Halbarad? **SPOILERS**

[samrohan]

The man in the background indeed looks like Faramir and the caves look like the Henneth Annun set. <P>I however would like to see Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli being followed by the rangers through the paths of the Death as it would bring more credibility to the film. The book also describes how Gimli lags behind the others in the caves, this would not be the same if you lag behind twenty or behind two...<P>The rangers could not follow though the Paths without being with Aragorn, the spirits of the dead would probably not allow them to go through. It is only because Aragorn is who he is that they are tolerated in that miserable and dead place.<P>How does Aragorn get the baner from Arwen with the Tree and the stars if they are not given to him by the Sons of Elrond and the rangers. He has to get them as he unleashes the baner upon the hill and summons the dead to follow him down to the river and take over the pirates.