WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Boromir88]

So Mac voted for...

Day 1: Nogrod (retracted and Nogrod again)
Day 2: Eomer
Day 3: Gwath
Day 4: Gwath
Day 5: Izzy (after retracting vote for Kath)
Day 6: Lommy

Eonwe: (Day 3)

Gwath:

Shasta: (Day 6)

Izzy: (Day 6)

Nerwen: (Day 4, Day 5, Day 6)

Other notes:

Day 3- Mac votes for Gwath, and at the end Nerwen retracts Rikae (after revealing as the hunter), votes Annu, and Gwath votes Annu.

Day 6- Everyone who was around after Mac's reveal (excluding myself) switched to Lommy. That doesn't really reveal too much, as well Mac said he was the Ranger, and someone innocent could believe that.

The only thing that sticks out is Shasta without question accepts Mac's claim and quickly votes for Lommy. His suspicion for it was not just Mac's reveal, but Eonwe voting with Lommy. Hmm...I also recall a defensive Mac when I pointed out Shasta's, Eonwe's, and Inziladun's post spurt after Mith said something. Inziladun is not a mutineer, and I believe he's innocent...but jury still out on Shasta and Eonwe.

Nerwen voted along with Mac the most amount of times...which is kind of odd. But actually I think this makes Nerwen look even more innocent (if there really was any doubt, I thought Nerwen could be a co-conspie). Mac trying to follow a presumed innocent's vote? Especially on Day 5, Nerwen votes for Izzy, and Mac retracts his vote for Kath and follows.

Gwath did not vote with Mac at all, but Mac tried to lynch Gwath twice, and when I wondered how Gwath's non-appearance would play into the mutineers strategy, Mac praised the observation and used the suspicion against Gwath to try and get Lommy lynched.

As for why Mith? How come it seems like I make a statement of innocence about someone they wind up dead? I apologize Mith. Anyway, I think it was Mith, because she's been here everyday and voted everyday. Even if she hasn't been an 'active' force, she votes everyday...plus no one really thought she was a mutineer.

The 5 still alive are all wildcards, which will make this very difficult vote for ye 5. Even if I believe Nerwen's innocent, I still have no idea what she is going to do.