* * Revised Fall of Gondolin pt.5 -- >end [the remaining sections] * * - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Aiwendil · 02-13-2004, 12:34 AM

I would prefer not to nail down the exact division between Tuor and Earendil until we've at least started work on the Earendil chapter, and decided whether we intend to include the alliterative fragment in some form.

The issue of Gil-Galad in general needs some thought. As for his presence at the mouths of Sirion: the note from "The Parentage of Gil-Galad" used in FG-C-27 is a bit tricky. I'm not sure whether it constitutes a change from the older story (wherein he and Cirdan leave the havens and take up residence on Balar) or not. I am inclined to think that it does not, and that Gil-Galad still ends up on Balar with Cirdan - and the story proceeds as in Q30 and QS77. If that's so, then FG-C-27 may need to change.

02-13-2004, 12:34 AM	#12
Aiwendil Late Istar Join Date: Mar 2001 Posts: 2,224	I would prefer not to nail down the exact division between Tuor and Earendil until we've at least started work on the Earendil chapter, and decided whether we intend to include the alliterative fragment in some form. The issue of Gil-Galad in general needs some thought. As for his presence at the mouths of Sirion: the note from "The Parentage of Gil-Galad" used in FG-C-27 is a bit tricky. I'm not sure whether it constitutes a change from the older story (wherein he and Cirdan leave the havens and take up residence on Balar) or not. I am inclined to think that it does not, and that Gil-Galad still ends up on Balar with Cirdan - and the story proceeds as in Q30 and QS77. If that's so, then FG-C-27 may need to change.