The Cartoons - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Michael Baggins · 04-06-2002, 11:31 PM

So I watched them all now. I thought the LOTR was good, I liked how they portrayed the people, but yes they cut out a lot. I thought the ROTK stank, but I thought that the voice for Gollum in that cartoon was perfect. I don't know why the maker of the LOTR would make the first two and not the third, that was odd. Did anyone else notice that the orcs looked like one of the bad guys from Silver Hawks in ROTK and The Hobbit? I'm a cartoon buff, so maybe no one else remembers it that detailed. Also, I thought some of the voice sounded the same, maybe it was the same animator.

04-06-2002, 11:31 PM	#13
Michael Baggins Pile O'Bones Join Date: Mar 2002 Location: Brooklyn Posts: 12	So I watched them all now. I thought the LOTR was good, I liked how they portrayed the people, but yes they cut out a lot. I thought the ROTK stank, but I thought that the voice for Gollum in that cartoon was perfect. I don't know why the maker of the LOTR would make the first two and not the third, that was odd. Did anyone else notice that the orcs looked like one of the bad guys from Silver Hawks in ROTK and The Hobbit? I'm a cartoon buff, so maybe no one else remembers it that detailed. Also, I thought some of the voice sounded the same, maybe it was the same animator.