FOTR against TTT -- Analysis

[kittiewhirl1677]

Well, to be truthful, I have a number of vast opinions. <P>You see, FotR was definately very good. It had just the right amount of frightening events, and just the right amount of nice ones. <P>TTT was also very good, having a very different feel from the first movie. I think, that since TTT was the middle, it was not very very good, nor was it anywhere near to bad. <P>The reason why not many people like TTT, is probably because the book itself is mostly in war. I just finished reading it, and I know that the movie was very different. I think that if they didn't change what they did, it would have turned out to be a very bad movie.<P>TTT was not really supposed to be perfect. I mean, PJ probably tried to make it as good as he could, but face it. You can't make an okay book turn into a brilliant movie. I mean, you can, but I just think that if you decided to change that much of the book's story to make a perfect movie, it wouldn't be LOTR anymore. <P>The second book, truthfully, was not my favorite. I'm at the beginning of the third book currently, and it already seems very exciting - my kind of book! I hope they don't try to twist the storyline of the book for the RotK, because if they don't it will turn out to be a great movie.<P>Okay, I'll stop my boring talk now.<P>Chao!<BR>-Maya