Mandos?

[Lady Eowyn]

<font face="Verdana"><table><TR><TD><FONT SIZE="1" face="Verdana, Helvetica, sans-serif">Wight
Posts: 131</TD><TD></TD></TR></TABLE>
Re: Mandos?

Well, good thing Feanor stayed there...I don't think it would have done any good to bring him back!!!

Hmm, now this made me wonder. How does Mandos choose wich elf can go back and which not?
Was it on how you lived your life and if you &quot;were good&quot; you were allowed to come back?

And he that breaks a thing to find out what it is has left the path of wisdom</p>

Its a matter of whos ready/

[zifnab]

Originally Posted by High Queen Galadriel

Its a matter of whos ready/

How does one become ready to leave the Halls of Waiting? And further more, be ready for what? The everyday task of simply living? Since they have left 'Man' in charge(?!), Valinor seems 'task' free.

Glorfindel - What do you think it was like for elves (after they were killed)living in Mandos? I mean I always look at Mandos the Valar as being pretty creepy. Not really the kind of guy I would want to be spending a couple of ages at his place if you know what I mean.

I always tried to 'not' compare it with legends like Hades or Hades Empire or in Christian (and other) earlier beliefs, Kabbalah and Purgatory (not quite hell, but more like waiting rooms). Souls wandering aimlessly around? Searching for any opportunity to emerge, once more into a physical body. I see The Halls of Mandos as mere enlightenment. A sort or pit stop on your journey through the valleys of enternity.

Must be a nice thought. To actually know where you're going.

[zifnab]

I also find it ironic that Glorfindel is asking about the Halls of Mandos, when after that fierce Balrog battle, you had a 'short' vacation among it. So...how was it? Did you have to take your shoes of before entering.

To be honest that would be a good thread. What's da Halls like?! Clean the dust of your HomE volumes and add alittle imagination and a dash of emotion.

It's always a pleasure to post here on the 'downs.