Tol-in-Gaurhoth LXIX: Were-Librarians

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

It's already been thrown out there and not be me, so stop making it look like this is some big secret we should shupt up about.

It's been thrown out as a hunch without anything to back it. Unlikely the librarians would seriously consider it as it stood. You were asking him to solidify it and, which would also cause the village to discuss gifteds instead of librarians.

Originally Posted by Boro

I don't know why that makes me evil.

See above.

Originally Posted by Boro

And in this case the Ranger is much better protected because he/she can defend himself or anyone twice in a row...I figure the role is almost like the hunter where sometimes the hunter is more dangerous known than unknown.

*takes a deep breath*

That is utter nonsense. Yes, the ranger is better protected and is able to take two night kills away from the librarians if revealed. But if he has to protect himself he cannot protect the seer twice and thus give us two additional dreams out of a revealed seer. Two dreams at the end of the game can be deciding! You know that well. Almost like the hunter? What threat is attacking the ranger to the librarians? None, except for losing kills.

Originally Posted by Boro

This isn't the normal Ranger and I don't know why you jumped on me asking about Hakon's hunch.

See above.

Originally Posted by Boro

For all you know I could be the ranger and curious to Hakon's reasoning and trying to protect myself. (I'll say now before I get bombarded against by more people I'm not the Ranger...but whatever)

No. If that was the case you would be gathering questionable information at the cost of risking the life of someone you do not know is not gifted.

Originally Posted by Boro

It's more evil that 2 people immediately jump out on me asking Hakon to explain himself.

True. It should have been more.


Alonariel - you voted for me yesterday without reason and you still think I'm suspicious... mind to share why?


Form, I'm jumpy about Boro because he did something an innocent Boro would not have done. Would a wolf-Boro do it? Not sure, maybe not, because it would be too risky. Would a cobbler-Boro do it? Yes. (Note that I said Boro=evil, not Boro=wolf.)
Anyway, with the Snitch's power the way it is, I would not consider lynching him a waste in the least.