All made up?

[Morsul the Dark]

yes I have always thought Middle-Earth was far too...detailed perhaps?

lines of kings histories of legends languages written languages. culturesw fully developped.

but most importantly Tolkien did not know the full tale to some of the charactors he did not know what happened to the entwives or the blue wizards...if Tolkien fully created this world wouldnt he have known?

One problem I have is that the whole world of Middle Earth is too 'coherent', it doesn't feel 'made up'

this has bothered me as well...