General list:
Bom Tombadillo - might be trying to make an easy lynch out of
sally, but then again, he is a newbie, who knows how his thought processes go. Therefore, he will get a newbie pass from me toDay.
Nogrod - I don't have clear idea about him yet, hope to see more posts from him.
Shasta - has not contributed much anything to base judgement upon.
Kitanna - raising suspicions with, in my opinion, grounds which are not really worth of suspicion, but then again, maybe she just has bad standards for suspecting people and not meaning evil intentionally.
G55 - reasonable this far, and in any case, also a newbie pass for her toDay.
Sally - I don't see her suspicious. I don't have much more info on her, though, but I certainly wouldn't suspect her based on what several others seem to.
Eomer - despite appearing, didn't say anything worth much. I think that's a problem of rather many people this far.
Nerwen - questionmark. Thoughtful as usual, but of course there might be some sinister thoughts behind that mask, so who knows.
Loslote - nothing to base any thoughts on, again one of those I would like to see more from.
Greenie - had posted a nice summary, but too long. For some reason, I get uneasy feeling from her, but hard to say.
Lommy - not appeared yet
Nilp - this far only schizophrenic stuff, so that's not worth much
Mithalwen - she had a few times been commenting on suspicions raised by confirming them (like "yes, I agree
sally is odd" and "
TomBom is strange - he does not know rules"-see below), which might be a typical Wolfy attitude (i.e. you are picking on suspicions which are lying around to simply blend with the crowd) and she had backed away from questioning
Shasta, which might be being a bit of "Ms. Agreeable" - but of course, maybe it was also just related to the amount of sleep/coffee/time/whatever she had and nothing was intended by it. Half of her posts are "administratory" anyway and without much content (referring to what is the time, who is posting and such), so it's hard to tell.
All in all, I don't have any very strong suspect this far. I at most know people I know I
don't want to vote (at least now), which is also good by itself. But I will read and think.
Random question:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mith
Interesting - I usually think not knowing the rules is suspicious - which mean Bom is looking interesting ... rule query, first post and this offer to more or less "mercy lynch" Sally.
|
Why do you think not knowing the rules is suspicious? I would think the opposite - WWs especially really have to read the rules, so that they can operate properly. (Although, in my opinion, everybody should read the rules carefully to be able to operate properly in his or her own role - even ordos, so that they can judge well what's going on and what are the options... but for WWs and Gifteds it is necessary, because e.g. you cannot play a Ranger without knowing how this role works, and a Wolf should know that as well, so that they know how they should plan their Night-kills in regards to there being other roles which can hinder them and so on...)