Most Tragic Figure

[red]

Gollum is certainly a pathetic character but putting him on the list raises the whole question of whether he was evil from the start or undone by the One Ring. I lean toward the first view. -Turambar

Here, here! I must agree. How anyone can see anything good in that snivelling little fellow is beyond me! Started evil, ended evil and all evil in between. He'd never make my "tragic" list.

Actually, I don't think there is enough good in Turin for him to make my list either. He was too rash and prideful. Curse or no curse.

-réd