Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

And that is all very well but sometimes you have to accept that you aren't going to get what you want and make the best of it.

I agree. But as long as you have a chance to avoid the lynching of someone you feel is clearly less suspicious than some others then the innocent villager tries to avoid lynching the innocentish with all effort. Remeber. You speak with hindsight here. I acted in total darkness as to who where what yesterDay.

At least Rikae has the courage of her convictions - even though I don't really agree with them.

I'm not sure if it's courage vs. sneakiness if someone votes early (RL reasons are a good reason to vote early anyhow - but early votes are always easier) even if independent-mindedly or actually takes part during the minutes where things are decided. You see what happened when I did the best I could...

Do you really think a wolf-Noggie would have hanged around 1.30 AM half-dead from several days of 4 hour sleeps RL just to get more suspected? To save Menel perhaps? Oh no. I was a wolf with Menel once. I lynched him on Day1 and contributed to it heavily earlier on the Day (aided by Boro). No way. For wolf-Noggie it's the security of himself and his image among the villagers. For the innocent Noggie it's the villager's good - even if it arouses controversy or suspicions because those are needed to get things going and the wolves to reveal themselves.

We should be hunting wolves and not having this absurd cross-examination.

Or is this what to aim for Mith? How come you were so sure about Menel's guilt yesterDay? You can't say you were sure or that there weren't other candidates as suspicious as he was? How come you managed to pick him as so sure candidate?

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Or is this what to aim for Mith? How come you were so sure about Menel's guilt yesterDay? You can't say you were sure or that there weren't other candidates as suspicious as he was? How come you managed to pick him as so sure candidate?

You seemed to find the reasoning good at the time. I wasn't sure but he looked the most suspicious at the time I had to vote. So I voted for him. I didn't know ...