WW LXXXII: Return to Tol-in-Gaurhoth

[skip spence]

Originally Posted by Me

Firstly, the reason I voted Shasta was not so much his behaviour but rather Lottie's very flimsy accusation. It was so off I actually felt that she might've known something we did not.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Fair enough, and the point did occur to me too– though I rejected it when she started saying "but I could be wrong". However, why didn't Shasta's flimsy accusation of Pitch also strike you as Seerish?

Why not? I suppose that although Shasta's accusation of Pitch also did seem weak (something almost unavoidable on a Day 1 unless a wolf makes a very foolish and blatant mistake I think), Lottie's motivation to attack Shasta was just plain ridiculous if she had honest intentions and as she, as we now know, isn't the Seer.

Originally Posted by Lottie

Really, though, not liking Shasta. Too non-confrontational, and the way he words this especially:

Originally Posted by Shasta

Wrong. The Hunter takes their current pick to the grave with them if lynched, regardless of alignment.

I mean, what in the name of Eru Illuvatar could been seen as suspicious in that? Not sure if a wolf would be so careless though...