Silmarillion - Chapter 22 - Of the Ruin of Doriath

[Estelyn Telcontar]

This chapter is connected to the previous one by several elements: it begins with the fate of the father Húrin, after death ended the fate of his son Túrin. And, as Aiwendil mentioned in the previous discussion, yet another Elven kingdom is destroyed:

Originally Posted by Aiwendil

You know, it occurs to me that in the larger context of the history of the First Age, probably the most important event in this story is the fall of Nargothrond. Indeed, if one considers this and the subsequent two chapters, we have a trilogy of stories each of which revolves to some extent around the fall of one of the Elves' hidden kingdoms: here Nargothrond, in the next chapter Doriath, and in the chapter after that Gondolin.

Death and tragedy continue to be the most prominent elements in the continuation of Tolkien's epic tale, and once more a Silmaril is involved. The end of Beren and Lúthien's story is told, and the way is prepared for the tale of the fate of this Silmaril.

One important factor featured in this chapter is the enmity between Dwarves and Elves. Could the misunderstandings have been avoided and a better relationship have developed if characters had acted differently?

The corruptive influence of treasures is also shown, in this case the Nauglamir and one Silmaril. Did the combination of them multiply their fateful effect? On the one hand its beauty was great, especially when possessed by Lúthien. On the other hand, it had a negative influence even on her lifespan. And it caused a new Kinslaying.

One more thing occurred to me while rereading this chapter: the characters seem to fall into despair when their spouses die. We see that in Húrin, who even takes his own life after losing Morwen. But more fateful is Melian's withdrawal from the fate of her people when Thingol is killed - she withdraws her protection from the kingdom, which is left defenseless against its enemies. Not even Beren and Lúthien's son can restore its glory permanently. Should Melian have acted more responsibly, considering others more than her own grief?