did all the ring bearers go west? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

kharank · 11-25-2002, 09:53 AM

Hmmm, possibly. But I think the reason Frodo was in danger on Amon Hen was because he was on that Seat of Seeing, which kinda revealed him openly, and would have been a pain in the *** if he hadnt taken off the ring, cos Sauron woulda see him...

Back to Bombadil though, i reckon he could count as a ring-bearer, but thats just my opinion, and it depends very much on your definition of bearer. Tom held the ring, and even put it on his finger, so surely that must count for something, even if it did have no effect on anybody. Oh, and by the way Curulin, I've heard this topic of conversation before. 24601 mean anything to you? lol

11-25-2002, 09:53 AM	#28
kharank Animated Skeleton Join Date: Nov 2002 Location: Belgium Posts: 31	Hmmm, possibly. But I think the reason Frodo was in danger on Amon Hen was because he was on that Seat of Seeing, which kinda revealed him openly, and would have been a pain in the *** if he hadnt taken off the ring, cos Sauron woulda see him... Back to Bombadil though, i reckon he could count as a ring-bearer, but thats just my opinion, and it depends very much on your definition of bearer. Tom held the ring, and even put it on his finger, so surely that must count for something, even if it did have no effect on anybody. Oh, and by the way Curulin, I've heard this topic of conversation before. 24601 mean anything to you? lol __________________ High Lord Kharank has spoken