Letter to PJ - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Massharpoon · 12-21-2002, 12:00 PM

I know changes must be made from book to movie, like cutting things out, or short. ** Spoilers **I also think things very important to the overall story should not have been forgoton (Faramir and Frodo dialogue).Why make Pippin trick Treebeard. Please tell me what logic there was int that.We need a dramatic death sequence so lets bring elves to Helms Deep and Kill Haldir. Even though his character was never realy built up people will be sad. BAH!These must be the things that you refer to as well thought out.

12-21-2002, 12:00 PM	#5
Massharpoon Pile O'Bones Join Date: Nov 2002 Location: Virginia Posts: 12	I know changes must be made from book to movie, like cutting things out, or short.<BR> Spoilers <P>I also think things very important to the overall story should not have been forgoton (Faramir and Frodo dialogue).<P>Why make Pippin trick Treebeard. Please tell me what logic there was int that.<P>We need a dramatic death sequence so lets bring elves to Helms Deep and Kill Haldir.<BR>Even though his character was never realy built up people will be sad. BAH!<P>These must be the things that you refer to as well thought out.