Gandalf Vs. The Witch King - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

the phantom · 01-04-2005, 06:04 PM

Here's how the Witch King's power was handled in the movie.

1) Aragorn chases him away by waving a branch around and yelling. Witch King's apparent power: low

2) Gandalf is thrown on the ground and has his staff broken and looks scared. Witch King's apparent power: very high

3) A hobbit cuts his leg and he kneels down for ten minutes and waits for Eowyn to stab him in the head. Witch King's apparent power: low

A bit inconsistent, eh?

The remedy....

1) Have the wraiths retreat more quickly when Aragorn comes, then have him explain to the hobbits that they figured their work was pretty much done since they had stabbed Frodo.

2) I didn't mind this scene too much. The WK had to be big and bad and this scene made him look it.

3) Explain that Merry's sword is the nastiest anti-Witch King blade in the world.

01-04-2005, 06:04 PM	#10
the phantom Beloved Shadow Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: The Stadium Posts: 5,971	Here's how the Witch King's power was handled in the movie. 1) Aragorn chases him away by waving a branch around and yelling. Witch King's apparent power: low 2) Gandalf is thrown on the ground and has his staff broken and looks scared. Witch King's apparent power: very high 3) A hobbit cuts his leg and he kneels down for ten minutes and waits for Eowyn to stab him in the head. Witch King's apparent power: low A bit inconsistent, eh? The remedy.... 1) Have the wraiths retreat more quickly when Aragorn comes, then have him explain to the hobbits that they figured their work was pretty much done since they had stabbed Frodo. 2) I didn't mind this scene too much. The WK had to be big and bad and this scene made him look it. 3) Explain that Merry's sword is the nastiest anti-Witch King blade in the world. __________________ the phantom has posted. This thread is now important.