prima facie, but I don't know if I like it yet.
Nessa seems to be one of those players that stays comfortably below the surface--or, in other words, I can't read her.