LOTR vs Harry Potter - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Sweatpea Knotwise · 07-22-2002, 03:59 PM

I think in likening Potter and LOTR to Rivendell and Lorien, you are giving Potter more credit than it deserves. I would not accuse Rowling of stealing ideas, since Tolkien was not completely original either (and if you want to see a case for plagiarism, read The Sword of Shannara), but I would certainly not put Potter on so close a level with LOTR. <P>Here’s my idea – and mayhap only a “hobbit-like” thinker will see validity in it…. <P>Comparing Potter to LOTR is like comparing a Burger King meal to a four course dinner at The Four Seasons. Sure, the Whopper and fries are quite yummy for a quick bite, but you don’t know what you’re missing until you’ve savored white truffle risotto, lobster bisque, and filet mignon, topped off with tiramisu and espresso.<P>Whoa.... I didn't realize this thread had a "page 2". It looks like the subject has degenerated to a "Potter is evil" level.<p>[ July 22, 2002: Message edited by: Sweatpea Knotwise ]

07-22-2002, 03:59 PM	#11
Sweatpea Knotwise Pile O'Bones Join Date: Jul 2002 Posts: 17	I think in likening Potter and LOTR to Rivendell and Lorien, you are giving Potter more credit than it deserves. I would not accuse Rowling of stealing ideas, since Tolkien was not completely original either (and if you want to see a case for plagiarism, read The Sword of Shannara), but I would certainly not put Potter on so close a level with LOTR. <P>Here’s my idea – and mayhap only a “hobbit-like” thinker will see validity in it…. <P>Comparing Potter to LOTR is like comparing a Burger King meal to a four course dinner at The Four Seasons. Sure, the Whopper and fries are quite yummy for a quick bite, but you don’t know what you’re missing until you’ve savored white truffle risotto, lobster bisque, and filet mignon, topped off with tiramisu and espresso.<P>Whoa.... I didn't realize this thread had a "page 2". It looks like the subject has degenerated to a "Potter is evil" level.<p>[ July 22, 2002: Message edited by: Sweatpea Knotwise ] __________________ Single Hobbit Lass seeks Single Hobbit Lad, enjoys quiet evenings at home and the occasional spot of Old Toby. Talent: a killer seedcake. Contact “The ‘Pea” at Willowrot Row, Michel Delving.