Good and evil

[William Cloud Hicklin]

I'm not sure what I think. Galadriel sees herself as 'beautiful and terrible.' Sam imagines a garden swollen to a realm. But is this accurate, or the Ring's deceit? Sauron could once appear beautiful.

I suspect that for Tolkien Beauty was in large part dependent on natural harmony (and allowing the Music to take its course). The exercise of forceful interference introduces disharmony- the discord of Melkor, if you like. Sauron's inability after the Fall of Numenor to take on a fair form indicates that with the diminishment of his power he was unable to maintain a *disguise*- that his outward form reflected his true nature. Note also Saruman in death- rags of flesh over a hideous skull. There is something about the Will to Power which brings inherent ugliness along with it. Since temporal power of the sort the Ring promises involves coercion and enslavement, the process almost ineveitably involves the evocation of Fear- and terror involves using the ugly and the hideous. I believe Galadriel+ Ring would ultimately, like Saruman, have recruited Orcs.

For an Augustinian Catholic beauty on Earth is a distant echo of Divine perfection, and so I think for Tolkien the rejection of Eru's purpose (embodied in the moral law) means abandoning that echo- this can be seen even in the case of Aule and the Dwarves, who are not evil, but are indeed unlovely.