Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Feanor of the Peredhil

Well, a happy occurence it is to wake up alive. My suspicion of the phantom is lessening, although I do not know why. His logic battles ceaselessly with my own. I'll explain more in about an hour.

Okay... It's been "about an hour" and me not suspecting the phantom is... I dunno. I'm moody. Right now my mood is saying "Well, when I offered up a truce (temporary though it may be), he didn't fight me on it, so that's a point or two in his favor." Mind you, I still hate his sacrifice plan. All probability aside, you're still killing innocent people. That just doesn't sit well with me.

I don't dismiss the possibility that the 'plan' was a bluff orchestrated by the phantom and Fea (they certainly seem like the types, these two ) but even if they did that, I think it may have been put forth to study our reactions to it, and not because they're werewolves trying to snare us

What a brilliant idea. The two of us, planning a very public arguement that goes almost entirely against our usual "I agree, phantom ol' pal" and "Fea's right, as usual" discourses. A pair of werewolves, making it disturbingly obvious that we both want to save lives, we just hate the way each other plan on doing it. Or... not. What people forget is that we PM all the time, and we argue like siblings. You should have seen the stuff about lab dissections... This whole huge debate? There's no bluff, there's no layer subtly hidden beneath, no hidden agendas. I think he's got a flawed, sketchy, morally uncertain plan, and I'm telling him so, and at the same time, trying to keep people from following it.

And I agree with Evisse... we need to hear more from the quiet ones. That's why tp and I stopped arguing for a little while.