Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Child of the 7th Age
But Yavanna, if he saw the tough and brave side of Hobbits, why did he still feel that the only way to keep them safe was to isolate them totally from Men? It just seems like more of the same old isolationist thinking.
|
To expand upon this question, I would like to ask what is the evidence/hint to Aragorn's
supposed extremist decision to exclude Men from the Shire?
I think it poor logic to exclude Men or Dwarves. Wouldn't that sever relations to Gondor? To Aragorn? I don't remeber the exact page that Aragorn says this (but I think it's in Homeward Bound in ROTK) doesn't he hint on coming to the shire himself? or vice-versa?
08-24-2004, 04:01 PM
Threaded Mode