Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[Lalaith]

Lommy, I'd disagree slightly with this assessment;

Lalaith was slightly suspicious of him and wasn't sure what to think of him on Day3. TGWBS suspected her quite strongly on Day4.
Lalaith was uneasy about him and voted him (though retracted) on Day4.

Guy was in my top four suspects on both Day 3 & 4. By day four I was a lot more than uneasy. In fact, the reason I was torn, as I said before I voted, between him and Saucie is that I felt that both were probably wolves so I didn't mind which one of them got lynched.
Nothing of course is certain in Werewolf and it may be that I am being an unusually misguided and pig-headed innocent. But I remain convinced, despite the mutual voting today, that both Durelin and Saucie are wolves, and, knowing one of them would probably be lynched, the other is hoping to gain kudos for helping the task along.
I still have a tiny doubt about Durelin but very little about Saucie.
++SAUCEPANMAN

[Kitanna]

I just wrote out somethings and the computer I'm on decided to delete it. And also since I'm away from home I have limited access.

But I've been looking at SpM and Durelin as best I can. I've read the cases against them and I'd say Durelin looks far more innocent than SpM. But I haven't looked at either hard enough to truly vote for either. I realize I should vote for one or the other because one is most likely a faithful, but I'm held back. I haven't given enough attention to either to feel comfortable voting for them.
But I'm going to look back and perhaps change my mind. If I run out of time or I turn up nothing I will vote for one of my suspects from yesterday.

[Kitanna]

Something just caught my eye and I see Durelin also noticed it. Gil has been suspecting tgwbs and SpM all along. If SpM bites it today and is a faithful I think a close look at Gil is needed. I'm not sure his suspicious are just dumbluck. Howver this depends on the guilt or innocence of SpM.

So looking mostly at posts from today (and a few from late yesterday) I think Durelin may well be innocent. I believe if SpM is guilty, than Durelin is probably innocent (and vice versa). I don't want to see Durelin lynched. Her posts today cry innocence to me. I could be reading them horribly wrong.

Regardless of who is lynched today I think a close look should be taken at Gil. I have lessened my suspcions of my other four and moved Gil up.
He is almost always quiet and keeps his posts short. But he was right in his "hunch" about tgwbs. He has suspected and voted for SpM and now he votes for Durelin. If either one of them turns out to be a faithful (and I'm sure one will be) I'd say Gil's hunches may be more than they seem.

I'd like to vote for Gil, Hookbill, or to a way lesser extent Lalaith (I've moved her down due to my suspcions of Gil). But I will hold off my voting for a little while (probably about 10 minutes) just to see what happens.

[Lalaith]

Hang on a minute Kitanna. You're sure either Saucie or Durelin will turn out to be a faithful, you think Durelin's posts cry out innocence, (so therefore one must infer you think Sauce a faithful) but then you want to vote for either Gil, Hookbill or perhaps me?

[Lalaith]

I mean, by all means vote where you wish to, but I just thought this needed explaining.

[Mithalwen]

Having just read through his posts .. I am inclined to think Gil innocent ..but then I said that about TGWBS......

[Lalaith]

That Glirdan error was what swung it for me vis a vis Gil. I just don't think he would have fabricated such a misunderstanding.

[Hookbill the Goomba]

Sorry for not posting peoples, it's been one of those days.
If this keeps up, I may have to pull out.

I understand your casem Master Pan, and I'd probably vote for me in your shoes, which makes me think that you're not a wolf because I cannot see any advantage the faithfuls would have in getting me lynched as I readily admit I've not really posed a threat as far as I am aware.
I'm running out of time, so I'll have to come to a decision...

Durelin's name kept popping up so I thought I'd give the old Wight's posts a check up and I can see where the people are coming from. 'Loud' is how Durelin was described somewhere above, and I'm not sure how to read that particular reading.

Gil-Gallad is the only one who has left me uneasy today. And I see it's now 8:59 so... erm... well... *shakes nervously*

Sorry, Gil...

++ Gil-Gallad

[Kitanna]

Originally Posted by Lalaith

Hang on a minute Kitanna. You're sure either Saucie or Durelin will turn out to be a faithful, you think Durelin's posts cry out innocence, (so therefore one must infer you think Sauce a faithful) but then you want to vote for either Gil, Hookbill or perhaps me?

I don't feel I have a strong case against SpM or I'd vote for him. I know that probably sounds stupid or ridiculous, but I'd rather vote for someone I have a case against and not just some gut feeling. Because in the end all I have against (or for) either SpM or Durelin is a gut feeling.

[Durelin]

About 15 minutes till the close of the Day and we still have not heard from Hookbill. He did vote yesterDay, though, at least, so luckily we aren't running the risk again of untimely losing another innocent. He definitely needs to be looked at again, even though we really don't have much to go on him.

If we have another wolf in SPM, if the wolves get a kill toNight, tomorrow it will be 6 of us against 2 wolves; if not, it will be 3 against five? Why do these things always come down to the wire...

Wow, it seems like it's been a while since the voting hasn't been neck-to-neck to the last minute. *waits for the retractions to start*

[Mithalwen]

Well this village has been peculiarly suicidal.......... but we still have a ranger..and a hunter ......so we may get a bonus.....

[Mithalwen]

++ The Saucepan Man

[Durelin]

Originally Posted by Kath

I'm not sure about looking at Gil, Kitanna. That slip about the wolves killing Glirdan ... I just can't see him doing it on purpose. It's possible, but of the quiet ones I think I'd still be more inclined to believe Hookbill a wolf than Gil.

The mess up doesn't necessarily have to be on purpose or mean he's innocent. Limiting it to just those two options seems rather foolish to me. Particularly with Gil, I'm prepared to expect anything.

[Mithalwen]

So 3votes for Mr Teflon and 2 forDurelin....

Hmm