LOTR vs Harry Potter - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Lady_Espel · 09-24-2002, 01:08 PM

I quite like Harry Potter, but its not 100% fantasy. I think that the fourth book was the worst so maybe thats how the books are goin. I hope not. But compared to LOTR, well, you <I>can't</I> compare them. LOTR is completely different, it is complete fantasy, whereas HP isn't. Plus, LOTR is quite a bit more mature, even if HP does appeal to adults to. As for the movies, well, maybe if they'd of used more of actual book, HP might of been better. But it wasn't and the acting skills of Daniel Radcliff didnt help. Wow, that's longer than my english essay. I come off a bit vicious about HP don't I? But I do like it, really.

09-24-2002, 01:08 PM	#11
Lady_Espel Animated Skeleton Join Date: Sep 2002 Posts: 42	I quite like Harry Potter, but its not 100% fantasy. I think that the fourth book was the worst so maybe thats how the books are goin. I hope not. But compared to LOTR, well, you <I>can't</I> compare them. LOTR is completely different, it is complete fantasy, whereas HP isn't. Plus, LOTR is quite a bit more mature, even if HP does appeal to adults to. As for the movies, well, maybe if they'd of used more of actual book, HP might of been better. But it wasn't and the acting skills of Daniel Radcliff didnt help. Wow, that's longer than my english essay. I come off a bit vicious about HP don't I? But I do like it, really. __________________ I ran into my ex the other day, hit reverse and did it again.