Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[Roa_Aoife]

Also, I've just realized that with my analysis toDay and yesterDay, and excluding myself and Rikae, I've only got four people left to analyze! And as they're all quiet people, this shouldn't take long at all.

(See, Nogrod, this is why analyzing during the Night phase when you've nothing better to do is worthwhile. Sure you could die in the night, but if you don't, way more work gets done.)

EDIT: I forgot, those people are:

Gil-Galad
Glirdan
Kath
Mithalwen

So, I'll skip Glirdan- I believe everything that can be said about his ONE post has been said already. Gil-galad, coming up. (This shouldn't take long.)

[Roa_Aoife]

Gil-galad

1st post - Decides to take things slow, will review and be back later, decides to look at Manwe and Nogrod because they are under the most speculation

(Really playing it safe here- he says he's going after the two most suspicious people at the time, but never comes back with any conclusions.)

2nd post - Says that he also has a tendency not to say much, doesn't think Manwe is a wolf, lists his hunches: SPM, Hookbill, TGWBS, and Rikae

He does not return to vote on Day 1

3rd post - Agrees with Manwe, puts Legate at the bottom of his list, is worried that he won't return, Votes SPM, apologizes

While I, too, think SPM is guilty, I'd like to see more reasoning from Gil. Also, I don't like his apologizing. (I never like it, really. Either you think someone is guilty, or you don't. If you do, have some conviction in your vote. If you don't, then don't vote for them.) However, as he's cited parental trouble in the Admin thread, I'm going to let him slide for now.

Parents can be such a bother, wouldn't you say, Thin?

Kath next!

[Roa_Aoife]

Kath, Day 1

1st post - feels weird with out an occupation, states the ratios and odds, thinks we have good odds, feels lost

(All she does is state the obvious, However, she is admittedly one of the very first posters, and it looks more like she honestly doesn't know what to discuss rather than trying to appear present with out actually doing anything.)

2nd post - Banter with TGWBS, doesn't think Manwe is suspicious, but just new, wonders if he might be another Valier, thinks Legate is trying to set hemself up as "The Calm One," thinks Hookbill is normal, comment about Durelin and lack of roles, has to leave

No vote, but she explains that on the admin thread. I always have a hard time reading Kath, but she's being especially non-controversial right now. She's making a presence, and she looks like she saying something of substance, but in reality, nothing she says is a new thought. With only two posts, she's barely above Glirdan. I'm definitely keeping a close eye on her from now on.

Mith next, and then I'm done for the night. (Everyone can breathe a sigh of relief.)

[Mänwe]

Mhm, but surely then if she was truly not trying to appear 'present' wouldn't you just not post? Stating the obvious as her first post and as one of the first posters to use a popular phrase, 'screams' of wanting to appear present. Do you not think? If she was really straped for something to say, you'd just not say anything.

I mean most people here are bashing on about 'substance'.

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

So I started this post with the intention of saying that Roa's skills in analyzing was not as great as I thought, but as I started to think about what she said I found that she was more correct than I first thought.

Some of my theories my seemed forced and that is because they are. . .I have to force my self to find things I find suspicouse otherwise I would seldom get more than 1 suspect at the time. So yeah many of my suspicions is not based on me seing something and saying "that is wolfish" but more a case of me thinking "that is slightly odd" and then start to make a shaky case out of it.

I have never claimed have any analytical skills, if I do then they do not show because I seldome have pations to make analysis like Roa's.

Anyways you might not belive me, but I did/do want to vote Legate, his attempt to be the voice of reason just seemed over the top. He reminds me of those ever so good people that end up being the real bad guy in cartoons. . .I don't know what else to say as their is not theory behind it, it is purly gut and feeling that legate is trying to hard.

I still feel the same about Mänwe, I think he acts weird and I do suspect him, but for some reason at the same time I have seriouse doubts that he is a wolf. . . It is hard to explain, but it was kind of the same feeling I had about Garin and that was why I mentioned that I would rather lynch Legate.

I suppose it might be that the people that really strikes you as acting in a really weird/wolfish way is very seldome wolves, in fact I can't remember when I last spottet a wolf like this. Whenever I have had the luck to spot a wolf it has been on small things, like a slight twist of words.

Warning: If people start talking about me being over defencive I will beat them with a stick!

When a post is made about me, I feel that I should respond in order to clarify or confuse further.

[Mänwe]

Or kill them during the night? Sorry I couldn't resist.

[Mänwe]

Roa, as to where Kitanna stated she understood me;

I'm glad to see Manwe addressed my questions and concerns and I understand his reasoning behind the four he picked in earlier posts (Nogrod, Roa, SpM, and myself). I feel somewhat better about Manwe when he's not dancing around a topic and avoiding answering questions.

Post #96.

[Roa_Aoife]

Mith, Day 1

1st post - Not alot to say, thinks the game will be interesting, cautions everyone about gifteds and their odd vibes, reminds everyone of the cobbler

(While I disagree with Mith about being cautious of gifteds, I find little to suspect in her first post. She managed to stir up quite a bit with it, despite being the first post of the game.)

2nd post - Says she hasn't been near a computer since her first post, is going to read what she's missed

3rd post - points out that Roa likes talk so she can examine it and doesn't find it odd, decides to look at the people who have made a big deal about her joking statement while ignoring her serious one, says she just wanted to remind the village of possible dynamics and to consider all the angles before going after someone suspicious, says her statement about sharing details was rhetorical

(Again, while I disagree with her about her view on the gifted, she seems very reasonable at this point.)

4th post - Remembers that Garin has a tendency to look suspicious

(What happened to looking at the people who misunderstood your statement?)

5th post - Disagrees with Roa about gifted

(Well, that was expected, though she still hasn't looked at the people who ignored her serious statement, and in seems more in favor of looking at the one person who didn't.)

6th post - feels uneasy about Lal's single post, thinks Manwe is just new, wants to see why everyone finds Rikae suspicious, says a vote for SPM would be traditional, but is puzzled by the squabling between him and Roa, though the two are the most likely to argue "the toss" (?), says the village is much quieter than expected

(Ah, here they are. I wish she'd put a little more into it though. There's just a brief summary on each. I'm not sure what to make of that.)

7th post - Doesn't know who to vote for, wants to save Rikae but isn't convinced of either Manwe or Garin's guilt

(While I can understand the frustration, it's better to lynch an innocent and save the seer than to quibble about it and let the minutes slide away. It worries me. Does she know both are innocent and doesn't want to be tied to an innocent bandwagon?)

8th post - Says Rikae was a very bold wolf last game, but she will be found out quickly if she is lying

(I'm not sure what the point of this was. Everyone realizes this, I think, and I don't believe that anyone had called Rikae into question yet, though I could be wrong.)

9th - Says Lal would be her choice since she can't decide about Roa and SPM, says Lal doesn't feel right, and she may be playing with an evil Lal for the first time.

10th - agrees that Rikae shouldn't reveal anything until Day 2

11th - Votes Lal, since Rikae is safe

(Well, at least she stuck to her guns, small as they may have been. I can respect sticking with your own conclusions instead of going with a bandwagon, but it still seems like she went with a safe vote instead of risking a vote for Garin or Manwe to save our seer. I don't trust her hesitation, here.)

Okay, having analyzed everyone in the village except the dead, the known innocent, and myself, I feel I've made my fair share of contributions to the village for now. I'm going to bed, but I should be back well before the end of the Day. (I may check back in a little bit, if I can't sleep, but no promises.)