A "Complete Silmarillion" in Spanish - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

gondowe · 03-07-2009, 06:37 PM

I insist that it's a legend even for the elves themselves ( of Aman and Sindar) not a kwoledge as "the wise men say".
I only take the characters, and didn't mention the spouses for Miriel and of course (I had forgotten) for Melian.
I feel that if Ingwe was "the eldest for he awoke first" then Finwe and Elwe must be the second and third, and Unbegotten.
And yes, possibly the sentence from Ruin of Doriath was written by CT. Possibly he though he awoke in Cuivienen. But this sentence I retained in the reconstructed text of that chapter.

Greetings

03-07-2009, 06:37 PM	#10
gondowe Wight Join Date: Jan 2009 Posts: 248	I insist that it's a legend even for the elves themselves ( of Aman and Sindar) not a kwoledge as "the wise men say". I only take the characters, and didn't mention the spouses for Miriel and of course (I had forgotten) for Melian. I feel that if Ingwe was "the eldest for he awoke first" then Finwe and Elwe must be the second and third, and Unbegotten. And yes, possibly the sentence from Ruin of Doriath was written by CT. Possibly he though he awoke in Cuivienen. But this sentence I retained in the reconstructed text of that chapter. Greetings