Dead Gondolin

[Joy]

You have an interesting veiw, but I don't believe that it is correct. (No offense.)

As far as the location goes, and taking in to consideration the ME being changed and reformed, Gondolin and the paths of the dead where pretty much in the same spot.

Gondolin was in Beleriand, which sank at the end of the 1st Age.

And Aragorn is a descendent of Thingol which would explain his authority over the ghosts.

True, Aragorn in the desendent of Thingol though many generations, but Thingol was not the Lord of Gondolin. He was Lord of Doriath or Menengroth. Turgon was the Lord of Gondolin.