Here for a short moment, just briefly...
Quote:
Originally Posted by the phantom
Based upon her final post, Nerwen, Shasta, and me look quite good now. Anyone disagree?
|
Looks like that to me, and I think that's the basic line I am going to hold. I need to review all; in any case, I don't think it's some 100% free pass, but basically I would try to go with that and refrain from voting the three of you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin
couldn't our Seer have been someone who, I don't know, participated?
|
Basically exactly the same wording of what I wanted to say as I saw it...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin
Given her rep vote for Phantom early on, I'm inclined to think Phantom was her Night 1 dream.
|
i
Well, I think it doesn't necessary mean that - it could just have been a good way to cast a random vote, hoping to get lost in the crowd of
phantom-voters and get some pass for the Day from the SoE (for being a bit suspicious, and too random for being the Seer). It would expose her to some threat of being lynched, but then, there were like two other people who did the same, so she could have hoped for merging with the crowd, so to say, and not feeling the threat so strongly.
I find it more likely that she'd dream of
phantom later - certainly after the Day 1 events, I think in any case, every Seer would do that. But I didn't really have time to go through all her posts and am working only based on my memory and what others quote here. I will look at her posts later myself. Not that it seems to matter whether she dreamt of
tp on Night 1 or whatnot. Basically the three-list above is the thing I am going to use. It is quite lucky that anyway, if it is so, she didn't dream of somebody who died at the same Night - that's actually what I had been afraid of all the time, since the Seer didn't seem to come out with any dreams.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
So what tipped them off to Mira? She did so little else that I think it must have been her post at #627– specifically, her list of three innocents. Thing is, I don't think you (phantom) were the only other per person who made a list of three, so that might tell us something. (Need to check.)
|
There was at least
phantom and especially
Foley with sorta similar list and possibly some Seer-ish things ("don't lynch Nerwen"). There definitely must be reasons why the SoE chose
Mira over everybody else, that's also worth looking at - but will have to do it when I come back.
Okay, whatever, gotta run now. Will be back later toDay, in several hours...