ROTK Minor Change Wishlist - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Orofaniel · 12-19-2003, 07:51 AM

My wish list:<UL TYPE=SQUARE><LI>Saruman- I definitely think that Saruman should have been a part of RotK. It's a bit "odd" when a "major" character as him disappear in the last movie when he has had a big part in the two first movies. (My opinion though.) I also think he's a great character....<LI>The Sourcing of the Shire- I love that chapter! I'm a bit disappointed that they didn't show it in the movie.<LI> The Houses of Healing- I think they should have a couple of short scenes with this as well. I think it was a bit weird that Faramir and Eowyn in the end of the movie (When Arwen and Aragorn kissed) just stood there, smiling. Why did they stand together? That's the question I would have asked if I hadn't read the books. <LI>The Mouth of Sauron- I was looking forwards to see the Mouth of Sauron. Instead I felt that the great "eye" was replacing him. <LI>Denethor- He should have thrown himself on the fire.<LI> Eowyn- While she fought with the Witch King she should have acted more "less-Shampoo-Commercial-like", if you know what I mean. While she said "I'm not a man, I'm a woman!" she waved with her hair in the wind, and I think it was a bit fake, and unlike the "book Eowyn".<LI>Legolas- He should really stop the "fake" jumps of his. He had one in TTT when he jumped up on the horse backwards...or something. This time he jumped on the Oliphaunt.....Geesh...<LI>Gollum- He should never create the small "conflict" between Frodo and Sam. He told Frodo that Sam wanted the ring....and the Lembas bread situation.<LI>Galadriel- That she didn't "introduce" the movie as she did in the first two movies. I also think that perhaps she should have said the lines in the end while they were showing a map.....But Frodo was alright... </UL>That is my wish list…it’s not that short either.Anyway, I think that the movies are good, and that the cast & crew have done a great job. I can’t really “complain” because I wouldn’t had done it better myself…

12-19-2003, 07:51 AM	#7
Orofaniel Mighty Mouse of Mordor Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Lands of the North, where no man can reach.... Posts: 823	<B>My wish list:</B><P><UL TYPE=SQUARE><LI><B>Saruman-</B> I definitely think that Saruman should have been a part of RotK. It's a bit "odd" when a "major" character as him disappear in the last movie when he has had a big part in the two first movies. (My opinion though.) I also think he's a great character....<P><LI><B>The Sourcing of the Shire-</B> I love that chapter! I'm a bit disappointed that they didn't show it in the movie.<P><LI> <B>The Houses of Healing-</B> I think they should have a couple of short scenes with this as well. I think it was a bit weird that Faramir and Eowyn in the end of the movie (When Arwen and Aragorn kissed) just stood there, smiling. Why did they stand together? That's the question I would have asked if I hadn't read the books. <P><LI><B>The Mouth of Sauron- </B>I was looking forwards to see the Mouth of Sauron. Instead I felt that the great "eye" was replacing him. <P><LI><B>Denethor</B>- He should have thrown himself on the fire.<P><LI><B> Eowyn-</B> While she fought with the Witch King she should have acted more "less-Shampoo-Commercial-like", if you know what I mean. While she said "I'm not a man, I'm a woman!" she waved with her hair in the wind, and I think it was a bit fake, and unlike the "book Eowyn".<P><LI><B>Legolas-</B> He should really stop the "fake" jumps of his. He had one in TTT when he jumped up on the horse backwards...or something. This time he jumped on the Oliphaunt.....Geesh...<P><LI><B>Gollum-</B> He should never create the small "conflict" between Frodo and Sam. He told Frodo that Sam wanted the ring....and the Lembas bread situation.<P><LI><B>Galadriel- </B>That she didn't "introduce" the movie as she did in the first two movies. I also think that perhaps she should have said the lines in the end while they were showing a map.....But Frodo was alright... </UL><P>That is my wish list…it’s not that short either.<P>Anyway, I think that the movies are good, and that the cast & crew have done a great job. I can’t really “complain” because I wouldn’t had done it better myself… __________________ I lost my old sig...somehow....screams and shouts ..............What is this?- Now isn't this fun? >_< .....and yes, the jumping mouse is my new avatar. ^_^