Was the cast of characters perfect?

[Tigerlily Gamgee]

I read that thing about Dominic a while ago and it made me a little mad. For though I did not think his acting was as strong as some of the other cast members I don't think that a director of a film would EVER say that about one of his actors. I mean, he obviously cast him for a reason.<BR>As for who could've done better...<BR>That is not for me to judge because any actor has the ability to play a role wonderfully, so I am sure other people could've have done the roles. But a big part about being cast in a role is who you are as a person - and since no two people are alike in real life I believe that the cast was chosen for those who were most naturally like their characters (though from an article I read it seems that the cast all had bad "potty mouth" when not on the set )<BR>So, yes, I do think that they cast the perfect cast, or if there was someone better out there for a certain role they didn't make it to the auditions.