A critical look at the Tom B / Witch King theory

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Hey, you may think that this is not serious but I do. That question was inside my head for ages and I'm still not convinced by a lot of these arguments. As far as I can see there is no section of the Forums entitled "Discussions on ridiculous theories"

Did the Witch King not have a lot of power? Sure, he was no Dark Lord but who's to say he couldn't change form whenever he felt like it. Maybe when he changed into Tom Bombadil, he changed so completely that no thought of taking the Ring from Frodo entered his head.

And sure, Tom said that he is the Eldest but if you were the Witch King in disguise then wouldn't you lie?

I didn't really make myself clear the first time but what I meant was that the Ring had a different effect on Tom and Witch King than it did on everyone else. Neither was fooled when Frodo put on the Ring.