Quote:
Originally Posted by Nienna
Ok kids we need to find some new suspects because I'm not a wolf and I'm pretty sure Sally isn't a wolf... and since I think it is safe to assume for the moment that Lottie isn't a wolf... new suspects need to be brought forward. I'd also appreciate some reasoning behind why people seem to find me very suspicious and willing to kill just to see if I'm evil. *Waits patiently to be analyzed*
|
Well now you can't expect us to just sit here and be hunky-dory about those who defended
Mnemo and voted in an attempt to save her. You are under suspicion for strong and understandable reasons.
However, as I said before, I think votes can be craftily manipulated by the wolves. And since
Mnemo had 3-votes on Day 1 I'm putting more stock into the wolf-on-wolf than
Eomer is. That still doesn't change the fact that several people defended her, and several more didn't have much to say about her, so
Eomer is being 100% understandable in his focus on those who defended
Mnemo.
Taking other stuff into consideration, aside from the voting, I think you look pretty good
Nienna. Your consistant efforts against
Lommy make you look more innocent than others who defended
Mnemo.
Lommy is a tough lynch, and I would think any wolves who were trying some sort of effort to save
Mnemo would try to turn the focus on someone who was under more suspicion/an easier lynch.
I will just tell you though, I have no idea what you're seeing that is suspicious with
Lommy. I may be putting too much stock in judging people based on feelings and words, but
Lommy said she was "detached." A wolf doesn't say that, plain and simple. A wolf is excited to be a wolf, they may not be a loud/active player, but there still is a certain level of excitement, and involvement, about having the role.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brinniel
So apparently Eomer has come to the conclusion that everyone who voted Mnemo is innocent and those who tried to save her are probably guilty. That is a horrible assumption to make. While those who weren't convinced of Mnemo's guilt may look more suspicious, that doesn't necessarily mean they are. And with seven votes for Mnemo, I think it could be very likely that at least one is wolf-on-wolf. There are players among the Mnemo voters who are risk-takers and would probably be perfectly okay with sacrificing a wolf to make them look better.
|
Eomer is pretty much saying that, but that's still an exaggeration. It's like when people thought I was saying we should lynch all the reasonable players.
Eomer isn't saying lynch everyone who defended/voted to save
Mnemo, because there just aren't that many wolves. But he is rightfully pointing attention to the sizeable group of people who did something to defend
Mnemo. Anyone in that group could be a wolf and it's only right they all should come under suspicion for it.
Edit: crossed with
Brinn