Can elves die by being poisined???

[doug*platypus]

I think you have to use garlic or something don't you? Or EDTA like in Blade II?

Elves are not vampires!! JRR Tolkien didn't create them to be comic book characters with highly defined, very specific weaknesses. They're not in a Saturday morning cartoon!

Seems to me that it's far easier to list those things that kill Men, but do not kill Elves. I can only think of two: ageing and disease.

Surely the above quote from Saucepan Man should be enough to stop the madness? Biological warfare?! OMG... this is The Lord of the Rings we're talking about, not the latest X-Box game (although unfortunately these days they are one and the same thing).